============================================================
OPERA A — REGIMEN_A EXECUTION ENGINE
Ars Generalis Applied — Principial Evaluation System
Version: 1.0.0-OPERA-A-FULL
Status: PROPOSED / FULL ENGINE / CANONICAL TARGET
Scope: deterministic qualitative evaluation of Absolute Dignities under contraction
Authority: TENET A / TENET T / TENET K / TENET E / AREPO A
Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY
Class: OPERA
============================================================
<!-- LOCAL_SECTION_INDEX_START -->
## LOCAL SECTION INDEX
Scope: local anchors within this artifact only. No cross-artifact links are introduced here.
- [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-purpose)
- [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-control-principle)
- [MODEL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-model)
- [I. REGIME ORDER LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-i-regime-order-law)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule)
- [RATIONALE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rationale)
- [II. INPUT CONTRACT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-ii-input-contract)
- [MANDATORY CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-mandatory-conditions)
- [III. STAGE I — BCD CORE EVALUATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-iii-stage-i-bcd-core-evaluation)
- [SYNTHESIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-synthesis)
- [FIELD:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-field)
- [BCD_STABILITY STATES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-bcd-stability-states)
- [GLOBAL EFFECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-global-effect)
- [IV. INHERITANCE GATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-iv-inheritance-gate)
- [IF PARTIAL / FRACTURED:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-if-partial-fractured)
- [IF STABLE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-if-stable)
- [V. STAGE II — DERIVED EVALUATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-v-stage-ii-derived-evaluation)
- [INHERITANCE APPLICATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-inheritance-application)
- [INHERITANCE RULES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-inheritance-rules)
- [VI. GLOBAL SYNTHESIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-vi-global-synthesis)
- [CONVERTIBILITY_STATUS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-convertibility-status)
- [VII. CORE EVALUATION AXES (ALL DIGNITIES)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-vii-core-evaluation-axes-all-dignities)
- [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-presence-mode)
- [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect)
- [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-correlative-profile)
- [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-attribution-mode)
- [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-distortion-flags)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-2)
- [VIII. T-MEDIATED ENGINE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-viii-t-mediated-engine)
- [EXTENDED T](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-extended-t)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-3)
- [IX. Q-SUPPORT ENGINE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-ix-q-support-engine)
- [EXTENDED SUPPORT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-extended-support)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-4)
- [X. SUBJECT BINDING LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-x-subject-binding-law)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-5)
- [XI. SUPPORT DEPTH](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xi-support-depth)
- [MULTI-PATH](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-multi-path)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-6)
- [XII. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xii-failure-conditions)
- [XIII. OUTPUT STRUCTURE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xiii-output-structure)
- [XIV. INTERPRETIVE FUNCTION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xiv-interpretive-function)
- [XV. SYSTEM ALIGNMENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xv-system-alignment)
- [TENET A:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-tenet-a)
- [AREPO A:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-arepo-a)
- [OPERA A:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-opera-a)
- [ROTAS A:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rotas-a)
- [SATOR A:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-sator-a)
- [XVI. SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xvi-summary)
- [CLOSURE RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-closure-rule)
- [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-class-opera)
- [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-purpose-2)
- [PATCH PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-principle)
- [PATCH-01 — ACT GENERATION LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-01-act-generation-law)
- [ACT GENERATION LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-act-generation-law)
- [INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-interpretation)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-7)
- [CONSTRAINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-constraint)
- [PATCH-02 — AGENT GROUNDING LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-02-agent-grounding-law)
- [AGENT GROUNDING LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-agent-grounding-law)
- [INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-interpretation-2)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-8)
- [CONSTRAINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-constraint-2)
- [PATCH-03 — FULL CIRCLE CLOSURE LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-03-full-circle-closure-law)
- [FULL CIRCLE CLOSURE LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-full-circle-closure-law)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-9)
- [MEANING](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-meaning)
- [CONSTRAINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-constraint-3)
- [PATCH-04 — CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY CHECK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-04-circular-consistency-check)
- [CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY CHECK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-circular-consistency-check)
- [CHECK 1:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-check-1)
- [CHECK 2:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-check-2)
- [FORMAL SCHEMA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-formal-schema)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-10)
- [PATCH-05 — NEW DISTORTION FLAG](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-05-new-distortion-flag)
- [CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-circular-inconsistency)
- [EXAMPLES OF USE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-examples-of-use)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-11)
- [PATCH-06 — VALIDITY CONSEQUENCES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-06-validity-consequences)
- [VALIDITY CONSEQUENCES OF CIRCULAR FAILURE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-validity-consequences-of-circular-failure)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-12)
- [PATCH-07 — RELATION TO BCD INHERITANCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-07-relation-to-bcd-inheritance)
- [RELATION TO INHERITANCE LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-relation-to-inheritance-law)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-13)
- [CONSTRAINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-constraint-4)
- [PATCH-08 — OUTPUT INTEGRATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-08-output-integration)
- [CIRCULAR_VALIDATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-circular-validation)
- [ACT_SOURCE_STATUS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-act-source-status)
- [AGENT_TARGET_STATUS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-agent-target-status)
- [CIRCULAR_CLOSURE_STATUS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-circular-closure-status)
- [CIRCULAR_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-circular-flags)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-14)
- [PATCH-09 — DOWNSTREAM CONSEQUENCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-09-downstream-consequence)
- [DOWNSTREAM CONSEQUENCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-downstream-consequence)
- [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-15)
- [PATCH SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-summary)
<!-- LOCAL_SECTION_INDEX_END -->
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-purpose"></a>
PURPOSE
============================================================
OPERA A defines the lawful execution system for evaluating
Absolute Dignities (A) under contracted conditions.
It provides:
• deterministic principial evaluation
• structured qualitative outputs (no scoring)
• doctrinally consistent contraction reading
• dependency-ordered dignity evaluation
• compatibility with AREPO admissibility
• structured outputs for SATOR mediation
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-control-principle"></a>
CONTROL PRINCIPLE
------------------------------------------------------------
OPERA A does not evaluate “absolute truth in itself”.
OPERA A evaluates:
how Absolute Dignities appear under contraction
on a bound subject through lawful structure.
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-model"></a>
MODEL
------------------------------------------------------------
RULE-STRUCTURED QUALITATIVE EVALUATION
• discrete states
• explicit rules
• no numeric scoring
• no analogy-based inference
• no hidden heuristics
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-i-regime-order-law"></a>
I. REGIME ORDER LAW
============================================================
Absolute Dignities are evaluated in strict order:
STAGE I — CORE FIELD (BCD)
B — Bonitas
C — Magnitudo
D — Duratio
STAGE II — DERIVED FIELD (EFGHIK)
E — Potestas
F — Sapientia
G — Voluntas
H — Virtus
I — Veritas
K — Gloria
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
No evaluation of EFGHIK is structurally valid
before BCD_FIELD is established.
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rationale"></a>
RATIONALE
------------------------------------------------------------
BCD is the minimal differentiated field required to express A
without collapse into undifferentiated singularity.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-ii-input-contract"></a>
II. INPUT CONTRACT
============================================================
A_INPUT := {
SUBJECT_BINDING,
Q_SUPPORT,
T_SUPPORT,
VALIDITY_STATE,
PATH_TYPE
}
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-mandatory-conditions"></a>
MANDATORY CONDITIONS
------------------------------------------------------------
1. TENET A bound
2. AREPO A admitted
3. SUBJECT bound via TENET K
4. Q-min present:
Q-C, Q-E, Q-G
5. T-ground present:
T-B, T-C, T-D
Failure → BLOCK
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-iii-stage-i-bcd-core-evaluation"></a>
III. STAGE I — BCD CORE EVALUATION
============================================================
Execute:
B_RESULT := OPERA A(B)
C_RESULT := OPERA A(C)
D_RESULT := OPERA A(D)
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-synthesis"></a>
SYNTHESIS
------------------------------------------------------------
BCD_FIELD := {
B_RESULT,
C_RESULT,
D_RESULT,
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-field"></a>
FIELD:
{
BCD_STABILITY,
BCD_CONVERTIBILITY,
BCD_CORRELATIVE_STATE,
BCD_DISTORTION_PROFILE
}
}
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-bcd-stability-states"></a>
BCD_STABILITY STATES
------------------------------------------------------------
• STABLE
• PARTIAL
• FRACTURED
• COLLAPSED
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-global-effect"></a>
GLOBAL EFFECT
------------------------------------------------------------
A_FIELD_STATUS :=
• VIABLE
• LIMITED
• UNSTABLE
• INVALID
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-iv-inheritance-gate"></a>
IV. INHERITANCE GATE
============================================================
IF BCD_STABILITY = COLLAPSED:
→ OPERA A TERMINATES
→ GLOBAL VALIDITY = BLOCKED
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-if-partial-fractured"></a>
IF PARTIAL / FRACTURED:
→ Derived evaluation allowed with constraints
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-if-stable"></a>
IF STABLE:
→ Full evaluation allowed
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-v-stage-ii-derived-evaluation"></a>
V. STAGE II — DERIVED EVALUATION
============================================================
Execute:
E_RESULT := OPERA A(E)
F_RESULT := OPERA A(F)
G_RESULT := OPERA A(G)
H_RESULT := OPERA A(H)
I_RESULT := OPERA A(I)
K_RESULT := OPERA A(K)
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-inheritance-application"></a>
INHERITANCE APPLICATION
------------------------------------------------------------
Each Dx ∈ {E..K} must:
• read BCD_FIELD
• inherit constraints
• apply local evaluation
• reconcile both
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-inheritance-rules"></a>
INHERITANCE RULES
------------------------------------------------------------
BCD_STABLE → full range allowed
BCD_PARTIAL → capped evaluation
BCD_FRACTURED → degraded evaluation
BCD_COLLAPSED → blocked
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-vi-global-synthesis"></a>
VI. GLOBAL SYNTHESIS
============================================================
A_RESULT := {
BCD_FIELD,
DERIVED_RESULTS,
GLOBAL
}
------------------------------------------------------------
GLOBAL := {
CONVERTIBILITY_STATUS,
SUPPORT_DEPTH,
ATTRIBUTION_PROFILE,
VALIDITY_STATE
}
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-convertibility-status"></a>
CONVERTIBILITY_STATUS
------------------------------------------------------------
Derived from BCD + EFGHIK:
• NEAR_INTEGRAL (rare)
• STABLE_CONTRACTED
• PARTIAL
• FRAGMENTED
• BROKEN
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-vii-core-evaluation-axes-all-dignities"></a>
VII. CORE EVALUATION AXES (ALL DIGNITIES)
============================================================
Each dignity must produce:
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-presence-mode"></a>
PRESENCE_MODE:
STRONG | MODERATE | WEAK | DEFORMED | ABSENT
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect"></a>
CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:
NEAR_INTEGRAL | STABLE_CONTRACTED | PARTIAL |
FRAGMENTED | BROKEN
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-correlative-profile"></a>
CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:
BALANCED | AGENT_DOMINANT | PATIENT_DOMINANT |
ACT_DOMINANT | INCOMPLETE
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-attribution-mode"></a>
ATTRIBUTION_MODE:
PROPER | APPROPRIATED | MISATTRIBUTED
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-distortion-flags"></a>
DISTORTION_FLAGS:
{ ... }
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-2"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
No dignity may omit any axis.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-viii-t-mediated-engine"></a>
VIII. T-MEDIATED ENGINE
============================================================
All evaluation must pass through T:
T-B — Difference
T-C — Concordance
T-D — Contrariety
Required for all dignities.
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-extended-t"></a>
EXTENDED T
------------------------------------------------------------
T-E — Beginning
T-F — Middle
T-G — End
T-H — Majority
T-I — Equality
T-K — Minority
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-3"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
T-D has veto power over false coherence.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-ix-q-support-engine"></a>
IX. Q-SUPPORT ENGINE
============================================================
Minimum required:
Q-C — what is it?
Q-E — why is it so?
Q-G — what quality is claimed?
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-extended-support"></a>
EXTENDED SUPPORT
------------------------------------------------------------
Q-D — from what?
Q-F — how much?
Q-K1 — how?
Q-K2 — through what?
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-4"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
Without Q-min:
→ degrade or BLOCK
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-x-subject-binding-law"></a>
X. SUBJECT BINDING LAW
============================================================
All evaluation must bind subject via TENET K:
B — God
C — Angel
D — Heaven
E — Human
F — Imago
G — Animal
H — Vegetal
I — Elemental
K — Instrumental
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-5"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
If subject cannot be bound:
→ SUBJECT_UNBOUND
→ degrade or BLOCK
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xi-support-depth"></a>
XI. SUPPORT DEPTH
============================================================
Default:
SUPPORT_DEPTH = SINGLE_PATH
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-multi-path"></a>
MULTI-PATH
------------------------------------------------------------
Only if:
• Q expansion present
• T reinforcement present
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-6"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
Support depth must be explicitly declared.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xii-failure-conditions"></a>
XII. FAILURE CONDITIONS
============================================================
BLOCK if:
• no subject binding
• no Q-min support
• BCD_COLLAPSED
• dominant contradiction ignored
------------------------------------------------------------
DEGRADE if:
• partial support
• asymmetry unresolved
• attribution unstable
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xiii-output-structure"></a>
XIII. OUTPUT STRUCTURE
============================================================
A_RESULT := {
DIGNITY_MAP: {
B: B_RESULT,
C: C_RESULT,
D: D_RESULT,
E: E_RESULT,
F: F_RESULT,
G: G_RESULT,
H: H_RESULT,
I: I_RESULT,
K: K_RESULT
},
BCD_FIELD: {
BCD_STABILITY,
BCD_CONVERTIBILITY,
BCD_CORRELATIVE_STATE,
BCD_DISTORTION_PROFILE
},
GLOBAL: {
CONVERTIBILITY_STATUS,
SUPPORT_DEPTH,
ATTRIBUTION_PROFILE,
VALIDITY_STATE
}
}
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xiv-interpretive-function"></a>
XIV. INTERPRETIVE FUNCTION
============================================================
OPERA A governs:
• principial evaluation of contracted A
• detection of structural coherence
• detection of distortion and contradiction
• lawful expansion from core to derived dignities
• preparation for downstream OPERAE
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xv-system-alignment"></a>
XV. SYSTEM ALIGNMENT
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-tenet-a"></a>
TENET A:
preserves principial invariance
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-arepo-a"></a>
AREPO A:
governs admissibility
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-opera-a"></a>
OPERA A:
executes principial evaluation
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rotas-a"></a>
ROTAS A:
provides structural display
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-sator-a"></a>
SATOR A:
mediates output
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-xvi-summary"></a>
XVI. SUMMARY
============================================================
OPERA A is:
a deterministic symbolic constraint evaluator
operating over qualitative discrete states
with explicit structural rules
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-closure-rule"></a>
CLOSURE RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
No principial reading is valid unless:
BCD stabilizes,
inheritance is respected,
and all dignity evaluations remain
structurally consistent with that field.
============================================================
END OF OPERA A
============================================================
============================================================
PATCH BLOCK — OPERA A CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY LAW
Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Validation Patch
Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-CIRCULAR-CONSISTENCY-PATCH
Status: PROPOSED / NON-DESTRUCTIVE PATCH BLOCK
Scope: cyclic validation of dignity coherence through ACT and AGENT closure
Authority: OPERA A / TENET A / TENET T
Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-class-opera"></a>
Class: OPERA
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-purpose-2"></a>
PURPOSE
------------------------------------------------------------
This patch adds a circular validation layer to OPERA A.
It does NOT replace:
• BCD priority
• BCD→EFGHIK inheritance
• local dignity evaluation
• T-mediated evaluation
• Q-min support requirements
It DOES add:
• cyclic consistency checking
• act-source validation
• agent-target validation
• full-circle principial closure control
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-principle"></a>
PATCH PRINCIPLE
------------------------------------------------------------
A dignity is not fully validated merely because it appears
locally coherent.
It must also be coherent with:
• the triad of which it is the act
• the triad of which it is the agent
Thus OPERA A gains a second-order validation surface:
local validity
+
inherited validity
+
circular validity
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-01-act-generation-law"></a>
PATCH-01 — ACT GENERATION LAW
============================================================
Add to OPERA A:
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-act-generation-law"></a>
ACT GENERATION LAW
------------------------------------------------------------
The following derived dignities are read as acts of prior triads:
E = ACT(BCD)
F = ACT(CDE)
G = ACT(DEF)
H = ACT(EFG)
I = ACT(FGH)
K = ACT(GHI)
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-interpretation"></a>
INTERPRETATION
------------------------------------------------------------
This means:
• Potestas is not evaluated as isolated power
but as the act issuing from Bonitas, Magnitudo,
and Duratio
• Sapientia is not evaluated as isolated wisdom
but as the act issuing from CDE
• and so forth through the full chain
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-7"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
No dignity in EFGHIK may receive a strong reading if the triad
from which it is generated cannot lawfully sustain that act.
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-constraint"></a>
CONSTRAINT
------------------------------------------------------------
This law refines but does not replace ordinary local evaluation.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-02-agent-grounding-law"></a>
PATCH-02 — AGENT GROUNDING LAW
============================================================
Add to OPERA A:
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-agent-grounding-law"></a>
AGENT GROUNDING LAW
------------------------------------------------------------
The following core dignities are read as agents of later triads:
B = AGENT(HIK)
C = AGENT(IKB)
D = AGENT(KBC)
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-interpretation-2"></a>
INTERPRETATION
------------------------------------------------------------
This means:
• Bonitas must remain compatible with the later field
constituted by Virtus, Veritas, Gloria
• Magnitudo must remain compatible with IKB
• Duratio must remain compatible with KBC
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-8"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
BCD is not only prior cause-field.
BCD is also validated retroactively by later principial closure.
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-constraint-2"></a>
CONSTRAINT
------------------------------------------------------------
This does not erase BCD primacy.
It introduces retroactive validation, not retroactive reversal.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-03-full-circle-closure-law"></a>
PATCH-03 — FULL CIRCLE CLOSURE LAW
============================================================
Add to OPERA A:
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-full-circle-closure-law"></a>
FULL CIRCLE CLOSURE LAW
------------------------------------------------------------
The A-field must be readable as a cyclic principial closure.
Minimal circular articulation:
BCD → E → F → G → H → I → K → BCD
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-9"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
After full OPERA A execution, the system must check whether
the evaluated dignity-field forms a lawfully coherent cycle.
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-meaning"></a>
MEANING
------------------------------------------------------------
A result may be:
• locally coherent
• inheritedly admissible
• yet circularly inconsistent
Such a result is not invalidated absolutely,
but it must be flagged and possibly degraded.
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-constraint-3"></a>
CONSTRAINT
------------------------------------------------------------
Circular closure is a validation layer,
not a separate execution engine.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-04-circular-consistency-check"></a>
PATCH-04 — CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY CHECK
============================================================
Add to OPERA A final validation phase:
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-circular-consistency-check"></a>
CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY CHECK
------------------------------------------------------------
For each dignity D:
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-check-1"></a>
CHECK 1:
consistency with its ACT source triad
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-check-2"></a>
CHECK 2:
consistency with its AGENT target triad
when such target relation is defined
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-formal-schema"></a>
FORMAL SCHEMA
------------------------------------------------------------
For derived dignities:
CONSISTENT_ACT(Dx) :=
Dx is structurally compatible with source_triad(Dx)
For retro-grounding core dignities:
CONSISTENT_AGENT(Dx) :=
Dx is structurally compatible with target_triad(Dx)
Full circular consistency:
CIRCULAR_OK :=
∀ relevant D:
CONSISTENT_ACT(D)
∧
CONSISTENT_AGENT(D) where applicable
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-10"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
This check occurs after:
• local dignity evaluation
• BCD synthesis
• inheritance application
• global result composition
It is a late validation layer.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-05-new-distortion-flag"></a>
PATCH-05 — NEW DISTORTION FLAG
============================================================
Add to OPERA A distortion system:
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-circular-inconsistency"></a>
CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY
------------------------------------------------------------
Definition:
assigned when a dignity is locally plausible
but structurally inconsistent with:
• its ACT source triad
• its AGENT target triad
• or the full circular closure of the A-field
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-examples-of-use"></a>
EXAMPLES OF USE
------------------------------------------------------------
1. F appears strong locally,
but CDE cannot lawfully generate it
→ CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY
2. GHI cannot lawfully sustain K as evaluated
→ CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY
3. HIK does not support B as agent
→ CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY on B-field closure
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-11"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
This flag must be explicit.
Silent circular failure is forbidden.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-06-validity-consequences"></a>
PATCH-06 — VALIDITY CONSEQUENCES
============================================================
Add to OPERA A:
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-validity-consequences-of-circular-failure"></a>
VALIDITY CONSEQUENCES OF CIRCULAR FAILURE
------------------------------------------------------------
If circular inconsistency is minor and local:
• keep result admissible
• degrade strength
• attach flag
If circular inconsistency is repeated or load-bearing:
• degrade GLOBAL validity
• reduce downstream reuse readiness
If circular inconsistency breaks the full field:
• mark result as:
A_FIELD_CIRCULAR_FAILURE
• block combinatory downstream reuse unless explicitly
overridden by later repair or reformulation
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-12"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
Circular inconsistency does not always force total block.
But it always prevents silent “clean field” presentation.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-07-relation-to-bcd-inheritance"></a>
PATCH-07 — RELATION TO BCD INHERITANCE
============================================================
Add clarification:
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-relation-to-inheritance-law"></a>
RELATION TO INHERITANCE LAW
------------------------------------------------------------
BCD inheritance remains primary.
Circular consistency does not abolish:
BCD → EFGHIK priority
Instead:
BCD priority establishes the field
circular consistency validates its full closure
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-13"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
Validation order remains:
1. local dignity evaluation
2. BCD field synthesis
3. inheritance application to EFGHIK
4. global synthesis
5. circular consistency check
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-constraint-4"></a>
CONSTRAINT
------------------------------------------------------------
Circular closure must not be used to justify skipping BCD-first
evaluation.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-08-output-integration"></a>
PATCH-08 — OUTPUT INTEGRATION
============================================================
Add to OPERA A global output object:
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-circular-validation"></a>
CIRCULAR_VALIDATION:
------------------------------------------------------------
{
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-act-source-status"></a>
ACT_SOURCE_STATUS:
<COHERENT | PARTIAL | FAILED>
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-agent-target-status"></a>
AGENT_TARGET_STATUS:
<COHERENT | PARTIAL | FAILED>
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-circular-closure-status"></a>
CIRCULAR_CLOSURE_STATUS:
<CLOSED | WEAKLY_CLOSED | OPEN | FAILED>
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-circular-flags"></a>
CIRCULAR_FLAGS:
{ ... }
}
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-14"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
If this field is present, SATOR A must preserve it in
self-binding explanation when downstream reuse is relevant.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-09-downstream-consequence"></a>
PATCH-09 — DOWNSTREAM CONSEQUENCE
============================================================
Add to OPERA A reuse discipline:
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-downstream-consequence"></a>
DOWNSTREAM CONSEQUENCE
------------------------------------------------------------
A-result is combinatorially cleaner when:
• BCD is stable
• inheritance is lawful
• circular closure is closed or weakly closed
A-result is not combinatorially ready when:
• circular closure is open or failed
• CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY is load-bearing
------------------------------------------------------------
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-rule-15"></a>
RULE
------------------------------------------------------------
D / TERTIA / QUARTA reuse must not silently ignore circular
failure.
============================================================
<a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-a-executionmechanism-patch-summary"></a>
PATCH SUMMARY
============================================================
This patch adds to OPERA A:
• ACT generation law
• AGENT grounding law
• full-circle closure law
• circular consistency check
• CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY distortion flag
• explicit validity consequences
• output integration for cyclic validation
Net effect:
OPERA A ceases to be only a linear dependency engine
and becomes a cyclic principial validation engine.
This sharpens:
• anti-drift control
• coherence checking
• reuse discipline
• Llullian structural fidelity
============================================================
END OF PATCH BLOCK — OPERA A CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY LAW
============================================================