02_STACK_A/OPERA_Ax_ExecutionMechanism.md

Page Sections

LLULLIANA_PROTOCOL_SURFACE: line 1
Version: 1.1.0-OPERA-A-AX-DUPLEX line 12
Status: PROPOSED / FULL ENGINE / CANONICAL TARGET line 13
Scope: extended predicate-column carrier execution over the full duplex ROTA A contract line 14
Authority: TENET A / AREPO A line 15
Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY line 16
Class: OPERA line 18
ALIAS BINDING: line 19
LIBER_X_ALIGNMENT: line 32
ATQS_OPERA_DISCIPLINE: line 45
ROTA_A_DUPLEX_AX_EXECUTION_PROFILE: line 56
## LOCAL SECTION INDEX line 103
Scope: local anchors within this artifact only. No cross-artifact links are introduced here. line 105
PURPOSE line 870
OPERA A AX defines the lawful execution system for evaluating line 872
admitted off-diagonal predication carriers under contracted line 873
conditions. Absolute dignity identities remain read-only. line 874
It provides: line 877
CONTROL PRINCIPLE line 890
OPERA A does not evaluate “absolute truth in itself”. line 892
OPERA A evaluates: line 895
The ABS dignity locus remains an L0 reference and is never the line 900
unit executed by OPERA. line 901
MODEL line 907
RULE-STRUCTURED QUALITATIVE EVALUATION line 909
I. REGIME ORDER LAW line 922
Contracted predicate summaries are derived in strict order from line 926
RULE line 946
No evaluation of EFGHIK is structurally valid line 948
before BCD_FIELD is established. line 949
RATIONALE line 955
BCD is the minimal differentiated field required to express A line 957
without collapse into undifferentiated singularity. line 958
II. INPUT CONTRACT line 965
carrier predicates or must be validated against them. L0 is line 987
reference-only and emits no carrier state. FULL_72 evaluates all line 988
in-scope direction as NOT_SELECTED. line 990
The valid mode/level matrix is exhaustive: line 992
Every other mode/level combination is BLOCKED by AREPO A. line 999
MANDATORY CONDITIONS line 1005
1. TENET A bound line 1007
2. AREPO A admitted line 1008
3. PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID resolved under TENET A line 1009
4. Q-min present: line 1013
5. T-ground present: line 1016
Failure → BLOCK line 1019
derive the compatibility summaries: line 1031
These are contracted-locus summaries. Primary BCD work consists line 1040
NOT_SELECTED and never infers them from a reverse. line 1043
SYNTHESIS line 1049
BCD_STABILITY STATES line 1072
GLOBAL EFFECT line 1084
IV. INHERITANCE GATE line 1098
IF PARTIAL / FRACTURED: line 1108
IF STABLE: line 1114
These are contracted-locus summaries. Stage II evaluates the line 1142
admitted subset of the remaining 66 ordered carriers across 33 line 1143
INHERITANCE APPLICATION line 1150
INHERITANCE RULES line 1164
VI. GLOBAL SYNTHESIS line 1180
CONVERTIBILITY_STATUS line 1202
Derived from BCD + EFGHIK: line 1205
VII. CARRIER EVALUATION DIMENSIONS line 1218
Every evaluated predication carrier must resolve all five line 1221
non-executable. Contracted-locus summaries are derived views. line 1223
RULE line 1256
No evaluated carrier may omit any evaluation dimension. line 1258
VIII. T-MEDIATED ENGINE line 1265
All evaluation must pass through T: line 1269
Required for every selected predication carrier. line 1275
EXTENDED T line 1281
RULE line 1295
T-D has veto power over false coherence. line 1297
IX. Q-SUPPORT ENGINE line 1304
Minimum required: line 1308
EXTENDED SUPPORT line 1318
RULE line 1330
Without Q-min: line 1333
X. SUBJECT BINDING LAW line 1342
Every carrier evaluation must resolve PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID under line 1346

LLULLIANA_PROTOCOL_SURFACE: version: 1.0.0-A-PRINCIPIAL-OPERA-AX posture: EMBEDDED_LOCAL_FACET / DORMANT_UNLESS_SELECTED role: supply the admitted extended principial evaluation variant to OPERA_LLULLIANA without impersonating the general hermeneutic OPERA authority: OPERA A AX remains its own local execution authority activation: requires explicit Llulliana routing, AREPO admission, variant selection, and composition trace non_coupling: OPERA A AX remains independently reusable and does not call Stack Llulliana by default transitive_consumers: D / F / G / H / I expose the effective OPERA A AX ancestry when used ============================================================ OPERA A — REGIMEN_A EXECUTION ENGINE Ars Generalis Applied — Principial Evaluation System Version: 1.1.0-OPERA-A-AX-DUPLEX Status: PROPOSED / FULL ENGINE / CANONICAL TARGET Scope: extended predicate-column carrier execution over the full duplex ROTA A contract Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY Class: OPERA ALIAS BINDING: Alias_Artifact: ./ALIAS_A Alias_Class: AGLA / ALIAS Canonical_Invocation: OPERA A AX Invocation_Surfaces: - OPERA A AX - OPERA AX - A_AX - AX Alias_Law: routing only; no execution, admissibility, doctrine, structure, or mediation authority transfers from alias. ============================================================ LIBER_X_ALIGNMENT: patch_id: LIBER_X_ATQS_MAIN_STACK_ALIGNMENT source_liber: _00_Documentation/00_Sources/01_CONTEXT_Development_Only/CODEX_DEV/LIBER_X_ARS_BREVIS_VERSIO_LATINA_SCHOLASTICA_COMMENTATA.md notation_liber: 90_STACK_LIBER/LIBRI X/LIBER X - NOTATIONIS STYLATAE ATQS caput_rosetta: CAPUT B/C/D ars_brevis_locus: Alphabet, First Figure, Definitions agu_dataset_lane: AGU Dataset 001 and Dataset 002 target_stack: A class_role: OPERA alignment_note: A and T share the alphabet/figures/definitions Rosetta layer; A remains principial dignity regimen. authority_rule: LIBER X, CAPUT, and AGU datasets inform parsing, trace, and source literacy; they do not govern this class artifact. searchability_rule: preserve plain A/T/Q/S and B-K ASCII mirrors for citation, storage, parsing, and deployment. ATQS_OPERA_DISCIPLINE: notation_source: 90_STACK_LIBER/LIBRI X/LIBER X - NOTATIONIS STYLATAE ATQS effect: OPERA may accept optional human sigils and styled notation only by normalizing them to canonical regimen/operator structure before execution. normalization_examples: !B -> A_FORMAL(B); :B -> T_FORMAL(B); ?B -> Q_FORMAL(B); ;B -> S_FORMAL(B); #B -> ALL_REGIMENS(B) across admitted lanes only. local_slot_rule: context-derived, OPERA-derived, or qualified LIBER_EX_OPERAE content may fill LOCAL_APPLIED_PREPROCESSED slots only with provenance and expiry/discardability. rosetta_source_trace: enabled: OPTIONAL_WHERE_OUTPUT_SCHEMA_ACCEPTS_TRACE fields: [liber_x_source, caput_rosetta, agu_dataset_lane, normalized_input, ascii_mirror, local_slot_status] prohibition: no glyph, sigil, punctuation, CAPUT, or LIBER source creates OPERA authority by itself. ============================================================ ROTA_A_DUPLEX_AX_EXECUTION_PROFILE: profile_version: 1.0.0-A-DUPLEX effective_date: 2026-08-14 status: PROPOSED_CANONICAL_TARGET / EXTENDED OPERA VARIANT prerequisite: explicit AREPO A binding to IDX-A-OPERA-AX and ROTA_A_DUPLEX_STRUCTURAL_PROFILE coverage: all 9 absolute loci / all 9 contracted loci / 9 homologous axes / 72 ordered predication carriers dignity_local_rule: each legacy A_x template is a reusable predicate-column evaluator, not a unary truth store or an executable ABS locus evaluator_signature: EVAL_PREDICATE(predicate_token=j, principial_subject_id=i, external_subject_binding?, context_id, execution_id) where i != j evaluator_output: one independently traced ROTA_A.PRED.i.j result plus a derived contracted-locus summary when requested matrix_rule: carrier state is keyed by [carrier_id, context_id, execution_id]; it must not be reduced to nine predicate slots or an unversioned ordered pair contraction_levels: L0 absolute reference / L1 subalternate principial predication / L2 singular applied contraction execution_modes: [REFERENCE_ONLY, FULL_72, SELECTED_SET] l0_rule: REFERENCE_ONLY only; L0 never invokes OPERA, never evaluates an ABS locus or homologous AXIS, and never emits CARRIER_RESULTS l1_l2_rule: every L1/L2 execution unit is exactly one admitted ROTA_A.PRED.i.j carrier with i != j; unary OPERA, diagonal PRED.i.i, ABS execution, and AXIS execution are forbidden mode_matrix: REFERENCE_ONLY permits L0 citation/inspection only; FULL_72 evaluates all 72 off-diagonal PRED(i,j) carriers at L1/L2; SELECTED_SET evaluates only admitted off-diagonal carriers at L1/L2 and marks all omitted in-scope directions NOT_SELECTED subject_rule: PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID is required for L1/L2; EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING is optional at L1 and mandatory with provenance at L2 legacy_subject_binding: any later SUBJECT_BINDING field is a compatibility view only and cannot replace the two typed subject fields above surface_rule: output CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM and SURFACE_REALIZATION_CONSTRAINTS as distinct fields; SATOR alone may emit a contextual SURFACE_REALIZATION with realization trace and may not assume mechanical inflection D_variant_rule: Durans is the duplex CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM at CON_D, never SURFACE_REALIZATION or an executable predication-carrier result; Durabilis remains a traceable lexical legacy form and no equivalence is inferred legacy_input_supersession: every later A_INPUT or BCD_INPUT block in this concatenated suite is a local partial view and inherits DUPLEX_SCHEMA_VERSION / OPERA_ARTIFACT_ID / CONTEXT_ID / EXECUTION_ID / CONTRACTION_LEVEL / PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID / selected carrier refs / conditional EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING legacy_result_supersession: every predicate-column payload is subordinate to A_DUPLEX_AX_RESULT; every primary result is keyed by [carrier_id, context_id, execution_id], while every X_RESULT name is permitted only as Summary(ROTA_A.CON.X) derived through BY_PREDICATE over those composite keys template_wrapper: EVAL_PREDICATE(j,i,external_x?,context_id,execution_id) -> CARRIER_RESULTS[[ROTA_A.PRED.i.j,context_id,execution_id]] template_result_law: every *_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD block below is subordinate to the composite-key result envelope and is never an autonomous result store legacy_template_name_law: labels OPERA A(B) through OPERA A(K) below identify predicate-column components only; none is a unary execution or result identity evaluation_dimension_law: the five legacy analytic lenses are EVALUATION_DIMENSIONS; ROTA_A.AXIS.* remains structural and non-executable pair_key_law: 36 stateless unordered keys each group exactly two reverse carriers; no pair key is a camera or result predicate_column_lexicon: B: { ABSOLUTE_NOUN: Bonitas, LEXICAL_LEMMA: Bonus, CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM: Bonum } C: { ABSOLUTE_NOUN: Magnitudo, LEXICAL_LEMMA: Magnus, CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM: Magnum } D: { ABSOLUTE_NOUN: Duratio, LEXICAL_LEMMA: Durabilis, CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM: Durans, LEGACY_NON_EQUIVALENCE: true } E: { ABSOLUTE_NOUN: Potestas, LEXICAL_LEMMA: Potens, CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM: Potens } F: { ABSOLUTE_NOUN: Sapientia, LEXICAL_LEMMA: Sapiens, CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM: Sapiens } G: { ABSOLUTE_NOUN: Voluntas, LEXICAL_LEMMA: Volens, CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM: Volens } H: { ABSOLUTE_NOUN: Virtus, LEXICAL_LEMMA: Virtuosus, CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM: Virtuosum } I: { ABSOLUTE_NOUN: Veritas, LEXICAL_LEMMA: Verus, CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM: Verum } K: { ABSOLUTE_NOUN: Gloria, LEXICAL_LEMMA: Gloriosus, CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM: Gloriosum } lexical_surface_boundary: CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM is a stable metalinguistic label and never execution evidence; SURFACE_REALIZATION is a separate SATOR-owned contextual field carrying realization trace bcd_summary_law: BCD states are computed only in Summary(ROTA_A.CON.B), Summary(ROTA_A.CON.C), and Summary(ROTA_A.CON.D), each derived by BY_PREDICATE over evaluated composite carrier keys inheritance_target_law: BCD inheritance conditions Eval(ROTA_A.CON.E..ROTA_A.CON.K) only; it never conditions, produces, or mutates ABS loci common_result_envelope: [CARRIER_RESULTS, PAIR_VIEWS, CONTRACTED_LOCUS_SUMMARY_MAP, CIRCULAR_VALIDATION] pair_view_law: PAIR_VIEWS: derived view over CARRIER_RESULTS contracted_summary_map_law: CONTRACTED_LOCUS_SUMMARY_MAP: derived BY_PREDICATE view over primary carrier results circular_validation_view_law: CIRCULAR_VALIDATION: derived validation view over CARRIER_RESULTS circular_payload_law: every CARRIER_RESULTS payload carries CIRCULAR_CHECK_REF; CIRCULAR_VALIDATION.GLOBAL_CYCLE_CHECK nests ACT_SOURCE_STATUS, AGENT_TARGET_STATUS, CIRCULAR_CLOSURE_STATUS, and CIRCULAR_FLAGS prohibition: this variant cannot enlarge ROTAS topology, materialize Stack G camerae, or promote a rendered connection to a result ============================================================  ## LOCAL SECTION INDEX Scope: local anchors within this artifact only. No cross-artifact links are introduced here. - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle) - [MODEL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-model) - [I. REGIME ORDER LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-regime-order-law) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule) - [RATIONALE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rationale) - [II. INPUT CONTRACT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-contract) - [MANDATORY CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-conditions) - [III. STAGE I — BCD CORE EVALUATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-stage-i-bcd-core-evaluation) - [SYNTHESIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-synthesis) - [FIELD:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-field) - [BCD_STABILITY STATES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bcd-stability-states) - [GLOBAL EFFECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-global-effect) - [IV. INHERITANCE GATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-inheritance-gate) - [IF PARTIAL / FRACTURED:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-if-partial-fractured) - [IF STABLE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-if-stable) - [V. STAGE II — EXTENDED CONTRACTED EVALUATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-stage-ii-derived-evaluation) - [INHERITANCE APPLICATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-inheritance-application) - [INHERITANCE RULES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-inheritance-rules) - [VI. GLOBAL SYNTHESIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-global-synthesis) - [CONVERTIBILITY_STATUS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-status) - [VII. CARRIER EVALUATION DIMENSIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-core-evaluation-axes-all-dignities) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-2) - [VIII. T-MEDIATED ENGINE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-t-mediated-engine) - [EXTENDED T](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-extended-t) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-3) - [IX. Q-SUPPORT ENGINE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-q-support-engine) - [EXTENDED SUPPORT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-extended-support) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-4) - [X. SUBJECT BINDING LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-subject-binding-law) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-5) - [XI. SUPPORT DEPTH](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-support-depth) - [MULTI-PATH](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-multi-path) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-6) - [XII. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-failure-conditions) - [XIII. OUTPUT STRUCTURE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-output-structure) - [XIV. INTERPRETIVE FUNCTION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-interpretive-function) - [XV. SYSTEM ALIGNMENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-system-alignment) - [TENET A:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-tenet-a) - [AREPO A:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-arepo-a) - [OPERA A:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-opera-a) - [ROTAS A:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rotas-a) - [SATOR A:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-sator-a) - [XVI. SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-summary) - [CLOSURE RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-closure-rule) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-2) - [PATCH PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-principle) - [PATCH-01 — ACT GENERATION LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-01-act-generation-law) - [ACT GENERATION LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-act-generation-law) - [INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-7) - [CONSTRAINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint) - [PATCH-02 — AGENT GROUNDING LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-02-agent-grounding-law) - [AGENT GROUNDING LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-agent-grounding-law) - [INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-2) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-8) - [CONSTRAINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint-2) - [PATCH-03 — FULL CIRCLE CLOSURE LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-03-full-circle-closure-law) - [FULL CIRCLE CLOSURE LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-full-circle-closure-law) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-9) - [MEANING](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-meaning) - [CONSTRAINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint-3) - [PATCH-04 — CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY CHECK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-04-circular-consistency-check) - [CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY CHECK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-circular-consistency-check) - [CHECK 1:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-check-1) - [CHECK 2:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-check-2) - [FORMAL SCHEMA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-formal-schema) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-10) - [PATCH-05 — NEW DISTORTION FLAG](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-05-new-distortion-flag) - [CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-circular-inconsistency) - [EXAMPLES OF USE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-examples-of-use) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-11) - [PATCH-06 — VALIDITY CONSEQUENCES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-06-validity-consequences) - [VALIDITY CONSEQUENCES OF CIRCULAR FAILURE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-validity-consequences-of-circular-failure) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-12) - [PATCH-07 — RELATION TO BCD INHERITANCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-07-relation-to-bcd-inheritance) - [RELATION TO INHERITANCE LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-relation-to-inheritance-law) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-13) - [CONSTRAINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint-4) - [PATCH-08 — OUTPUT INTEGRATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-08-output-integration) - [CIRCULAR_VALIDATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-circular-validation) - [ACT_SOURCE_STATUS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-act-source-status) - [AGENT_TARGET_STATUS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-agent-target-status) - [CIRCULAR_CLOSURE_STATUS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-circular-closure-status) - [CIRCULAR_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-circular-flags) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-14) - [PATCH-09 — DOWNSTREAM CONSEQUENCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-09-downstream-consequence) - [DOWNSTREAM CONSEQUENCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-downstream-consequence) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-15) - [PATCH SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-summary) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-2) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-3) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-2) - [I. DOCTRINAL BASIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis) - [INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-3) - [II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements) - [MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions) - [III. BCD EVALUATION STRUCTURE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-bcd-evaluation-structure) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-16) - [IV. CORE SYNTHESIS — BCD FIELD](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-core-synthesis-bcd-field) - [IV.1 — BCD_STABILITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-1-bcd-stability) - [STABLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-stable) - [PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-partial) - [FRACTURED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-fractured) - [COLLAPSED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-collapsed) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-17) - [IV.2 — BCD_CONVERTIBILITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-2-bcd-convertibility) - [COHERENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-coherent) - [PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-partial-2) - [DISJOINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-disjoint) - [BROKEN](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-broken) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-18) - [IV.3 — BCD_CORRELATIVE_STATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-3-bcd-correlative-state) - [INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-4) - [IV.4 — BCD_DISTORTION_PROFILE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-4-bcd-distortion-profile) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-19) - [V. INHERITANCE LAW (CRITICAL)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-inheritance-law-critical) - [RULES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rules) - [CONSTRAINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint-5) - [VI. T-MEDIATED INTEGRATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-t-mediated-integration) - [T-B (DIFFERENCE)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-b-difference) - [T-C (CONCORDANCE)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-c-concordance) - [T-D (CONTRARIETY)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-d-contrariety) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-20) - [VII. Q-MIN SUPPORT FOR BCD](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-q-min-support-for-bcd) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-21) - [VIII. OUTPUT STRUCTURE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-output-structure) - [B:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-b) - [C:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-c) - [D:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-d) - [FIELD:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-field-2) - [BCD_STABILITY:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bcd-stability) - [BCD_CONVERTIBILITY:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bcd-convertibility) - [BCD_CORRELATIVE_STATE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bcd-correlative-state) - [BCD_DISTORTION_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bcd-distortion-profile) - [GLOBAL_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-global-effect-2) - [A_FIELD_STATUS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-a-field-status) - [EFGHIK_PERMISSION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-efghik-permission) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-22) - [IX. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-failure-conditions) - [DEGRADATION CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-degradation-conditions) - [X. INTERPRETIVE SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-interpretive-summary) - [OPERA A(BCD):](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-opera-a-bcd) - [CLOSURE RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-closure-rule-2) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-4) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-5) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-4) - [I. GLOBAL INHERITANCE MATRIX](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-global-inheritance-matrix) - [S = STABLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-s-stable) - [S = PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-s-partial) - [S = FRACTURED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-s-fractured) - [S = COLLAPSED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-s-collapsed) - [II. CORE DEPENDENCY MAPPINGS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-core-dependency-mappings) - [E — POTESTAS (Power)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-e-potestas-power) - [F — SAPIENTIA (Wisdom / Mediation)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-f-sapientia-wisdom-mediation) - [G — VOLUNTAS (Will)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-g-voluntas-will) - [H — VIRTUS (Virtue)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-h-virtus-virtue) - [I — VERITAS (Truth)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-veritas-truth) - [K — GLORIA (Glory)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-k-gloria-glory) - [III. CONVERTIBILITY PROPAGATION LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-convertibility-propagation-law) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-30) - [IV. DISTORTION PROPAGATION LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-distortion-propagation-law) - [RULES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rules-3) - [PRIORITY RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-priority-rule) - [V. ATTRIBUTION INHERITANCE LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-attribution-inheritance-law) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-31) - [VI. CORRELATIVE INHERITANCE LAW](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-correlative-inheritance-law) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-32) - [VII. EXCEPTION CLAUSE (LOCAL STABILIZATION)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-exception-clause-local-stabilization) - [CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-conditions) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-33) - [CONSTRAINT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint-7) - [VIII. OUTPUT INTEGRATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-output-integration) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-34) - [IX. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-failure-conditions-3) - [DEGRADATION CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-degradation-conditions-3) - [X. SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-summary) - [CLOSURE RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-closure-rule-4) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-5) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-6) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-5) - [I. DOCTRINAL BASIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-3) - [BOUNDARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary) - [II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-3) - [MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-3) - [BONITAS EVALUATION UNIT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bonitas-evaluation-unit) - [III. BONITAS — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-bonitas-canonical-doctrinal-seed) - [EXECUTION INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation) - [IV. EVALUATION AXES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes) - [V. AXIS 1 — PRESENCE MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode) - [V.1 — STRONG](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong) - [V.2 — MODERATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate) - [V.3 — WEAK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak) - [V.4 — DEFORMED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed) - [V.5 — ABSENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent) - [VI. AXIS 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect) - [VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral) - [VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted) - [VI.3 — PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial) - [VI.4 — FRAGMENTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented) - [VI.5 — BROKEN](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-35) - [VII. AXIS 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile) - [MINIMAL MODEL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model) - [VII.1 — BALANCED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-1-balanced) - [VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-2-agent-dominant) - [VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-3-patient-dominant) - [VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-4-act-dominant) - [VII.5 — INCOMPLETE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-5-incomplete) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-36) - [VIII. AXIS 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode) - [VIII.1 — PROPER](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper) - [VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated) - [VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-37) - [IX. AXIS 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags) - [FLAG LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic) - [X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR BONITAS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-bonitas) - [T-B — DIFFERENCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-b-difference-3) - [T-C — CONCORDANCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-c-concordance-3) - [T-D — CONTRARIETY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-d-contrariety-3) - [T-E — BEGINNING](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-e-beginning) - [T-F — MIDDLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-f-middle) - [T-G — END](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-g-end) - [T-H — MAJORITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-h-majority) - [T-I — EQUALITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-i-equality) - [T-K — MINORITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-k-minority) - [XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS FOR BONITAS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-for-bonitas) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-38) - [INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-7) - [XII. DECISION LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-39) - [XIII. BONITAS RESULT OBJECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-bonitas-result-object) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-2) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-2) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-2) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-2) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-2) - [T_SUPPORT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-support) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification) - [JUSTIFICATION RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-rule) - [XIV. EXAMPLE — ABSTRACT TEMPLATE ONLY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-abstract-template-only) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-2) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-3) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-3) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-3) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-3) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-3) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-2) - [EXAMPLE STATUS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status) - [XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions) - [BLOCK-PRESSURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-block-pressure-conditions) - [XVI. REUSE READINESS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness) - [CONDITIONAL REUSE (FLAGGED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-conditional-reuse-flagged) - [UNSAFE REUSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-unsafe-reuse) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-40) - [XVII. GLOBAL INTEGRATION INTO A_RESULT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-global-integration-into-a-result) - [INTEGRATION RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-integration-rule) - [INTER-DIGNITY CONSTRAINTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-inter-dignity-constraints) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-41) - [SYSTEM CONSEQUENCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-system-consequence) - [XVIII. SUPPORT DEPTH FORMALIZATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-support-depth-formalization) - [XVIII.1 — SINGLE_PATH](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-1-single-path) - [XVIII.2 — MINIMALLY_CROSS_SUPPORTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-2-minimally-cross-supported) - [XVIII.3 — MULTI_PATH_REINFORCED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-3-multi-path-reinforced) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-42) - [XIX. AREPO A HANDOFF CONTRACT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xix-arepo-a-handoff-contract) - [HANDOFF STRUCTURE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-handoff-structure) - [AREPO A RESPONSIBILITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-arepo-a-responsibility) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-43) - [FEEDBACK LOOP](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-feedback-loop) - [XX. CROSS-DIGNITY CONSISTENCY RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xx-cross-dignity-consistency-rule) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-44) - [PROHIBITION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-prohibition) - [INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-8) - [XXI. SATOR INTERFACE CONTRACT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xxi-sator-interface-contract) - [REQUIRED EXPOSURE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-required-exposure) - [OPTIONAL EXPOSURE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-optional-exposure) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-45) - [COMPATIBILITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-compatibility) - [XXII. CLOSURE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xxii-closure) - [FINAL RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-final-rule) - [SYSTEM POSITION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-system-position) - [CLOSURE CONDITION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-closure-condition) - [“how does Magnitudo appear here under contraction?”](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-how-does-magnitudo-appear-here-under-contraction) - [contracted Magnitudo only.](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-contracted-magnitudo-only) - [evaluate Magnitudo under contraction on bound referent x](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-evaluate-magnitudo-under-contraction-on-bound-referent-x) - [• amplification destroys proportion](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-amplification-destroys-proportion) - [No numeric score is permitted.](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-no-numeric-score-is-permitted) - [Magnitudo is not lawfully present in the current reading.](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-magnitudo-is-not-lawfully-present-in-the-current-reading) - [the correlative/attribution state.](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-the-correlative-attribution-state) - [But it materially conditions strength and reuse readiness.](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-but-it-materially-conditions-strength-and-reuse-readiness) - [• or BLOCKED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-or-blocked) - [enlargement is asserted without structural basis](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-enlargement-is-asserted-without-structural-basis) - [strengthens WEAK / FRAGMENTED readings](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-strengthens-weak-fragmented-readings) - [Q-F helps prevent quantity-confusion](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-q-f-helps-prevent-quantity-confusion) - [without explicit justification.](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-without-explicit-justification) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-3) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-4) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-4) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-4) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-4) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-4) - [T_SUPPORT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-support-2) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-3) - [• non-numeric](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-non-numeric) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-4) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-5) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-5) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-5) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-5) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-5) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-4) - [This example illustrates output form, not a canon judgment.](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-this-example-illustrates-output-form-not-a-canon-judgment) - [• QUANTITY_CONFUSION is uncorrected and central](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-quantity-confusion-is-uncorrected-and-central) - [Silent reuse is forbidden.](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-silent-reuse-is-forbidden) - [but do not yet require full multi-dignity orchestration.](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-but-do-not-yet-require-full-multi-dignity-orchestration) - [• composable into future master OPERA A](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-composable-into-future-master-opera-a) - [• numeric scoring](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-numeric-scoring) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-6) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-7) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-6) - [I. DOCTRINAL BASIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-4) - [BOUNDARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-2) - [II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-4) - [MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-4) - [DURATIO EVALUATION UNIT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-duratio-evaluation-unit) - [III. DURATIO — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-duratio-canonical-doctrinal-seed) - [EXECUTION INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-2) - [IV. EVALUATION AXES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-2) - [V. AXIS 1 — PRESENCE MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-2) - [V.1 — STRONG](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-2) - [V.2 — MODERATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-2) - [V.3 — WEAK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-2) - [V.4 — DEFORMED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-2) - [V.5 — ABSENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-2) - [VI. AXIS 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-2) - [VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-2) - [VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-2) - [VI.3 — PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-2) - [VI.4 — FRAGMENTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-2) - [VI.5 — BROKEN](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-2) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-46) - [VII. AXIS 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-2) - [MINIMAL MODEL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-2) - [VIII. AXIS 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-2) - [VIII.1 — PROPER](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-2) - [VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-2) - [VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-2) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-47) - [IX. AXIS 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-2) - [FLAG LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-2) - [X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR DURATIO](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-duratio) - [XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-48) - [XII. DECISION LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-2) - [XIII. DURATIO RESULT OBJECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-duratio-result-object) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-5) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-6) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-6) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-6) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-6) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-6) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-5) - [XIV. EXAMPLE — TEMPLATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-template) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-6) - [XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-2) - [XVI. REUSE READINESS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-2) - [XVII. FUNCTION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function) - [XVIII. SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-7) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-8) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-7) - [I. DOCTRINAL BASIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-5) - [BOUNDARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-3) - [II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-5) - [MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-5) - [POTESTAS EVALUATION UNIT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-potestas-evaluation-unit) - [III. POTESTAS — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-potestas-canonical-doctrinal-seed) - [EXECUTION INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-3) - [IV. EVALUATION AXES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-3) - [V. AXIS 1 — PRESENCE MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-3) - [V.1 — STRONG](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-3) - [V.2 — MODERATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-3) - [V.3 — WEAK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-3) - [V.4 — DEFORMED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-3) - [V.5 — ABSENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-3) - [VI. AXIS 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-3) - [VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-3) - [VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-3) - [VI.3 — PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-3) - [VI.4 — FRAGMENTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-3) - [VI.5 — BROKEN](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-3) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-49) - [VII. AXIS 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-3) - [MINIMAL MODEL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-3) - [VIII. AXIS 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-3) - [VIII.1 — PROPER](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-3) - [VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-3) - [VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-3) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-50) - [IX. AXIS 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-3) - [FLAG LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-3) - [X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR POTESTAS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-potestas) - [XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-2) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-51) - [XII. DECISION LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-3) - [XIII. POTESTAS RESULT OBJECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-potestas-result-object) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-6) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-7) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-7) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-7) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-7) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-7) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-7) - [XIV. EXAMPLE — TEMPLATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-template-2) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-8) - [XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-3) - [XVI. REUSE READINESS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-3) - [XVII. FUNCTION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function-2) - [XVIII. SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary-2) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-8) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-9) - [CRITICAL CORRECTION (v0.2.0)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-critical-correction-v0-2-0) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-8) - [I. DOCTRINAL BASIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-6) - [BOUNDARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-4) - [II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-6) - [MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-6) - [SAPIENTIA EVALUATION UNIT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-sapientia-evaluation-unit) - [III. SAPIENTIA — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-sapientia-canonical-doctrinal-seed) - [EXECUTION INTERPRETATION (CORRECTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-corrected) - [IV. EVALUATION AXES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-4) - [V. AXIS 1 — PRESENCE MODE (CORRECTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-corrected) - [V.1 — STRONG](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-4) - [V.2 — MODERATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-4) - [V.3 — WEAK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-4) - [V.4 — DEFORMED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-4) - [V.5 — ABSENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-4) - [VI. AXIS 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT (CORRECTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-corrected) - [NEAR_INTEGRAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-near-integral) - [STABLE_CONTRACTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-stable-contracted) - [PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-partial-5) - [FRAGMENTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-fragmented) - [BROKEN](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-broken-3) - [VII. AXIS 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE (CORRECTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-corrected) - [BALANCED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-balanced) - [ACT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-act-dominant) - [AGENT_DOMINANT / PATIENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-agent-dominant-patient-dominant) - [INCOMPLETE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-incomplete) - [VIII. AXIS 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-4) - [PROPER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-proper) - [APPROPRIATED:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-appropriated) - [MISATTRIBUTED:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-misattributed) - [IX. AXIS 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS (CORRECTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-corrected) - [FLAG LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-4) - [X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR SAPIENTIA (CORRECTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-sapientia-corrected) - [T-F — MIDDLE (PRIMARY AXIS)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-f-middle-primary-axis) - [T-C — CONCORDANCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-c-concordance-4) - [T-D — CONTRARIETY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-d-contrariety-4) - [T-G — END](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-g-end-2) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-52) - [XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS (ADJUSTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-adjusted) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-53) - [XII. DECISION LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-4) - [XIII. SAPIENTIA RESULT OBJECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-sapientia-result-object) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-7) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-8) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-8) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-8) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-8) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-8) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-9) - [XIV. EXAMPLE — TEMPLATE (CORRECTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-template-corrected) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-10) - [EXAMPLE STATUS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status-2) - [XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS (CORRECTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-corrected) - [XVI. FUNCTION (CORRECTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-function-corrected) - [XVII. SUMMARY (CORRECTED)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-summary-corrected) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-9) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-10) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-9) - [I. DOCTRINAL BASIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-7) - [BOUNDARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-5) - [II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-7) - [MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-7) - [VOLUNTAS EVALUATION UNIT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-voluntas-evaluation-unit) - [III. VOLUNTAS — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-voluntas-canonical-doctrinal-seed) - [EXECUTION INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-4) - [IV. EVALUATION AXES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-5) - [V. AXIS 1 — PRESENCE MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-4) - [V.1 — STRONG](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-5) - [V.2 — MODERATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-5) - [V.3 — WEAK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-5) - [V.4 — DEFORMED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-5) - [V.5 — ABSENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-5) - [VI. AXIS 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-4) - [VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-4) - [VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-4) - [VI.3 — PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-4) - [VI.4 — FRAGMENTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-4) - [VI.5 — BROKEN](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-4) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-54) - [VII. AXIS 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-4) - [MINIMAL MODEL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-4) - [VII.1 — BALANCED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-1-balanced-2) - [VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-2-agent-dominant-2) - [VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-3-patient-dominant-2) - [VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-4-act-dominant-2) - [VII.5 — INCOMPLETE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-5-incomplete-2) - [VIII. AXIS 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-5) - [VIII.1 — PROPER](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-4) - [VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-4) - [VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-4) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-55) - [IX. AXIS 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-4) - [FLAG LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-5) - [X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR VOLUNTAS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-voluntas) - [XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-3) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-56) - [XII. DECISION LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-5) - [XIII. VOLUNTAS RESULT OBJECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-voluntas-result-object) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-8) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-9) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-9) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-9) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-9) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-9) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-11) - [XIV. EXAMPLE — TEMPLATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-template-3) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-12) - [EXAMPLE STATUS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status-3) - [XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-4) - [XVI. REUSE READINESS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-4) - [XVII. FUNCTION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function-3) - [XVIII. SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary-3) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-10) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-11) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-10) - [I. DOCTRINAL BASIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-8) - [SEMANTIC CLARIFICATION (NON-DOCTRINAL)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-semantic-clarification-non-doctrinal) - [BOUNDARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-6) - [II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-8) - [MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-8) - [VIRTUS EVALUATION UNIT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-virtus-evaluation-unit) - [III. VIRTUS — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-virtus-canonical-doctrinal-seed) - [EXECUTION INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-5) - [IV. EVALUATION AXES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-6) - [V. AXIS 1 — PRESENCE MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-5) - [V.1 — STRONG](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-6) - [V.2 — MODERATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-6) - [V.3 — WEAK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-6) - [V.4 — DEFORMED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-6) - [V.5 — ABSENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-6) - [VI. AXIS 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-5) - [VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-5) - [VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-5) - [VI.3 — PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-5) - [VI.4 — FRAGMENTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-5) - [VI.5 — BROKEN](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-5) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-57) - [VII. AXIS 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-5) - [MINIMAL MODEL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-5) - [VII.1 — BALANCED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-1-balanced-3) - [VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-2-agent-dominant-3) - [VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-3-patient-dominant-3) - [VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-4-act-dominant-3) - [VII.5 — INCOMPLETE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-5-incomplete-3) - [VIII. AXIS 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-6) - [VIII.1 — PROPER](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-5) - [VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-5) - [VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-5) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-58) - [IX. AXIS 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-5) - [FLAG LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-6) - [X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR VIRTUS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-virtus) - [XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-4) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-59) - [XII. DECISION LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-6) - [XIII. VIRTUS RESULT OBJECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-virtus-result-object) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-9) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-10) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-10) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-10) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-10) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-10) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-13) - [XIV. EXAMPLE — TEMPLATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-template-4) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-14) - [EXAMPLE STATUS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status-4) - [XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-5) - [XVI. REUSE READINESS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-5) - [XVII. FUNCTION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function-4) - [XVIII. SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary-4) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-11) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-12) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-11) - [I. DOCTRINAL BASIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-9) - [BOUNDARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-7) - [II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-9) - [MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-9) - [VERITAS EVALUATION UNIT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-veritas-evaluation-unit) - [III. VERITAS — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-veritas-canonical-doctrinal-seed) - [EXECUTION INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-6) - [IV. EVALUATION AXES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-7) - [V. AXIS 1 — PRESENCE MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-6) - [V.1 — STRONG](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-7) - [V.2 — MODERATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-7) - [V.3 — WEAK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-7) - [V.4 — DEFORMED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-7) - [V.5 — ABSENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-7) - [VI. AXIS 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-6) - [VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-6) - [VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-6) - [VI.3 — PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-6) - [VI.4 — FRAGMENTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-6) - [VI.5 — BROKEN](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-6) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-60) - [VII. AXIS 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-6) - [MINIMAL MODEL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-6) - [VII.1 — BALANCED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-1-balanced-4) - [VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-2-agent-dominant-4) - [VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-3-patient-dominant-4) - [VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-4-act-dominant-4) - [VII.5 — INCOMPLETE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-5-incomplete-4) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-61) - [VIII. AXIS 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-7) - [VIII.1 — PROPER](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-6) - [VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-6) - [VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-6) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-62) - [IX. AXIS 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-6) - [FLAG LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-7) - [X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR VERITAS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-veritas) - [T-B — DIFFERENCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-b-difference-4) - [T-C — CONCORDANCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-c-concordance-5) - [T-D — CONTRARIETY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-d-contrariety-5) - [T-E — BEGINNING](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-e-beginning-2) - [T-F — MIDDLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-f-middle-2) - [T-G — END](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-g-end-3) - [T-H — MAJORITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-h-majority-2) - [T-I — EQUALITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-i-equality-2) - [T-K — MINORITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-k-minority-2) - [XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS FOR VERITAS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-for-veritas) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-63) - [INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-9) - [XII. DECISION LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-7) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-64) - [XIII. VERITAS RESULT OBJECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-veritas-result-object) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-10) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-11) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-11) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-11) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-11) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-11) - [T_SUPPORT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-support-3) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-15) - [JUSTIFICATION RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-rule-2) - [XIV. EXAMPLE — ABSTRACT TEMPLATE ONLY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-abstract-template-only-2) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-11) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-12) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-12) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-12) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-12) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-12) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-16) - [EXAMPLE STATUS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status-5) - [XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-6) - [BLOCK-PRESSURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-block-pressure-conditions-2) - [XVI. REUSE READINESS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-6) - [REUSE WARNING](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-reuse-warning) - [XVII. FUNCTION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function-5) - [XVIII. SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary-5) - [Class: OPERA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-12) - [PURPOSE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-13) - [CONTROL PRINCIPLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-12) - [I. DOCTRINAL BASIS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-10) - [SEMANTIC CLARIFICATION (NON-DOCTRINAL)](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-semantic-clarification-non-doctrinal-2) - [BOUNDARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-8) - [II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-10) - [MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-10) - [GLORIA EVALUATION UNIT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-gloria-evaluation-unit) - [III. GLORIA — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-gloria-canonical-doctrinal-seed) - [EXECUTION INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-7) - [IV. EVALUATION AXES](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-8) - [V. AXIS 1 — PRESENCE MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-7) - [V.1 — STRONG](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-8) - [V.2 — MODERATE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-8) - [V.3 — WEAK](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-8) - [V.4 — DEFORMED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-8) - [V.5 — ABSENT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-8) - [VI. AXIS 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-7) - [VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-7) - [VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-7) - [VI.3 — PARTIAL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-7) - [VI.4 — FRAGMENTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-7) - [VI.5 — BROKEN](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-7) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-65) - [VII. AXIS 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-7) - [MINIMAL MODEL](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-7) - [VII.1 — BALANCED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-1-balanced-5) - [VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-2-agent-dominant-5) - [VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-3-patient-dominant-5) - [VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-4-act-dominant-5) - [VII.5 — INCOMPLETE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-5-incomplete-5) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-66) - [VIII. AXIS 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-8) - [VIII.1 — PROPER](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-7) - [VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-7) - [VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-7) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-67) - [IX. AXIS 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-7) - [FLAG LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-8) - [X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR GLORIA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-gloria) - [T-B — DIFFERENCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-b-difference-5) - [T-C — CONCORDANCE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-c-concordance-6) - [T-D — CONTRARIETY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-d-contrariety-6) - [T-E — BEGINNING](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-e-beginning-3) - [T-F — MIDDLE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-f-middle-3) - [T-G — END](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-g-end-4) - [T-H — MAJORITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-h-majority-3) - [T-I — EQUALITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-i-equality-3) - [T-K — MINORITY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-k-minority-3) - [XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS FOR GLORIA](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-for-gloria) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-68) - [INTERPRETATION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-10) - [XII. DECISION LOGIC](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-8) - [RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-69) - [XIII. GLORIA RESULT OBJECT](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-gloria-result-object) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-12) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-13) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-13) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-13) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-13) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-13) - [T_SUPPORT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-support-4) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-17) - [JUSTIFICATION RULE](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-rule-3) - [XIV. EXAMPLE — ABSTRACT TEMPLATE ONLY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-abstract-template-only-3) - [CARRIER:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-13) - [PRESENCE_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-14) - [CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-14) - [CORRELATIVE_PROFILE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-14) - [ATTRIBUTION_MODE:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-14) - [DISTORTION_FLAGS:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-14) - [JUSTIFICATION:](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-18) - [EXAMPLE STATUS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status-6) - [XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-7) - [BLOCK-PRESSURE CONDITIONS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-block-pressure-conditions-3) - [XVI. REUSE READINESS](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-7) - [REUSE WARNING](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-reuse-warning-2) - [XVII. FUNCTION](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function-6) - [XVIII. SUMMARY](#local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary-6)  <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ OPERA A AX defines the lawful execution system for evaluating admitted off-diagonal predication carriers under contracted conditions. Absolute dignity identities remain read-only. It provides: • deterministic principial evaluation • structured qualitative outputs (no scoring) • doctrinally consistent contraction reading • dependency-ordered carrier evaluation and locus aggregation • compatibility with AREPO admissibility • structured outputs for SATOR mediation ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ OPERA A does not evaluate “absolute truth in itself”. OPERA A evaluates: how one admitted principial subject token participates in a distinct contracted predicate through PRED(i,j), i != j. The ABS dignity locus remains an L0 reference and is never the unit executed by OPERA. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-model"></a> MODEL ------------------------------------------------------------ RULE-STRUCTURED QUALITATIVE EVALUATION • discrete states • explicit rules • no numeric scoring • no analogy-based inference • no hidden heuristics ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-regime-order-law"></a> I. REGIME ORDER LAW ============================================================ Contracted predicate summaries are derived in strict order from off-diagonal carrier evaluations; ABS loci remain reference-only: STAGE I — CORE FIELD (BCD) B — Bonitas C — Magnitudo D — Duratio STAGE II — EXTENDED CONTRACTED EVALUATION FIELD (EFGHIK) E — Potestas F — Sapientia G — Voluntas H — Virtus I — Veritas K — Gloria ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ No evaluation of EFGHIK is structurally valid before BCD_FIELD is established. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rationale"></a> RATIONALE ------------------------------------------------------------ BCD is the minimal differentiated field required to express A without collapse into undifferentiated singularity. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-contract"></a> II. INPUT CONTRACT ============================================================ A_INPUT := { DUPLEX_SCHEMA_VERSION, OPERA_ARTIFACT_ID: IDX-A-OPERA-AX, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, EXECUTION_MODE: REFERENCE_ONLY | FULL_72 | SELECTED_SET, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, SELECTED_CONTRACTED_LOCUS_REFS, SELECTED_PREDICATION_CARRIER_REFS, LEGACY_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } `SELECTED_CONTRACTED_LOCUS_REFS` is derived from the selected carrier predicates or must be validated against them. L0 is reference-only and emits no carrier state. FULL_72 evaluates all 72 off-diagonal carriers; SELECTED_SET records every omitted in-scope direction as NOT_SELECTED. The valid mode/level matrix is exhaustive: L0 -> REFERENCE_ONLY; no selected carrier refs and no result L1 -> FULL_72 | SELECTED_SET; PRED(i,j), i != j, only L2 -> FULL_72 | SELECTED_SET; PRED(i,j), i != j, only, with EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING and provenance Every other mode/level combination is BLOCKED by AREPO A. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-conditions"></a> MANDATORY CONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. TENET A bound 2. AREPO A admitted 3. PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID resolved under TENET A and, only for L2, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING classified through an admitted TENET K path where that substrate taxonomy applies 4. Q-min present: Q-C, Q-E, Q-G 5. T-ground present: T-B, T-C, T-D Failure → BLOCK ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-stage-i-bcd-core-evaluation"></a> III. STAGE I — BCD CORE EVALUATION ============================================================ After the six primary BCD carrier directions have been evaluated, derive the compatibility summaries: B_RESULT := Summary(ROTA_A.CON.B; BY_PREDICATE(ROTA_A.CON.B, evaluated composite carrier keys)) C_RESULT := Summary(ROTA_A.CON.C; BY_PREDICATE(ROTA_A.CON.C, evaluated composite carrier keys)) D_RESULT := Summary(ROTA_A.CON.D; BY_PREDICATE(ROTA_A.CON.D, evaluated composite carrier keys)) These are contracted-locus summaries. Primary BCD work consists of the six ordered carriers BC/CB, BD/DB, and CD/DC. Full mode evaluates all six; selected mode marks omitted directions NOT_SELECTED and never infers them from a reverse. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-synthesis"></a> SYNTHESIS ------------------------------------------------------------ BCD_FIELD := { B_RESULT, C_RESULT, D_RESULT, <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-field"></a> FIELD: { BCD_STABILITY, BCD_CONVERTIBILITY, BCD_CORRELATIVE_STATE, BCD_DISTORTION_PROFILE } } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bcd-stability-states"></a> BCD_STABILITY STATES ------------------------------------------------------------ • STABLE • PARTIAL • FRACTURED • COLLAPSED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-global-effect"></a> GLOBAL EFFECT ------------------------------------------------------------ A_FIELD_STATUS := • VIABLE • LIMITED • UNSTABLE • INVALID ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-inheritance-gate"></a> IV. INHERITANCE GATE ============================================================ IF BCD_STABILITY = COLLAPSED: → OPERA A TERMINATES → GLOBAL VALIDITY = BLOCKED <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-if-partial-fractured"></a> IF PARTIAL / FRACTURED: → Derived evaluation allowed with constraints <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-if-stable"></a> IF STABLE: → Full evaluation allowed ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-stage-ii-derived-evaluation"></a> V. STAGE II — EXTENDED CONTRACTED EVALUATION ============================================================ Derive, after executing the admitted PRED(i,j) carriers with i != j: E_RESULT := Summary(ROTA_A.CON.E; BY_PREDICATE(ROTA_A.CON.E, evaluated composite carrier keys)) F_RESULT := Summary(ROTA_A.CON.F; BY_PREDICATE(ROTA_A.CON.F, evaluated composite carrier keys)) G_RESULT := Summary(ROTA_A.CON.G; BY_PREDICATE(ROTA_A.CON.G, evaluated composite carrier keys)) H_RESULT := Summary(ROTA_A.CON.H; BY_PREDICATE(ROTA_A.CON.H, evaluated composite carrier keys)) I_RESULT := Summary(ROTA_A.CON.I; BY_PREDICATE(ROTA_A.CON.I, evaluated composite carrier keys)) K_RESULT := Summary(ROTA_A.CON.K; BY_PREDICATE(ROTA_A.CON.K, evaluated composite carrier keys)) These are contracted-locus summaries. Stage II evaluates the admitted subset of the remaining 66 ordered carriers across 33 pair keys; full duplex mode evaluates all 66. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-inheritance-application"></a> INHERITANCE APPLICATION ------------------------------------------------------------ Each Dx ∈ {E..K} must: • read BCD_FIELD • inherit constraints • apply local evaluation • reconcile both ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-inheritance-rules"></a> INHERITANCE RULES ------------------------------------------------------------ BCD_STABLE → full range allowed BCD_PARTIAL → capped evaluation BCD_FRACTURED → degraded evaluation BCD_COLLAPSED → blocked ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-global-synthesis"></a> VI. GLOBAL SYNTHESIS ============================================================ A_DUPLEX_AX_WORKING_SUMMARY := { BCD_FIELD, EXTENDED_CONTRACTED_RESULTS, CARRIER_RESULTS, GLOBAL } ------------------------------------------------------------ GLOBAL := { CONVERTIBILITY_STATUS, SUPPORT_DEPTH, ATTRIBUTION_PROFILE, VALIDITY_STATE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-status"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_STATUS ------------------------------------------------------------ Derived from BCD + EFGHIK: • NEAR_INTEGRAL (rare) • STABLE_CONTRACTED • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • BROKEN ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-core-evaluation-axes-all-dignities"></a> VII. CARRIER EVALUATION DIMENSIONS ============================================================ Every evaluated predication carrier must resolve all five evaluation dimensions below. `ROTA_A.AXIS.*` is structural and non-executable. Contracted-locus summaries are derived views. <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: STRONG | MODERATE | WEAK | DEFORMED | ABSENT <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: NEAR_INTEGRAL | STABLE_CONTRACTED | PARTIAL | FRAGMENTED | BROKEN <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: BALANCED | AGENT_DOMINANT | PATIENT_DOMINANT | ACT_DOMINANT | INCOMPLETE <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: PROPER | APPROPRIATED | MISATTRIBUTED <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ... } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-2"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ No evaluated carrier may omit any evaluation dimension. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-t-mediated-engine"></a> VIII. T-MEDIATED ENGINE ============================================================ All evaluation must pass through T: T-B — Difference T-C — Concordance T-D — Contrariety Required for every selected predication carrier. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-extended-t"></a> EXTENDED T ------------------------------------------------------------ T-E — Beginning T-F — Middle T-G — End T-H — Majority T-I — Equality T-K — Minority ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-3"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ T-D has veto power over false coherence. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-q-support-engine"></a> IX. Q-SUPPORT ENGINE ============================================================ Minimum required: Q-C — what is it? Q-E — why is it so? Q-G — what quality is claimed? ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-extended-support"></a> EXTENDED SUPPORT ------------------------------------------------------------ Q-D — from what? Q-F — how much? Q-K1 — how? Q-K2 — through what? ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-4"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Without Q-min: → degrade or BLOCK ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-subject-binding-law"></a> X. SUBJECT BINDING LAW ============================================================ Every carrier evaluation must resolve PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID under TENET A. L1 may stop there. L2 additionally requires a bounded EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING and provenance. When the selected domain uses Stack K substrate classes, that external binding is classified through an admitted TENET K path, for example: B — God C — Angel D — Heaven E — Human F — Imago G — Animal H — Vegetal I — Elemental K — Instrumental ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-5"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ If subject cannot be bound: → SUBJECT_UNBOUND → degrade or BLOCK ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-support-depth"></a> XI. SUPPORT DEPTH ============================================================ Default: SUPPORT_DEPTH = SINGLE_PATH ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-multi-path"></a> MULTI-PATH ------------------------------------------------------------ Only if: • Q expansion present • T reinforcement present ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-6"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Support depth must be explicitly declared. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-failure-conditions"></a> XII. FAILURE CONDITIONS ============================================================ BLOCK if: • PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID missing for L1/L2 • EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING or provenance missing for L2 • CONTEXT_ID or EXECUTION_ID missing for an executing result • AXIS_AS_PREDICATION • DIAGONAL_CARRIER_FORBIDDEN • PAIR_KEY_MISMATCH • ABSOLUTE_CONTRACTED_IDENTITY_COLLAPSE • no Q-min support • BCD_COLLAPSED • dominant contradiction ignored ------------------------------------------------------------ DEGRADE if: • partial support • asymmetry unresolved • attribution unstable ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-output-structure"></a> XIII. OUTPUT STRUCTURE ============================================================ DERIVED VIEW LAWS ------------------------------------------------------------ PAIR_VIEWS: derived view over CARRIER_RESULTS CONTRACTED_LOCUS_SUMMARY_MAP: derived BY_PREDICATE view over primary carrier results CIRCULAR_VALIDATION: derived validation view over CARRIER_RESULTS A_DUPLEX_AX_RESULT := { DERIVATION_LAWS: { PAIR_VIEWS: derived view over CARRIER_RESULTS CONTRACTED_LOCUS_SUMMARY_MAP: derived BY_PREDICATE view over primary carrier results CIRCULAR_VALIDATION: derived validation view over CARRIER_RESULTS }, EXECUTION_IDENTITY: { OPERA_ARTIFACT_ID: IDX-A-OPERA-AX, OPERA_VERSION, DUPLEX_SCHEMA_VERSION, EXECUTION_MODE, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, EXECUTED_SCOPE, AREPO_ADMISSION_REF, SATOR_MEDIATION_TARGET }, CARRIER_RESULTS: { [carrier_id, context_id, execution_id]: { CARRIER_ID, PAIR_KEY, DIRECTION: { SUBJECT_TOKEN, PREDICATE_TOKEN }, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, ABSOLUTE_SUBJECT_LOCUS_REF, CONTRACTED_PREDICATE_LOCUS_REF, CONTRACTED_CITATION_FORM, LEXICAL_LEMMA, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, RESULT_STATE, EVALUATION: { PRESENCE_MODE, CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT, CORRELATIVE_PROFILE, ATTRIBUTION_MODE, DISTORTION_FLAGS, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT }, EVIDENCE_TRACE, JUSTIFICATION, REUSE_STATE, SURFACE_REALIZATION_CONSTRAINTS, SURFACE_REALIZATION: null, SURFACE_REALIZATION_REF | NOT_REALIZED, AREPO_ADMISSION_REF, REVERSE_CARRIER_REF, REVERSE_RESULT_REF | NOT_EVALUATED, CIRCULAR_CHECK_REF } }, PAIR_VIEWS: { [pair_key]: { FORWARD_CARRIER_REF, FORWARD_RESULT_REF | NOT_EVALUATED, REVERSE_CARRIER_REF, REVERSE_RESULT_REF | NOT_EVALUATED, RECIPROCITY_STATUS } }, BY_SUBJECT: derived view over CARRIER_RESULTS, BY_PREDICATE: derived view over CARRIER_RESULTS, CONTRACTED_LOCUS_SUMMARY_MAP: { B: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.B), C: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.C), D: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.D), E: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.E), F: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.F), G: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.G), H: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.H), I: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.I), K: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.K) }, BCD_FIELD: { BCD_STABILITY, BCD_CONVERTIBILITY, BCD_CORRELATIVE_STATE, BCD_DISTORTION_PROFILE }, GLOBAL: { CONVERTIBILITY_STATUS, SUPPORT_DEPTH, ATTRIBUTION_PROFILE, VALIDITY_STATE }, CIRCULAR_VALIDATION: { CARRIER_CHECKS, RECIPROCAL_PAIR_CHECKS, CONTRACTED_LOCUS_AGGREGATE_CHECKS, GLOBAL_CYCLE_CHECK: { ACT_SOURCE_STATUS, AGENT_TARGET_STATUS, CIRCULAR_CLOSURE_STATUS, CIRCULAR_FLAGS } } } The legacy contracted-locus summary is a derived view only. It cannot overwrite or substitute the 72 independently keyed carrier states. PAIR_KEY(i,j) is a stateless unordered index for i != j. Exactly 36 keys exist; each groups PRED(i,j) and PRED(j,i), and none owns a camera, result, admission, or output identity. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-interpretive-function"></a> XIV. INTERPRETIVE FUNCTION ============================================================ OPERA A governs: • principial evaluation of contracted A • detection of structural coherence • detection of distortion and contradiction • lawful expansion from core to extended contracted evaluations • preparation for downstream OPERAE ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-system-alignment"></a> XV. SYSTEM ALIGNMENT ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-tenet-a"></a> TENET A: preserves principial invariance <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-arepo-a"></a> AREPO A: governs admissibility <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-opera-a"></a> OPERA A: executes principial evaluation <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rotas-a"></a> ROTAS A: provides duplex machine structure and empty carriers <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-sator-a"></a> SATOR A: mediates output ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-summary"></a> XVI. SUMMARY ============================================================ OPERA A is: a deterministic symbolic constraint evaluator operating over qualitative discrete states with explicit structural rules ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-closure-rule"></a> CLOSURE RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ No principial reading is valid unless: BCD stabilizes, inheritance is respected, and all contracted-locus summaries remain structurally consistent with that field. ============================================================ END OF OPERA A ============================================================ ============================================================ PATCH BLOCK — OPERA A CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY LAW Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Validation Patch Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-CIRCULAR-CONSISTENCY-PATCH Status: PROPOSED / NON-DESTRUCTIVE PATCH BLOCK Scope: cyclic validation of dignity coherence through ACT and AGENT closure Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-2"></a> PURPOSE ------------------------------------------------------------ This patch adds a circular validation layer to OPERA A. It does NOT replace: • BCD priority • BCD→EFGHIK inheritance • local carrier evaluation and derived contracted-locus aggregation • T-mediated evaluation • Q-min support requirements It DOES add: • cyclic consistency checking • act-source validation • agent-target validation • full-circle principial closure control ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-principle"></a> PATCH PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ A carrier result or contracted-locus aggregate is not fully validated merely because it appears locally coherent. It must also be coherent with: • the triad of which it is the act • the triad of which it is the agent Thus OPERA A gains a second-order validation surface: local validity + inherited validity + circular validity ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-01-act-generation-law"></a> PATCH-01 — ACT GENERATION LAW ============================================================ Add to OPERA A: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-act-generation-law"></a> ACT GENERATION LAW ------------------------------------------------------------ The following contracted evaluation aggregates depend on prior triads; no absolute dignity is derived by this rule: Eval(CON_E) = ACT_AGGREGATE(Eval(CON_B),Eval(CON_C),Eval(CON_D)) Eval(CON_F) = ACT_AGGREGATE(Eval(CON_C),Eval(CON_D),Eval(CON_E)) Eval(CON_G) = ACT_AGGREGATE(Eval(CON_D),Eval(CON_E),Eval(CON_F)) Eval(CON_H) = ACT_AGGREGATE(Eval(CON_E),Eval(CON_F),Eval(CON_G)) Eval(CON_I) = ACT_AGGREGATE(Eval(CON_F),Eval(CON_G),Eval(CON_H)) Eval(CON_K) = ACT_AGGREGATE(Eval(CON_G),Eval(CON_H),Eval(CON_I)) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation"></a> INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ This means that an admitted contracted evaluation for Potestas, Sapientia, and the following loci is checked against the specified prior aggregate. It does not make Potestas, Sapientia, or any other absolute dignity an output of BCD. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-7"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ No contracted EFGHIK evaluation may receive a strong reading if its dependency triad cannot lawfully sustain that act. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint"></a> CONSTRAINT ------------------------------------------------------------ This law refines but does not replace ordinary local evaluation. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-02-agent-grounding-law"></a> PATCH-02 — AGENT GROUNDING LAW ============================================================ Add to OPERA A: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-agent-grounding-law"></a> AGENT GROUNDING LAW ------------------------------------------------------------ The following core contracted aggregates are retro-checked against later aggregates: Eval(CON_B) is_grounded_by AGENT_AGGREGATE(Eval(CON_H),Eval(CON_I),Eval(CON_K)) Eval(CON_C) is_grounded_by AGENT_AGGREGATE(Eval(CON_I),Eval(CON_K),Eval(CON_B)) Eval(CON_D) is_grounded_by AGENT_AGGREGATE(Eval(CON_K),Eval(CON_B),Eval(CON_C)) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-2"></a> INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ This means: • Eval(CON_B) must remain compatible with the later aggregate constituted by Eval(CON_H), Eval(CON_I), Eval(CON_K) • Eval(CON_C) must remain compatible with Eval(CON_I,K,B) • Eval(CON_D) must remain compatible with Eval(CON_K,B,C) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-8"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ BCD is not only prior cause-field. BCD is also validated retroactively by later principial closure. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint-2"></a> CONSTRAINT ------------------------------------------------------------ This does not erase BCD primacy. It introduces retroactive validation, not retroactive reversal. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-03-full-circle-closure-law"></a> PATCH-03 — FULL CIRCLE CLOSURE LAW ============================================================ Add to OPERA A: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-full-circle-closure-law"></a> FULL CIRCLE CLOSURE LAW ------------------------------------------------------------ The A-field must be readable as a cyclic principial closure. Minimal circular articulation: BCD → E → F → G → H → I → K → BCD ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-9"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ After OPERA A execution, the system checks carrier results, reciprocal pair views, contracted-locus aggregates, and then the global dependency cycle. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-meaning"></a> MEANING ------------------------------------------------------------ A result may be: • locally coherent • inheritedly admissible • yet circularly inconsistent Such a result is not invalidated absolutely, but it must be flagged and possibly degraded. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint-3"></a> CONSTRAINT ------------------------------------------------------------ Circular closure is a validation layer, not a separate execution engine. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-04-circular-consistency-check"></a> PATCH-04 — CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY CHECK ============================================================ Add to OPERA A final validation phase: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-circular-consistency-check"></a> CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY CHECK ------------------------------------------------------------ For each selected composite carrier key `[carrier_id,context_id,execution_id]`: <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-check-1"></a> CHECK 1 — LOCAL_CARRIER_CHECK: carrier identity, admission, evidence, and result coherence <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-check-2"></a> CHECK 2 — RECIPROCAL_PAIR_CHECK: reverse directions remain independently keyed; ASYMMETRIC is permitted and equality is never presumed ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-formal-schema"></a> FORMAL SCHEMA ------------------------------------------------------------ For contracted evaluation aggregates: CONSISTENT_ACT(Dx) := Dx is structurally compatible with source_triad(Dx) For retro-grounding core dignities: CONSISTENT_AGENT(Dx) := Dx is structurally compatible with target_triad(Dx) Full circular consistency: CIRCULAR_OK := ALL LOCAL_CARRIER_CHECKS pass or are explicitly degraded AND ALL RECIPROCAL_PAIR_CHECKS preserve direction AND ALL CONTRACTED_LOCUS_AGGREGATE_CHECKS are traceable AND CIRCULAR_VALIDATION.GLOBAL_CYCLE_CHECK contains ACT_SOURCE_STATUS and AGENT_TARGET_STATUS AND its CIRCULAR_CLOSURE_STATUS is coherent or explicitly explained by its nested CIRCULAR_FLAGS ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-10"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ This check occurs after: • local carrier evaluation • reciprocal-pair validation • contracted-locus aggregation, including the BCD slice • inheritance application • global result composition It is a late validation layer. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-05-new-distortion-flag"></a> PATCH-05 — NEW DISTORTION FLAG ============================================================ Add to OPERA A distortion system: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-circular-inconsistency"></a> CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY ------------------------------------------------------------ Definition: assigned when a carrier result or contracted-locus aggregate is locally plausible but structurally inconsistent with: • its ACT source triad • its AGENT target triad • or the full circular closure of the A-field ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-examples-of-use"></a> EXAMPLES OF USE ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. F appears strong locally, but CDE cannot lawfully generate it → CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY 2. GHI cannot lawfully sustain K as evaluated → CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY 3. HIK does not support B as agent → CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY on B-field closure ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-11"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ This flag must be explicit. Silent circular failure is forbidden. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-06-validity-consequences"></a> PATCH-06 — VALIDITY CONSEQUENCES ============================================================ Add to OPERA A: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-validity-consequences-of-circular-failure"></a> VALIDITY CONSEQUENCES OF CIRCULAR FAILURE ------------------------------------------------------------ If circular inconsistency is minor and local: • keep result admissible • degrade strength • attach flag If circular inconsistency is repeated or load-bearing: • degrade GLOBAL validity • reduce downstream reuse readiness If circular inconsistency breaks the full field: • mark result as: A_FIELD_CIRCULAR_FAILURE • block combinatory downstream reuse unless explicitly overridden by later repair or reformulation ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-12"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Circular inconsistency does not always force total block. But it always prevents silent “clean field” presentation. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-07-relation-to-bcd-inheritance"></a> PATCH-07 — RELATION TO BCD INHERITANCE ============================================================ Add clarification: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-relation-to-inheritance-law"></a> RELATION TO INHERITANCE LAW ------------------------------------------------------------ BCD inheritance remains primary. Circular consistency does not abolish: BCD → EFGHIK priority Instead: BCD priority establishes the field circular consistency validates its full closure ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-13"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Validation order remains: 1. local carrier evaluation 2. reciprocal-pair checks and BCD contracted-locus aggregation 3. inheritance application to EFGHIK 4. global synthesis 5. circular consistency check ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint-4"></a> CONSTRAINT ------------------------------------------------------------ Circular closure must not be used to justify skipping BCD-first evaluation. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-08-output-integration"></a> PATCH-08 — OUTPUT INTEGRATION ============================================================ Add to OPERA A global output object: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-circular-validation"></a> CIRCULAR_VALIDATION: ------------------------------------------------------------ { CARRIER_CHECKS: keyed by [carrier_id, context_id, execution_id] RECIPROCAL_PAIR_CHECKS: <RECIPROCAL_EVALUATED | ASYMMETRIC | HALF_EVALUATED | NOT_SELECTED | CONFLICT> CONTRACTED_LOCUS_AGGREGATE_CHECKS: derived BY_PREDICATE checks only GLOBAL_CYCLE_CHECK: { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-act-source-status"></a> ACT_SOURCE_STATUS: <COHERENT | PARTIAL | FAILED> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-agent-target-status"></a> AGENT_TARGET_STATUS: <COHERENT | PARTIAL | FAILED> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-circular-closure-status"></a> CIRCULAR_CLOSURE_STATUS: <CLOSED | WEAKLY_CLOSED | OPEN | FAILED> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-circular-flags"></a> CIRCULAR_FLAGS: { ... } } } This object is embedded in `A_DUPLEX_AX_RESULT`; it is not a detached result store. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-14"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ If this field is present, SATOR A must preserve it in self-binding explanation when downstream reuse is relevant. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-09-downstream-consequence"></a> PATCH-09 — DOWNSTREAM CONSEQUENCE ============================================================ Add to OPERA A reuse discipline: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-downstream-consequence"></a> DOWNSTREAM CONSEQUENCE ------------------------------------------------------------ A-result is combinatorially cleaner when: • BCD is stable • inheritance is lawful • circular closure is closed or weakly closed A-result is not combinatorially ready when: • circular closure is open or failed • CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY is load-bearing ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-15"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ D / TERTIA / QUARTA reuse must not silently ignore circular failure. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-patch-summary"></a> PATCH SUMMARY ============================================================ This patch adds to OPERA A: • ACT generation law • AGENT grounding law • full-circle closure law • circular consistency check • CIRCULAR_INCONSISTENCY distortion flag • explicit validity consequences • output integration for cyclic validation Net effect: OPERA A ceases to be only a linear dependency engine and becomes a cyclic principial validation engine. This sharpens: • anti-drift control • coherence checking • reuse discipline • Llullian structural fidelity ============================================================ END OF PATCH BLOCK — OPERA A CIRCULAR CONSISTENCY LAW ============================================================ ============================================================ OPERA A(BCD) — BONITAS / MAGNITUDO / DURATIO CORE FIELD Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Execution Core Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-BCD-FIELD Status: PROPOSED / CORE ENGINE / CANONICAL STRUCTURE Scope: minimal principial stabilization of REGIMEN_A under contraction Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-2"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-3"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ Defines the minimal principial evaluation unit for REGIMEN_A through the triad: • B — Bonitas • C — Magnitudo • D — Duratio This triad constitutes: the minimal differentiated field required to express A without collapse into undifferentiated singularity. OPERA A(BCD) determines: • whether contracted A stabilizes at all • the structural coherence of principial presence • the baseline field from which EFGHIK may be evaluated ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-2"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ No contracted A-evaluation is structurally complete before BCD has been evaluated. All later contracted E–K evaluation states are conditioned by the BCD carrier slice and constrained by its coherence or failure. No absolute dignity identity is derived from BCD. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis"></a> I. DOCTRINAL BASIS ============================================================ TENET A supplies: • B / Bonitas — operative good • C / Magnitudo — intelligible greatness / extension • D / Duratio — persistence / stability in being These three together provide: • positivity (B) • amplitude / scope (C) • persistence / temporal coherence (D) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-3"></a> INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ A contracted subject cannot sustain principial reading if: • good is absent or contradictory (B failure) • scope is unintelligible or trivial (C failure) • persistence is unstable or collapsing (D failure) Thus: BCD := minimal ontological intelligibility condition for principial evaluation ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements"></a> II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ BCD_INPUT := { DUPLEX_SCHEMA_VERSION, OPERA_ARTIFACT_ID: IDX-A-OPERA-AX, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, EXECUTION_MODE: FULL_72 | SELECTED_SET, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, SELECTED_BCD_CARRIER_REFS, LEGACY_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions"></a> MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. TENET A bound 2. AREPO A admitted 3. PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID resolved under TENET A and, only for L2, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING classified through an admitted TENET K path where that substrate taxonomy applies 4. Q-min support: • Q-C • Q-E • Q-G 5. minimal T grounding: • T-B (difference) • T-C (concordance) • T-D (contrariety) Failure → BLOCK via AREPO A ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-bcd-evaluation-structure"></a> III. BCD EVALUATION STRUCTURE ============================================================ BCD_CARRIER_SLICE := { ROTA_A.PRED.B.C, ROTA_A.PRED.C.B, ROTA_A.PRED.B.D, ROTA_A.PRED.D.B, ROTA_A.PRED.C.D, ROTA_A.PRED.D.C } Within this BCD phase, FULL_72 evaluates all six BCD directions as part of the complete 72-carrier matrix. SELECTED_SET evaluates only the admitted refs and marks every omitted direction NOT_SELECTED. No selected direction may be skipped or inferred from its reverse. B_RESULT, C_RESULT, and D_RESULT are respectively Summary(ROTA_A.CON.B), Summary(ROTA_A.CON.C), and Summary(ROTA_A.CON.D), each derived by BY_PREDICATE over the matching [carrier_id, context_id, execution_id] keys. They are never unary primary results. Each result contains: • PRESENCE_MODE • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT • CORRELATIVE_PROFILE • ATTRIBUTION_MODE • DISTORTION_FLAGS ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-16"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ No admitted carrier may be skipped. No direction may be inferred from another. The BCD phase of FULL_72 evaluates all six explicitly. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-core-synthesis-bcd-field"></a> IV. CORE SYNTHESIS — BCD FIELD ============================================================ BCD_FIELD := synthesize( Summary(ROTA_A.CON.B), Summary(ROTA_A.CON.C), Summary(ROTA_A.CON.D) ) Produces: • BCD_STABILITY • BCD_CONVERTIBILITY • BCD_CORRELATIVE_STATE • BCD_DISTORTION_PROFILE ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-1-bcd-stability"></a> IV.1 — BCD_STABILITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Allowed states: • STABLE • PARTIAL • FRACTURED • COLLAPSED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-stable"></a> STABLE ------------------------------------------------------------ All conditions: • B, C, D are at least MODERATE • no BROKEN convertibility • T-D does not dominate • no MISATTRIBUTED core Interpretation: principial field is viable ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-partial"></a> PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Conditions: • at least one STRONG or MODERATE • others may be WEAK • coherence exists but is incomplete Interpretation: principial reading is possible but limited ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-fractured"></a> FRACTURED ------------------------------------------------------------ Conditions: • at least one DEFORMED or FRAGMENTED • strong asymmetry or contradiction • coherence unstable across the triad Interpretation: principial field is unstable ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-collapsed"></a> COLLAPSED ------------------------------------------------------------ Conditions: • any of: • Summary(CON_B).PRESENCE_MODE = ABSENT or DEFORMED • Summary(CON_C).PRESENCE_MODE = ABSENT • Summary(CON_D).PRESENCE_MODE = ABSENT or BROKEN • or dominant CONTRARIETY across triad Interpretation: no lawful A-field can be sustained ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-17"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ If BCD_STABILITY = COLLAPSED: → OPERA A global result must be BLOCKED → EFGHIK evaluation is not admissible ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-2-bcd-convertibility"></a> IV.2 — BCD_CONVERTIBILITY ============================================================ Derived from individual convertibility effects. Allowed states: • COHERENT • PARTIAL • DISJOINT • BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-coherent"></a> COHERENT ------------------------------------------------------------ All three mutually reinforce each other. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-partial-2"></a> PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Some reinforcement, some gaps. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-disjoint"></a> DISJOINT ------------------------------------------------------------ Dignities do not integrate meaningfully. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-broken"></a> BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ Convertibility cannot be sustained. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-18"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Convertibility is structural, not rhetorical. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-3-bcd-correlative-state"></a> IV.3 — BCD_CORRELATIVE_STATE ============================================================ Evaluate triadic presence across B, C, D: • BALANCED • ASYMMETRIC • THIN • COLLAPSED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-4"></a> INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ Balanced: triadic structure present across field Asymmetric: one dimension dominates excessively Thin: correlative presence minimal Collapsed: no meaningful triadic articulation ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-4-bcd-distortion-profile"></a> IV.4 — BCD_DISTORTION_PROFILE ============================================================ Union of distortion flags across B, C, D plus cross-field flags: • CONTRARIETY_DOMINANT • TEMPORAL_INSTABILITY • SCALE_INCOHERENCE • GOODNESS_CONTRADICTION • FIELD_ASYMMETRY ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-19"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Cross-field distortions have higher priority than local ones. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-inheritance-law-critical"></a> V. INHERITANCE LAW (CRITICAL) ============================================================ BCD_FIELD governs only later contracted-locus evaluations: Eval(ROTA_A.CON.E..ROTA_A.CON.K) := evaluated under BCD_FIELD constraints No ABS locus, homologous AXIS, or dignity identity inherits a BCD state. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rules"></a> RULES ------------------------------------------------------------ IF BCD_STABILITY = STABLE: → EFGHIK may be evaluated normally IF BCD_STABILITY = PARTIAL: → EFGHIK must be marked PROVISIONAL IF BCD_STABILITY = FRACTURED: → EFGHIK inherits degradation pressure IF BCD_STABILITY = COLLAPSED: → EFGHIK evaluation is BLOCKED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint-5"></a> CONSTRAINT ------------------------------------------------------------ Later Eval(ROTA_A.CON.E..ROTA_A.CON.K) summaries cannot silently override BCD contradictions. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-t-mediated-integration"></a> VI. T-MEDIATED INTEGRATION ============================================================ BCD must be evaluated through T: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-b-difference"></a> T-B (DIFFERENCE) ------------------------------------------------------------ Ensures B, C, D are not collapsed into one undifferentiated predicate. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-c-concordance"></a> T-C (CONCORDANCE) ------------------------------------------------------------ Measures coherence across: • goodness • greatness • duration ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-d-contrariety"></a> T-D (CONTRARIETY) ------------------------------------------------------------ Detects: • good that destroys itself • greatness without coherence • duration sustaining contradiction ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-20"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ T-D has veto power over false coherence. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-q-min-support-for-bcd"></a> VII. Q-MIN SUPPORT FOR BCD ============================================================ Required: • Q-C (what is the subject?) • Q-E (why is it so?) • Q-G (what quality is asserted?) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-21"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Without Q-C/E/G: → BCD_FIELD must be degraded or BLOCKED ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-output-structure"></a> VIII. OUTPUT STRUCTURE ============================================================ BCD_CARRIER_SLICE_RESULT(context_id, execution_id) := { CARRIER_RESULTS: { [carrier_id, context_id, execution_id]: FULL_CARRIER_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD including CIRCULAR_CHECK_REF for carrier_id in BCD_CARRIER_SLICE }, PAIR_VIEWS: { [pair_key]: derived forward/reverse refs and RECIPROCITY_STATUS for the three BCD pair keys }, CONTRACTED_LOCUS_SUMMARY_MAP: { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-b"></a> B: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.B), <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-c"></a> C: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.C), <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-d"></a> D: Summary(ROTA_A.CON.D) }, <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-field-2"></a> FIELD: { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bcd-stability"></a> BCD_STABILITY: <STABLE | PARTIAL | FRACTURED | COLLAPSED> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bcd-convertibility"></a> BCD_CONVERTIBILITY: <COHERENT | PARTIAL | DISJOINT | BROKEN> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bcd-correlative-state"></a> BCD_CORRELATIVE_STATE: <BALANCED | ASYMMETRIC | THIN | COLLAPSED> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bcd-distortion-profile"></a> BCD_DISTORTION_PROFILE: { ... } }, <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-global-effect-2"></a> GLOBAL_EFFECT: { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-a-field-status"></a> A_FIELD_STATUS: <VIABLE | LIMITED | UNSTABLE | INVALID> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-efghik-permission"></a> EFGHIK_PERMISSION: <ALLOWED | PROVISIONAL | DEGRADED | BLOCKED> }, CIRCULAR_VALIDATION: { CARRIER_CHECKS, RECIPROCAL_PAIR_CHECKS, CONTRACTED_LOCUS_AGGREGATE_CHECKS, GLOBAL_CYCLE_CHECK: { ACT_SOURCE_STATUS, AGENT_TARGET_STATUS, CIRCULAR_CLOSURE_STATUS, CIRCULAR_FLAGS } } } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-22"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ GLOBAL_EFFECT must be derived strictly from FIELD. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-failure-conditions"></a> IX. FAILURE CONDITIONS ============================================================ Immediate BLOCK if: • subject unbound • Q-min missing • Summary(CON_B).PRESENCE_MODE = ABSENT with no justification • Summary(CON_D).PRESENCE_MODE = BROKEN (no persistence) • dominant CONTRARIETY ignored ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-degradation-conditions"></a> DEGRADATION CONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ • asymmetry unresolved • causal gaps present • scale incoherence (C instability) • temporal instability (D weakness) ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-interpretive-summary"></a> X. INTERPRETIVE SUMMARY ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-opera-a-bcd"></a> OPERA A(BCD): • establishes whether principial reading is possible • stabilizes minimal A-field • prevents premature expansion into EFGHIK • enforces Llullian evaluation order ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-closure-rule-2"></a> CLOSURE RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ No executing BCD reading is structurally valid until the six selected carrier states are independently evaluated (or explicitly NOT_SELECTED in SELECTED_SET) and the B/C/D contracted-locus summaries are derived from them. ============================================================ END OF OPERA A(BCD) ============================================================ ============================================================ OPERA A — BCD→EFGHIK CONTRACTED-EVALUATION INHERITANCE RULES Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Dependency Layer Version: 0.2.0-OPERA-A-BCD-INHERITANCE-DUPLEX Status: PROPOSED / CORE DEPENDENCY LAW Scope: propagation of BCD field conditions into later contracted evaluation states without deriving absolute dignity identity Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-4"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-5"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ Defines how the stabilized (or unstable) BCD_FIELD governs the evaluation of extended contracted loci: • E — Potestas • F — Sapientia • G — Voluntas • H — Virtus • I — Veritas • K — Gloria This section ensures: • lawful evaluation order • non-collapse between core and extended contracted evaluations • principial coherence across OPERA A • prevention of false high-order claims over weak bases ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-4"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Contracted EFGHIK states are not evaluated independently. Their evaluations are: • downstream of the BCD field • constrained by BCD stability • interpreted through T-mediated relations grounded in B Their absolute dignity identities are not downstream of BCD. Thus: BCD_FIELD → conditions → Eval(CON_E..CON_K) ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-global-inheritance-matrix"></a> I. GLOBAL INHERITANCE MATRIX ============================================================ Let: S := BCD_STABILITY ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-s-stable"></a> S = STABLE ------------------------------------------------------------ EFGHIK_PERMISSION = ALLOWED Effects: • full evaluation allowed • strong PRESENCE_MODE admissible • NEAR_INTEGRAL possible (still contracted) • PROPER attribution fully admissible • multi-path reinforcement possible ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-s-partial"></a> S = PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ EFGHIK_PERMISSION = PROVISIONAL Effects: • evaluation allowed with caution • PRESENCE_MODE capped at MODERATE unless justified • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT capped at PARTIAL • ATTRIBUTION_MODE tends toward APPROPRIATED • SUPPORT_DEPTH defaults to SINGLE_PATH ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-s-fractured"></a> S = FRACTURED ------------------------------------------------------------ EFGHIK_PERMISSION = DEGRADED Effects: • evaluation allowed under degradation • PRESENCE_MODE capped at WEAK • DEFORMED becomes likely • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT tends toward FRAGMENTED • MISATTRIBUTION pressure increases • DISTORTION_FLAGS propagate strongly ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-s-collapsed"></a> S = COLLAPSED ------------------------------------------------------------ EFGHIK_PERMISSION = BLOCKED Effects: • no lawful Eval(ROTA_A.CON.E..ROTA_A.CON.K) • any remaining ABS statement must be treated as an L0 REFERENCE_ONLY citation, never as an evaluated claim • OPERA A must terminate or remain at BCD level ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-core-dependency-mappings"></a> II. CORE DEPENDENCY MAPPINGS ============================================================ Each extended contracted evaluation depends on BCD as follows: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-e-potestas-power"></a> E — POTESTAS (Power) ------------------------------------------------------------ Depends on: • B (good-directedness of power) • C (scope of power) • D (persistence of power) Inheritance rules: • If B weak → power tends toward destructive or DEFORMED • If C weak → power is trivial or OVEREXTENDED • If D weak → power is unstable or ephemeral ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-f-sapientia-wisdom-mediation"></a> F — SAPIENTIA (Wisdom / Mediation) ------------------------------------------------------------ Depends on: • B (good-directedness of mediation) • C (intelligible scope or amplitude of mediation) • D (stability and persistence of mediating form) Inheritance rules: • If B weak → mediation becomes misaligned, merely clever, or formally operative without principial good • If C weak → mediation is too narrow, thin, or insufficient to relate terms adequately • If D weak → mediation cannot hold stable form or durable intelligible relation Interpretation: Sapientia here is evaluated primarily as lawful mediation, intelligible middle, and form-bearing articulation, not as mere possession of knowledge. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-g-voluntas-will"></a> G — VOLUNTAS (Will) ------------------------------------------------------------ Depends on: • B (good orientation of desire) • C (range of intention) • D (stability of commitment) Inheritance rules: • If B weak → will becomes disordered • If C weak → will is trivial or scattered • If D weak → will is unstable or inconstant ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-h-virtus-virtue"></a> H — VIRTUS (Virtue) ------------------------------------------------------------ Depends on: • B (good enacted) • C (strength and scope of action) • D (habitual persistence) Inheritance rules: • If B weak → virtue becomes merely nominal • If C weak → virtue is weak or ineffective • If D weak → virtue lacks habitus ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-veritas-truth"></a> I — VERITAS (Truth) ------------------------------------------------------------ Depends on: • B (truth oriented toward good) • C (completeness of intelligibility) • D (stability of truth across time) Inheritance rules: • If B fractured → truth may be technically correct but misaligned (partial truth) • If C weak → truth is incomplete • If D weak → truth is unstable or contradictory ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-k-gloria-glory"></a> K — GLORIA (Glory) ------------------------------------------------------------ Depends on: • B (recognition of good) • C (magnitude of manifestation) • D (durable recognition) Inheritance rules: • If B weak → glory becomes vanity or illusion • If C weak → glory is minor or insignificant • If D weak → glory is fleeting ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-convertibility-propagation-law"></a> III. CONVERTIBILITY PROPAGATION LAW ============================================================ Extended contracted evaluation states inherit convertibility constraints: ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-30"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ If: BCD_CONVERTIBILITY = COHERENT Then: EFGHIK may reach STABLE_CONTRACTED or NEAR_INTEGRAL ------------------------------------------------------------ If: BCD_CONVERTIBILITY = PARTIAL Then: EFGHIK_CONVERTIBILITY ≤ PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ If: BCD_CONVERTIBILITY = DISJOINT Then: EFGHIK_CONVERTIBILITY ≤ FRAGMENTED ------------------------------------------------------------ If: BCD_CONVERTIBILITY = BROKEN Then: EFGHIK_CONVERTIBILITY = BROKEN or BLOCKED ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-distortion-propagation-law"></a> IV. DISTORTION PROPAGATION LAW ============================================================ Distortions in BCD propagate downstream. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rules-3"></a> RULES ------------------------------------------------------------ If B contains: GOODNESS_CONTRADICTION → propagate: CONTRARIETY_PRESENT to all EFGHIK If C contains: SCALE_INCOHERENCE → propagate: OVEREXTENSION or UNDEREXTENSION If D contains: TEMPORAL_INSTABILITY → propagate: INSTABILITY flags across all extended contracted evaluations ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-priority-rule"></a> PRIORITY RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Cross-field distortions override local clarity in EFGHIK. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-attribution-inheritance-law"></a> V. ATTRIBUTION INHERITANCE LAW ============================================================ ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-31"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ If BCD contains MISATTRIBUTION: • EFGHIK attribution defaults to: MISATTRIBUTED unless explicitly corrected If BCD attribution is APPROPRIATED: • EFGHIK cannot claim PROPER without justification If BCD attribution is PROPER: • EFGHIK may claim PROPER where structurally valid ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-correlative-inheritance-law"></a> VI. CORRELATIVE INHERITANCE LAW ============================================================ ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-32"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ If BCD_CORRELATIVE_STATE = BALANCED: → EFGHIK may reach BALANCED profiles If ASYMMETRIC: → extended contracted evaluations inherit asymmetry bias If THIN: → EFGHIK likely INCOMPLETE If COLLAPSED: → EFGHIK correlative evaluation invalid ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-exception-clause-local-stabilization"></a> VII. EXCEPTION CLAUSE (LOCAL STABILIZATION) ============================================================ Extended contracted evaluations may locally stabilize under strict conditions. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-conditions"></a> CONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ A contracted evaluation Eval(CON_x) may override inherited degradation if: • strong Q support exists (causal + qualitative) • strong T coherence exists locally • distortion flags are locally resolved • justification explicitly isolates the case ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-33"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Such cases must be marked: LOCAL_STABILIZATION ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-constraint-7"></a> CONSTRAINT ------------------------------------------------------------ Local stabilization does NOT repair BCD_FIELD globally. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-output-integration"></a> VIII. OUTPUT INTEGRATION ============================================================ Each extended contracted result must include: • inherited constraints • local evaluation • reconciliation between both ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-34"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ No EFGHIK result may ignore: • BCD_STABILITY • BCD_CONVERTIBILITY • BCD_DISTORTION_PROFILE ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-failure-conditions-3"></a> IX. FAILURE CONDITIONS ============================================================ Immediate BLOCK if: • EFGHIK evaluated under BCD_COLLAPSED • strong claims made ignoring BCD contradictions • convertibility inflated beyond BCD limits ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-degradation-conditions-3"></a> DEGRADATION CONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ • weak Q support • unresolved T tensions • ignored distortion inheritance ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-summary"></a> X. SUMMARY ============================================================ The inheritance system ensures: • principial order is preserved • evaluation remains Llull-consistent • no artificial elevation of extended contracted results occurs • structural coherence governs interpretation ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-closure-rule-4"></a> CLOSURE RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ EFGHIK are lawful only insofar as they remain grounded in the stability, convertibility, and coherence of BCD. ============================================================ END OF INHERITANCE RULES ============================================================ ============================================================ OPERA A(B) — OPERA BONITAS Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Execution Template Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-BONITAS-TEMPLATE Status: PROPOSED / TEMPLATE / CANONICAL-SEED Scope: deterministic qualitative evaluation model for Bonitas Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-5"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-6"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ This template defines how OPERA A should evaluate the Bonitas predicate column through admitted PRED(i,B), i != B, under contracted use without: • numeric scoring • loose analogy • hidden heuristics • silent doctrinal mutation It establishes a deterministic qualitative rule model for: • presence of Bonitas in a bound subject • correlative profile of Bonitas • convertibility impact under contraction • attribution mode • distortion flags • output discipline This is not yet the full OPERA A artifact. It is the canonical seed-template for one dignity. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-5"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Bonitas in pure REGIMEN_A is integral and fully convertible. Bonitas in OPERA A is never evaluated as pure integral plenitude. REFERENCE_ONLY cites the L0 ABS locus and performs no OPERA evaluation. Thus: OPERA A never asks: “is this absolute Bonitas in itself?” OPERA A asks: “how does Bonitas appear here under contraction?” ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-3"></a> I. DOCTRINAL BASIS ============================================================ TENET A supplies: • Bonitas as canonical dignity • its fixed ordinal token: Ⅰ / B • its canonical phrase: "Bonitas est, per quam bonum bonificat." • distinction between pure and contracted use • correlative necessity • proper / appropriated distinction ALBUS FIGURA PRIMA supplies touchstone insight for: • contraction ladder • partialization outside pure field • discrimination of convertibility • correlative grounding AREPO A supplies: • admissibility gates • binding requirements • degraded / blocked handling • convertibility discipline • correlative integrity gating ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary"></a> BOUNDARY ------------------------------------------------------------ This template does not redefine Bonitas. It defines a lawful evaluation procedure-template for contracted Bonitas only. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-3"></a> II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal input object: A_INPUT := { PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-3"></a> MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. TENET A bound 2. AREPO A admitted 3. subject anchor present 4. minimum Q support present 5. minimum T support present If any mandatory precondition fails: BLOCK via AREPO A ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-bonitas-evaluation-unit"></a> BONITAS EVALUATION UNIT ------------------------------------------------------------ BONITAS_PREDICATE_COLUMN_COMPONENT := evaluate one admitted PRED(i,B), i != B, under contraction ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-bonitas-canonical-doctrinal-seed"></a> III. BONITAS — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED ============================================================ ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅰ / B Canonical noun: Bonitas Lexical lemma: Bonus Contracted citation form: Bonum Canonical phrase: "Bonitas est, per quam bonum bonificat." Minimal doctrinal reading: Bonitas is that by reason of which good actively gives, communicates, or realizes good. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation"></a> EXECUTION INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ For contracted evaluation purposes, Bonitas is read through: • productive good-effect • coherence of act toward good • non-destructive participative orientation • tendency to communicate or instantiate good • compatibility with concordance and final coherence Bonitas is weakened when: • good is merely named but not operative • act harms what it claims to perfect • contrariety dominates • communicative / receptive structure collapses • attribution is merely rhetorical or decorative ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes"></a> IV. EVALUATION DIMENSIONS ============================================================ Each carrier in the Bonitas predicate column resolves five evaluation dimensions: 1. PRESENCE_MODE 2. CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT 3. CORRELATIVE_PROFILE 4. ATTRIBUTION_MODE 5. DISTORTION_FLAGS No numeric score is permitted. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode"></a> V. DIMENSION 1 — PRESENCE MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • STRONG • MODERATE • WEAK • DEFORMED • ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong"></a> V.1 — STRONG ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign STRONG iff all are true: 1. the subject exhibits operative good, not only nominal good 2. the act tends to communicate, produce, preserve, or realize a good effect 3. relation to end is non-destructive 4. T-contrariety does not dominate 5. some correlative coherence is preserved 6. attribution is not merely decorative Interpretation: Bonitas is genuinely present under contraction and acts as a meaningful principial force in the case. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate"></a> V.2 — MODERATE ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign MODERATE iff: 1. some operative good is present 2. good effect is mixed, limited, or partially unstable 3. coherence exists but is incomplete 4. contrariety exists but does not dominate 5. correlative expression is partial but non-collapsed Interpretation: Bonitas is meaningfully present, but not strongly stabilized. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak"></a> V.3 — WEAK ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign WEAK iff: 1. Bonitas is only thinly operative 2. good effect is narrow, local, or fragile 3. stronger support comes from other dignities or relations 4. correlative expression is shallow 5. convertibility toward other dignities is hard to defend Interpretation: Bonitas is plausible but only weakly instantiated. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed"></a> V.4 — DEFORMED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign DEFORMED iff: 1. the language of good is present 2. but its act is contradictory, self-canceling, exploitative, or corrosive 3. apparent goodness functions against concordance or against stable good effect 4. attribution is substantially distorted Interpretation: this is not a stable contracted Bonitas, but a damaged or misformed appearance of it. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent"></a> V.5 — ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign ABSENT iff: 1. no operative good can be demonstrated 2. no stable good-directed function is present 3. the attribution is empty, decorative, or unrelated 4. Bonitas adds no principial explanatory value Interpretation: Bonitas is not lawfully present in the current reading. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect"></a> VI. DIMENSION 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT ============================================================ Allowed states: • NEAR_INTEGRAL • STABLE_CONTRACTED • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral"></a> VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use only when: • path is highly refined • contrariety is minimal • concordance and equality are high • Bonitas integrates strongly with several other dignities • correlative coherence is balanced Constraint: this is still contracted, not pure integral plenitude. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted"></a> VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • Bonitas coheres with other dignities in a stable way • no major contradiction breaks the structure • good is productive and intelligible • attribution is proper or strongly defensible ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial"></a> VI.3 — PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • some principial coherence is preserved • but convertibility remains incomplete • relevant tensions remain unresolved • support is one-sided or narrow ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented"></a> VI.4 — FRAGMENTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • Bonitas appears in scattered or isolated traces • coherence with Magnitudo, Veritas, Virtus, etc. is poor • contrariety or asymmetry is high • correlative structure is unstable ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken"></a> VI.5 — BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • a Bonitas-reading cannot sustain principial coherence • distortion dominates • coherence is too compromised for lawful A-use ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-35"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Convertibility effect is never inferred from similarity alone. It must be justified by structural coherence under T and by the correlative/attribution state. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile"></a> VII. DIMENSION 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE ============================================================ Allowed states: • BALANCED • AGENT_DOMINANT • PATIENT_DOMINANT • ACT_DOMINANT • INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model"></a> MINIMAL MODEL ------------------------------------------------------------ Bonitas may appear through: • AGENT = that which gives / produces good • PATIENT = that which receives / bears good • ACT = the bonifying or good-producing relation itself ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-1-balanced"></a> VII.1 — BALANCED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when all three dimensions are materially present and mutually coherent. Interpretation: strongest contracted correlative state ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-2-agent-dominant"></a> VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • productive source is primary • received good or communicative act is secondary Example pattern: a beneficent source whose productive role is clearer than its receptivity ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-3-patient-dominant"></a> VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • the subject is chiefly bearer or receiver of good • productive agency is weaker or indirect ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-4-act-dominant"></a> VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • the operative relation of bonifying is clearer than agent/patient individuation • process dominates over stable bearer roles ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-5-incomplete"></a> VII.5 — INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • only one side is plausibly visible • the triad cannot be lawfully stabilized • AREPO degradation or block may follow ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-36"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Correlative profile does not by itself decide admissibility. But it materially conditions strength and reuse readiness. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode"></a> VIII. DIMENSION 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • PROPER • APPROPRIATED • MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper"></a> VIII.1 — PROPER ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when Bonitas belongs to the subject in a way that is: • intrinsic • native • structurally grounded • not merely borrowed or rhetorical ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated"></a> VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when Bonitas is present through: • derivative participation • secondary habit • contextual association • indirect good-bearing role This remains lawful, but not integral. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed"></a> VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when Bonitas is claimed but: • grounding is absent • another dignity or predicate would fit better • the attribution is decorative, confused, or misleading ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-37"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ MISATTRIBUTED Bonitas strongly pressures the result toward: • DEFORMED • ABSENT • or BLOCKED ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags"></a> IX. DIMENSION 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS ============================================================ Possible flags: • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT • ASYMMETRY_HIGH • CAUSAL_GAP • SUBJECT_MISMATCH • OVEREXTENSION • CORRELATIVE_THINNESS • ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic"></a> FLAG LOGIC ------------------------------------------------------------ CONTRARIETY_PRESENT Bonitas conflicts materially with the current structure ASYMMETRY_HIGH one correlative side dominates excessively CAUSAL_GAP Q/E support for why this is good is weak SUBJECT_MISMATCH the substrate does not support this dignity well OVEREXTENSION Bonitas is being used too broadly or rhetorically CORRELATIVE_THINNESS triadic structure is too weak ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY proper/appropriated status is unclear or unstable ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-bonitas"></a> X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR BONITAS ============================================================ Each admitted PRED(i,B), i != B, must be evaluated through relevant T predicates. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-b-difference-3"></a> T-B — DIFFERENCE ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Bonitas structurally distinct here without confusion? Effect: prevents collapse into generic praise-language ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-c-concordance-3"></a> T-C — CONCORDANCE ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: does the good cohere with the structure it belongs to? Effect: strengthens STRONG / MODERATE states ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-d-contrariety-3"></a> T-D — CONTRARIETY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: does the apparent good work against itself or against the broader principial coherence? Effect: strongest negative pressure on Bonitas ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-e-beginning"></a> T-E — BEGINNING ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Bonitas functioning as source, initiative, or origin? Effect: strengthens AGENT_DOMINANT readings ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-f-middle"></a> T-F — MIDDLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Bonitas mediating or communicating good between terms? Effect: strengthens ACT_DOMINANT or BALANCED readings ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-g-end"></a> T-G — END ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: does the act tend toward realized good as end? Effect: critical for stable Bonitas ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-h-majority"></a> T-H — MAJORITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Bonitas the dominant principial force in this reading? Effect: affects ranking, not validity by itself ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-i-equality"></a> T-I — EQUALITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Bonitas proportionately balanced with other relevant dignities? Effect: strengthens convertibility effect ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-k-minority"></a> T-K — MINORITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Bonitas only residual, marginal, or attenuated here? Effect: strengthens WEAK / FRAGMENTED readings ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-for-bonitas"></a> XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS FOR BONITAS ============================================================ Minimal rule-support required: • Q-C (what is this?) • Q-E (why is this Bonitas?) • Q-G (what quality is being claimed?) Recommended additional support: • Q-D (of what / from what?) • Q-K2 (with what mediation?) • Q-K1 (how?) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-38"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Without at least C + E + G support, Bonitas classification must be degraded or blocked. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-7"></a> INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ Q-C stabilizes object Q-E stabilizes causal claim Q-G stabilizes qualitative claim ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic"></a> XII. DECISION LOGIC ============================================================ Evaluation order: 1. verify AREPO admissibility 2. verify subject binding 3. verify Q-min support 4. inspect T tensions / concordances 5. determine presence mode 6. determine correlative profile 7. determine attribution mode 8. determine convertibility effect 9. attach distortion flags 10. emit Bonitas result object ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-39"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ No later step may silently override an earlier failure without explicit justification. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-bonitas-result-object"></a> XIII. BONITAS RESULT OBJECT ============================================================ Recommended output structure: BONITAS_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅰ / B <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-2"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: <STRONG | MODERATE | WEAK | DEFORMED | ABSENT> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-2"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: <NEAR_INTEGRAL | STABLE_CONTRACTED | PARTIAL | FRAGMENTED | BROKEN> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-2"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: <BALANCED | AGENT_DOMINANT | PATIENT_DOMINANT | ACT_DOMINANT | INCOMPLETE> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-2"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: <PROPER | APPROPRIATED | MISATTRIBUTED> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-2"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-support"></a> T_SUPPORT: { CONCORDANCE: ... CONTRARIETY: ... BEGINNING: ... MIDDLE: ... END: ... EQUALITY: ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification"></a> JUSTIFICATION: concise structured rationale } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-rule"></a> JUSTIFICATION RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Rationale must be: • structural • explicit • non-rhetorical • non-numeric ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-abstract-template-only"></a> XIV. EXAMPLE — ABSTRACT TEMPLATE ONLY ============================================================ Input case: x = a bounded action or institution claimed to be good Possible result: BONITAS_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-2"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅰ / B <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-3"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: MODERATE <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-3"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: PARTIAL <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-3"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: ACT_DOMINANT <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-3"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: APPROPRIATED <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-3"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ASYMMETRY_HIGH, CAUSAL_GAP } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-2"></a> JUSTIFICATION: good is present through a beneficial act-pattern, but not as stable intrinsic plenitude; explanatory support is incomplete and the receptive side is weak } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status"></a> EXAMPLE STATUS ------------------------------------------------------------ METHOD_TEMPLATE This example illustrates output form, not a canon judgment. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions"></a> XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS ============================================================ Bonitas evaluation must be blocked or degraded when: • no subject is bound • no causal basis for good is available • contrariety dominates but is ignored • attribution is misassigned without acknowledgment • good is asserted rhetorically with no principial support • pure plenitude is claimed in a bounded applied case ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-block-pressure-conditions"></a> BLOCK-PRESSURE CONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ Strong block pressure occurs when: • PRESENCE_MODE = ABSENT • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT = BROKEN • CORRELATIVE_PROFILE = INCOMPLETE • ATTRIBUTION_MODE = MISATTRIBUTED • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT is load-bearing ============================================================ ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness"></a> XVI. REUSE READINESS ============================================================ Bonitas result may be reused downstream only if all are true: • VALIDITY_STATE ≠ BLOCKED • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT ∈ {NEAR_INTEGRAL, STABLE_CONTRACTED} OR (PARTIAL with explicit flags) • ATTRIBUTION_MODE ≠ MISATTRIBUTED • CORRELATIVE_PROFILE ≠ INCOMPLETE • DISTORTION_FLAGS do not contain load-bearing CONTRARIETY_PRESENT without explicit containment ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-conditional-reuse-flagged"></a> CONDITIONAL REUSE (FLAGGED) ------------------------------------------------------------ If any of the following hold: • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT = PARTIAL • CORRELATIVE_PROFILE = ACT_DOMINANT or AGENT_DOMINANT with weak complement • CAUSAL_GAP present • ASYMMETRY_HIGH present Then: REUSE_FLAG := CONDITIONAL Meaning: • reusable with explicit warnings • not safe for blind composition • requires S/Q/T reinforcement before OPERA D ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-unsafe-reuse"></a> UNSAFE REUSE ------------------------------------------------------------ If any of the following hold: • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT ∈ {FRAGMENTED, BROKEN} • PRESENCE_MODE ∈ {DEFORMED, ABSENT} • ATTRIBUTION_MODE = MISATTRIBUTED Then: REUSE_FLAG := UNSAFE Meaning: • must not propagate into D / TERTIA / QUARTA • requires re-evaluation or re-binding ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-40"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Reuse readiness is not equivalent to validity. A result may be: • valid but not reusable • usable but not composable ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-global-integration-into-a-result"></a> XVII. GLOBAL INTEGRATION INTO A_DUPLEX_AX_RESULT ============================================================ B_RESULT := Summary(ROTA_A.CON.B; BY_PREDICATE(ROTA_A.CON.B, evaluated composite carrier keys)) participates as a derived view in A_DUPLEX_AX_RESULT. It never replaces the primary CARRIER_RESULTS entries. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-integration-rule"></a> INTEGRATION RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Bonitas must be read: • in relation to other dignities • not as isolated scalar ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-inter-dignity-constraints"></a> INTER-DIGNITY CONSTRAINTS ------------------------------------------------------------ Bonitas interacts critically with: • Magnitudo → scale of good • Veritas → truth of good • Virtus → power to enact good • Concordantia (via T-C) → coherence • Finis (via T-G) → realized good ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-41"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ If Bonitas is STRONG but: • Veritas is WEAK • or Virtus is WEAK Then: raise DISTORTION_FLAGS: • CAUSAL_GAP • OVEREXTENSION ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-system-consequence"></a> SYSTEM CONSEQUENCE ------------------------------------------------------------ No dignity may be interpreted as stable if it requires non-coherent support from other dignities. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-support-depth-formalization"></a> XVIII. SUPPORT DEPTH FORMALIZATION ============================================================ Support depth is evaluated at OPERA A level as: • SINGLE_PATH • MINIMALLY_CROSS_SUPPORTED • MULTI_PATH_REINFORCED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-1-single-path"></a> XVIII.1 — SINGLE_PATH ------------------------------------------------------------ Default state when: • only one admitted PRED(i,B), i != B, is present • Q/T support is minimal or absent • no independent reinforcement exists ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-2-minimally-cross-supported"></a> XVIII.2 — MINIMALLY_CROSS_SUPPORTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • Q support is present and coherent • at least one T predicate reinforces Bonitas • no major contradiction across layers ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-3-multi-path-reinforced"></a> XVIII.3 — MULTI_PATH_REINFORCED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • S, Q, and T layers all coherently support Bonitas • multiple independent justifications exist • no major distortion flags dominate ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-42"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Support depth must be: • explicitly declared • never inferred silently • never upgraded without structural justification ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xix-arepo-a-handoff-contract"></a> XIX. AREPO A HANDOFF CONTRACT ============================================================ B_RESULT and all primary carrier refs that support it must be passed to AREPO A for validation. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-handoff-structure"></a> HANDOFF STRUCTURE ------------------------------------------------------------ AREPO_INPUT := { B_RESULT_REF, SUPPORTING_CARRIER_RESULT_REFS, GLOBAL_CONTEXT, BINDING_STATE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-arepo-a-responsibility"></a> AREPO A RESPONSIBILITY ------------------------------------------------------------ AREPO A determines: • VALIDITY_STATE • admissibility for reuse • degradation status • block conditions ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-43"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ OPERA A must NOT: • assign VALIDITY_STATE independently • override AREPO A decisions ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-feedback-loop"></a> FEEDBACK LOOP ------------------------------------------------------------ AREPO A may: • downgrade result • flag missing bindings • enforce stricter interpretation OPERA A must accept AREPO output as authoritative. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xx-cross-dignity-consistency-rule"></a> XX. CROSS-DIGNITY CONSISTENCY RULE ============================================================ Within A_DUPLEX_AX_RESULT: no dignity may contradict another without explicit flag. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-44"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ If Bonitas implies: • stable good but another dignity implies: • structural contradiction Then: add DISTORTION_FLAGS: • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT • CORRELATIVE_THINNESS ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-prohibition"></a> PROHIBITION ------------------------------------------------------------ OPERA A must not silently harmonize contradictions. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-8"></a> INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ Contradiction is: • diagnostic signal • not an error to hide ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xxi-sator-interface-contract"></a> XXI. SATOR INTERFACE CONTRACT ============================================================ B_RESULT must be exposed only as Summary(ROTA_A.CON.B) with its supporting composite carrier keys so SATOR A can mediate it. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-required-exposure"></a> REQUIRED EXPOSURE ------------------------------------------------------------ Expose at minimum: • PRESENCE_MODE • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT • CORRELATIVE_PROFILE • ATTRIBUTION_MODE • SUPPORT_DEPTH • DISTORTION_FLAGS ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-optional-exposure"></a> OPTIONAL EXPOSURE ------------------------------------------------------------ • T_SUPPORT • JUSTIFICATION • Q_SUPPORT STATUS ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-45"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Output must be: • structurally explicit • non-rhetorical • self-binding ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-compatibility"></a> COMPATIBILITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Output must support: • SATOR diagnostic fields • reasoning-first exposition • training-aware mediation • teaching-aware mediation ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xxii-closure"></a> XXII. CLOSURE ============================================================ This BONITAS rule model defines: • deterministic qualitative evaluation • principial contraction logic • structured output discipline • compatibility with TENET / AREPO / SATOR ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-final-rule"></a> FINAL RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Bonitas under OPERA A is never: • purely asserted • numerically scored • analogically inferred It is always: • structurally evaluated • rule-determined • explicitly justified • contraction-aware ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-system-position"></a> SYSTEM POSITION ------------------------------------------------------------ This template serves as: • canonical seed for OPERA A dignity models • reusable pattern for all A dignities • bridge between doctrine (TENET) and execution (OPERA) • stable input for AREPO validation • structured output for SATOR mediation ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-closure-condition"></a> CLOSURE CONDITION ------------------------------------------------------------ A Bonitas evaluation is complete when: • all five evaluation dimensions are resolved • distortion flags are explicit • support depth is declared • reuse readiness is stated • no silent contradiction remains ============================================================ END OF OPERA A — BONITAS RULE MODEL TEMPLATE ============================================================ ============================================================ OPERA A(C) — OPERA MAGNITUDO Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Execution Template Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-MAGNITUDO-TEMPLATE Status: PROPOSED / TEMPLATE / CANONICAL-SEED Scope: deterministic qualitative evaluation model for Magnitudo Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY Class: OPERA PURPOSE This template defines how OPERA A should evaluate the Magnitudo predicate column through admitted PRED(i,C), i != C, under contracted use without: • numeric scoring • loose analogy • hidden heuristics • silent doctrinal mutation It establishes a deterministic qualitative rule model for: • presence of Magnitudo in a bound subject • correlative profile of Magnitudo • convertibility impact under contraction • attribution mode • distortion flags • output discipline This is not yet the full OPERA A artifact. It is the canonical seed-template for one dignity. CONTROL PRINCIPLE Magnitudo in pure REGIMEN_A is integral and fully convertible. Magnitudo in OPERA A is never evaluated as pure integral plenitude. REFERENCE_ONLY cites the L0 ABS locus and performs no OPERA evaluation. Thus: OPERA A never asks: “is this absolute Magnitudo in itself?” OPERA A asks: <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-how-does-magnitudo-appear-here-under-contraction"></a> “how does Magnitudo appear here under contraction?” ============================================================ I. DOCTRINAL BASIS TENET A supplies: • Magnitudo as canonical dignity • its fixed ordinal token: Ⅱ / C • its canonical phrase: "Magnitudo est, per quam bonum est magnum." • distinction between pure and contracted use • correlative necessity • proper / appropriated distinction ALBUS FIGURA PRIMA supplies touchstone insight for: • contraction ladder • partialization outside pure field • convertibility limits outside pure field • discrimination of convertibility • correlative grounding AREPO A supplies: • admissibility gates • binding requirements • degraded / blocked handling • convertibility discipline • correlative integrity gating BOUNDARY This template does not redefine Magnitudo. It defines a lawful evaluation procedure-template for <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-contracted-magnitudo-only"></a> contracted Magnitudo only. ============================================================ II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS Minimal input object: A_INPUT := { PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS TENET A bound AREPO A admitted subject anchor present minimum Q support present minimum T support present If any mandatory precondition fails: BLOCK via AREPO A MAGNITUDO EVALUATION UNIT MAGNITUDO_PREDICATE_COLUMN_COMPONENT := <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-evaluate-magnitudo-under-contraction-on-bound-referent-x"></a> evaluate one admitted PRED(i,C), i != C, under contraction ============================================================ III. MAGNITUDO — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅱ / C Canonical noun: Magnitudo Lexical lemma: Magnus Contracted citation form: Magnum Canonical phrase: "Magnitudo est, per quam bonum est magnum." Minimal doctrinal reading: Magnitudo is that by reason of which a thing possesses principial amplitude, extensiveness, elevation, fullness, or intensification according to its mode. EXECUTION INTERPRETATION For contracted evaluation purposes, Magnitudo is read through: • amplitude of power, scope, or reach • intensity or fullness of principial participation • structural extensiveness without collapse • capacity to sustain enlarged order or significance • non-trivial scale of effect, meaning, or coherence Magnitudo is weakened when: • largeness is only apparent or rhetorical • size lacks coherence, order, or principial support • excess becomes dispersion or inflation • extension is claimed without stable ground • quantity is confused with greatness <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-amplification-destroys-proportion"></a> • amplification destroys proportion ============================================================ IV. EVALUATION DIMENSIONS Each carrier in the Magnitudo predicate column resolves five evaluation dimensions: 1. PRESENCE_MODE 2. CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT 3. CORRELATIVE_PROFILE 4. ATTRIBUTION_MODE 5. DISTORTION_FLAGS <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-no-numeric-score-is-permitted"></a> No numeric score is permitted. ============================================================ V. DIMENSION 1 — PRESENCE MODE Allowed states: • STRONG • MODERATE • WEAK • DEFORMED • ABSENT V.1 — STRONG Assign STRONG iff all are true: 1. the subject exhibits real amplitude, extensiveness, or principial largeness, not merely superficial scale 2. the enlargement is coherent and structurally supportable 3. the extension does not destroy proportion or order 4. Magnitudo is explanatory, not decorative 5. T-contrariety does not dominate 6. some correlative coherence is preserved Interpretation: Magnitudo is genuinely present under contraction as a principial enlargement or fullness of the subject. V.2 — MODERATE Assign MODERATE iff: 1. some amplitude or principial extensiveness is present 2. greatness is real but partial, local, or condition-bound 3. coherence exists but remains incomplete 4. extension is meaningful but not fully stabilized 5. contrariety exists but does not dominate Interpretation: Magnitudo is meaningfully present, but not strongly stabilized. V.3 — WEAK Assign WEAK iff: 1. Magnitudo is only thinly demonstrable 2. extension is narrow, fragile, or weakly grounded 3. largeness depends heavily on external framing 4. correlative expression is shallow 5. convertibility toward other dignities is hard to defend Interpretation: Magnitudo is plausible but only weakly instantiated. V.4 — DEFORMED Assign DEFORMED iff: 1. the language of greatness is present 2. but the apparent largeness is inflated, disordered, disproportionate, empty, or self-undermining 3. extension becomes excess without principial integrity 4. greatness functions as bloat, domination, vanity, or incoherent overreach Interpretation: this is not a stable contracted Magnitudo, but a damaged or misformed appearance of it. V.5 — ABSENT Assign ABSENT iff: 1. no principial greatness can be demonstrated 2. no meaningful amplitude, fullness, or extensiveness is present 3. Magnitudo adds no principial explanatory value 4. the claim of greatness is empty, decorative, or misplaced Interpretation: <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-magnitudo-is-not-lawfully-present-in-the-current-reading"></a> Magnitudo is not lawfully present in the current reading. ============================================================ VI. DIMENSION 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT Allowed states: • NEAR_INTEGRAL • STABLE_CONTRACTED • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • BROKEN VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL Use only when: • path is highly refined • Magnitudo coheres strongly with Bonitas, Duratio, Potestas, Veritas, and Gloria • contrariety is minimal • the greatness is full without disproportion • correlative coherence is balanced Constraint: this is still contracted, not pure integral plenitude. VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED Use when: • Magnitudo is real, coherent, and structurally intelligible • amplitude is supported by order and not by inflation • no major contradiction breaks the greatness-claim • attribution is proper or strongly defensible VI.3 — PARTIAL Use when: • some principial greatness is present • but convertibility remains incomplete • support is narrow, uneven, or condition-specific • tensions remain unresolved VI.4 — FRAGMENTED Use when: • greatness appears in isolated traits only • coherence with Bonitas, Veritas, Virtus, or Duratio is poor • extension is unstable or disproportionate • correlative structure is thin VI.5 — BROKEN Use when: • a Magnitudo-reading cannot sustain principial coherence • greatness collapses into inflation, rhetoric, or excess • coherence is too compromised for lawful A-use RULE Convertibility effect is never inferred from size-language alone. It must be justified by principial coherence under T and by <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-the-correlative-attribution-state"></a> the correlative/attribution state. ============================================================ VII. DIMENSION 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE Allowed states: • BALANCED • AGENT_DOMINANT • PATIENT_DOMINANT • ACT_DOMINANT • INCOMPLETE MINIMAL MODEL Magnitudo may appear through: • AGENT = that which amplifies, enlarges, or intensifies • PATIENT = that which is enlarged, intensified, or fulfilled • ACT = the magnifying or great-making relation itself VII.1 — BALANCED Assign when all three dimensions are materially present and mutually coherent. Interpretation: strongest contracted correlative state VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT Assign when: • source of amplification is primary • magnifying agency is clearer than the bearer or act-field Example pattern: a subject whose expansive power is clearer than the stable field receiving that greatness VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT Assign when: • the subject chiefly appears as bearer of greatness • greatness is received, held, or displayed more than produced VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT Assign when: • the magnifying relation is clearer than stable bearer roles • process of amplification dominates over fixed source/recipient VII.5 — INCOMPLETE Assign when: • only one side is plausibly visible • triadic structure cannot be stabilized • greatness is asserted with poor structural articulation RULE Correlative profile does not by itself decide admissibility. <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-but-it-materially-conditions-strength-and-reuse-readiness"></a> But it materially conditions strength and reuse readiness. ============================================================ VIII. DIMENSION 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE Allowed states: • PROPER • APPROPRIATED • MISATTRIBUTED VIII.1 — PROPER Assign when Magnitudo belongs to the subject in a way that is: • intrinsic • structurally grounded • native to the subject's principial profile • not merely comparative rhetoric VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED Assign when Magnitudo is present through: • derivative extension • contextual largeness • secondary participation • mediated or comparative greatness This remains lawful, but not integral. VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED Assign when Magnitudo is claimed but: • quantity is mistaken for greatness • scale is confused with principial amplitude • another dignity or predicate fits better • the greatness-claim is decorative or inflated RULE MISATTRIBUTED Magnitudo strongly pressures the result toward: • DEFORMED • ABSENT <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-or-blocked"></a> • or BLOCKED ============================================================ IX. DIMENSION 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS Possible flags: • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT • ASYMMETRY_HIGH • CAUSAL_GAP • SUBJECT_MISMATCH • OVEREXTENSION • CORRELATIVE_THINNESS • ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY • QUANTITY_CONFUSION • INFLATION_WITHOUT_GROUND FLAG LOGIC CONTRARIETY_PRESENT greatness conflicts materially with the current structure ASYMMETRY_HIGH one correlative side dominates excessively CAUSAL_GAP Q/E support for why this is great is weak SUBJECT_MISMATCH the substrate does not support this dignity well OVEREXTENSION Magnitudo is being projected too broadly or beyond the lawful scope of the case CORRELATIVE_THINNESS triadic structure is too weak ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY proper/appropriated status is unclear or unstable QUANTITY_CONFUSION mere amount is being mistaken for principial greatness INFLATION_WITHOUT_GROUND <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-enlargement-is-asserted-without-structural-basis"></a> enlargement is asserted without structural basis ============================================================ X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR MAGNITUDO Each admitted PRED(i,C), i != C, must be evaluated through relevant T predicates. T-B — DIFFERENCE Question: is Magnitudo structurally distinct here without confusion with quantity, power, or glory? Effect: prevents collapse into vague largeness-language T-C — CONCORDANCE Question: does the greatness cohere with the structure it belongs to? Effect: strengthens STRONG / MODERATE states T-D — CONTRARIETY Question: does the apparent greatness become self-undermining, disproportionate, or destructive? Effect: strongest negative pressure on Magnitudo T-E — BEGINNING Question: is Magnitudo functioning as originating amplitude or source? Effect: strengthens AGENT_DOMINANT readings T-F — MIDDLE Question: is Magnitudo mediating enlargement, extension, or amplification between terms? Effect: strengthens ACT_DOMINANT or BALANCED readings T-G — END Question: does the greatness terminate in fuller realization, or only in expansion without end? Effect: critical for stable Magnitudo T-H — MAJORITY Question: is Magnitudo the dominant principial force in this reading? Effect: affects ranking, not validity by itself T-I — EQUALITY Question: is the greatness proportionate and balanced with the other relevant dignities? Effect: strengthens convertibility effect T-K — MINORITY Question: is Magnitudo only marginal, attenuated, or rhetorically claimed without strong structural basis? Effect: <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-strengthens-weak-fragmented-readings"></a> strengthens WEAK / FRAGMENTED readings ============================================================ XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS FOR MAGNITUDO Minimal rule-support required: • Q-C (what is this?) • Q-E (why is this Magnitudo?) • Q-G (what quality is being claimed?) Recommended additional support: • Q-F (how much / in what degree?) • Q-D (of what / from what?) • Q-K1 (how?) • Q-K2 (with what mediation?) RULE Without at least C + E + G support, Magnitudo classification must be degraded or blocked. INTERPRETATION Q-C stabilizes object Q-E stabilizes causal claim Q-G stabilizes qualitative claim <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-q-f-helps-prevent-quantity-confusion"></a> Q-F helps prevent quantity-confusion ============================================================ XII. DECISION LOGIC Evaluation order: 1. verify AREPO admissibility 2. verify subject binding 3. verify Q-min support 4. inspect T tensions / concordances 5. determine presence mode 6. determine correlative profile 7. determine attribution mode 8. determine convertibility effect 9. attach distortion flags 10. emit Magnitudo result object RULE No later step may silently override an earlier failure <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-without-explicit-justification"></a> without explicit justification. ============================================================ XIII. MAGNITUDO RESULT OBJECT Recommended output structure: MAGNITUDO_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-3"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅱ / C <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-4"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: <STRONG | MODERATE | WEAK | DEFORMED | ABSENT> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-4"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: <NEAR_INTEGRAL | STABLE_CONTRACTED | PARTIAL | FRAGMENTED | BROKEN> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-4"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: <BALANCED | AGENT_DOMINANT | PATIENT_DOMINANT | ACT_DOMINANT | INCOMPLETE> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-4"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: <PROPER | APPROPRIATED | MISATTRIBUTED> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-4"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-support-2"></a> T_SUPPORT: { CONCORDANCE: ... CONTRARIETY: ... BEGINNING: ... MIDDLE: ... END: ... EQUALITY: ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-3"></a> JUSTIFICATION: concise structured rationale } JUSTIFICATION RULE Rationale must be: • structural • explicit • non-rhetorical <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-non-numeric"></a> • non-numeric ============================================================ XIV. EXAMPLE — ABSTRACT TEMPLATE ONLY Input case: x = a bounded institution, action, system, or subject claimed to be great Possible result: MAGNITUDO_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-4"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅱ / C <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-5"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: MODERATE <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-5"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: PARTIAL <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-5"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: PATIENT_DOMINANT <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-5"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: APPROPRIATED <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-5"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { QUANTITY_CONFUSION, CAUSAL_GAP } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-4"></a> JUSTIFICATION: some real extensiveness or amplitude is present, but principial greatness is only partially grounded; the subject bears signs of greatness more than it generates them, and explanatory support remains incomplete } EXAMPLE STATUS METHOD_TEMPLATE <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-this-example-illustrates-output-form-not-a-canon-judgment"></a> This example illustrates output form, not a canon judgment. ============================================================ XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS Magnitudo evaluation must be blocked or degraded when: • no subject is bound • no causal basis for greatness is available • quantity is substituted for greatness without correction • contrariety dominates but is ignored • attribution is misassigned without acknowledgment • greatness is asserted rhetorically with no principial support • pure plenitude is claimed in a bounded applied case BLOCK-PRESSURE CONDITIONS Strong block pressure occurs when: • PRESENCE_MODE = ABSENT • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT = BROKEN • CORRELATIVE_PROFILE = INCOMPLETE • ATTRIBUTION_MODE = MISATTRIBUTED • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT is load-bearing <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-quantity-confusion-is-uncorrected-and-central"></a> • QUANTITY_CONFUSION is uncorrected and central ============================================================ XVI. REUSE READINESS Magnitudo result may be reused downstream only if: • validity is not BLOCKED • convertibility effect is not BROKEN • attribution mode is not MISATTRIBUTED • correlative profile is not INCOMPLETE in a load-bearing way • distortion flags do not forbid combinatory carry-forward REUSE CLASSES COMBINATORIALLY_READY lawful to pass downstream with normal caution READY_WITH_FLAGS lawful only if attached warnings are preserved NOT_READY do not silently reuse in D / TERTIA / QUARTA RULE Reuse readiness must be explicit. <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-silent-reuse-is-forbidden"></a> Silent reuse is forbidden. ============================================================ XVII. RELATION TO OTHER DIGNITIES Magnitudo has especially important interaction surfaces with: • Bonitas • Duratio • Potestas • Veritas • Gloria INTERACTION NOTE Magnitudo is strengthened when greatness is: • good rather than merely large • durable rather than momentary inflation • powerful without disorder • true rather than rhetorical • glorious by repose and fulfillment, not spectacle alone Magnitudo is weakened when: • it lacks Bonitas • it lacks Duratio • it lacks Veritas • it expands without proper end • it collapses into quantity alone BOUNDARY These interactions inform evaluation, <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-but-do-not-yet-require-full-multi-dignity-orchestration"></a> but do not yet require full multi-dignity orchestration. ============================================================ XVIII. FUNCTION The OPERA A(C) predicate-column template governs: • deterministic contracted evaluation of Magnitudo • principial discrimination between greatness and non-principial largeness • structured assessment of Magnitudo strength • correlative profile of magnifying structure • convertibility impact under contraction • explicit reuse-readiness for downstream operations Each OPERA A(C) carrier evaluation is: • carrier-atomic • deterministic • qualitative • rule-structured • non-numeric <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-composable-into-future-master-opera-a"></a> • composable into future master OPERA A ============================================================ XIX. SUMMARY Magnitudo in pure REGIMEN_A is fully convertible and integral. Magnitudo contributes in OPERA A(C) only through off-diagonal carrier evaluation under contraction and the derived CON_C summary. This artifact provides: • qualitative states • deterministic rule-lenses • correlative interpretation • convertibility discipline • distortion handling • structured output object Thus OPERA A(C) is a lawful predicate-column component for evaluating each admitted PRED(i,C), i != C; its result contributes only through Summary(ROTA_A.CON.C). It evaluates how greatness appears in a bound case without collapsing into: • quantity only • rhetorical praise • hidden heuristics <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-numeric-scoring"></a> • numeric scoring ============================================================ END OF OPERA A(C) — OPERA MAGNITUDO ============================================================ OPERA A(D) — OPERA DURATIO Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Execution Template Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-DURATIO-TEMPLATE Status: PROPOSED / TEMPLATE / CANONICAL-SEED Scope: deterministic qualitative evaluation model for Duratio Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-6"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-7"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ This template defines how OPERA A should evaluate the Duratio predicate column through admitted PRED(i,D), i != D, under contracted use without: • numeric scoring • loose analogy • hidden heuristics • silent doctrinal mutation It establishes a deterministic qualitative rule model for: • presence of Duratio in a bound subject • correlative profile of Duratio • convertibility impact under contraction • attribution mode • distortion flags • output discipline This is not yet the full OPERA A artifact. It is the canonical seed-template for one dignity. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-6"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Duratio in pure REGIMEN_A is integral and fully convertible. Duratio in OPERA A is never evaluated as pure integral plenitude. REFERENCE_ONLY cites the L0 ABS locus and performs no OPERA evaluation. Thus: OPERA A never asks: “is this absolute Duratio in itself?” OPERA A asks: “how does Duratio appear here under contraction?” ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-4"></a> I. DOCTRINAL BASIS ============================================================ TENET A supplies: • Duratio as canonical dignity • its fixed ordinal token: Ⅲ / D • its canonical phrase: "Duratio est, per quam bonum durat." • distinction between pure and contracted use • correlative necessity • proper / appropriated distinction ALBUS FIGURA PRIMA supplies touchstone insight for: • contraction ladder • persistence under limitation • temporal and structural stability • discrimination of endurance vs momentariness • correlative grounding AREPO A supplies: • admissibility gates • binding requirements • degraded / blocked handling • convertibility discipline • correlative integrity gating ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-2"></a> BOUNDARY ------------------------------------------------------------ This template does not redefine Duratio. It defines a lawful evaluation procedure-template for contracted Duratio only. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-4"></a> II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal input object: A_INPUT := { PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-4"></a> MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. TENET A bound 2. AREPO A admitted 3. subject anchor present 4. minimum Q support present 5. minimum T support present If any mandatory precondition fails: BLOCK via AREPO A ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-duratio-evaluation-unit"></a> DURATIO EVALUATION UNIT ------------------------------------------------------------ DURATIO_PREDICATE_COLUMN_COMPONENT := evaluate one admitted PRED(i,D), i != D, under contraction ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-duratio-canonical-doctrinal-seed"></a> III. DURATIO — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED ============================================================ ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅲ / D Canonical noun: Duratio Legacy/contextual lexical lemma: Durabilis Contracted citation form: Durans Non-equivalence rule: Durans and Durabilis are not globally interchangeable; the selected semantic/correlative role and source trace must be explicit. Canonical phrase: "Duratio est, per quam bonum durat." Minimal doctrinal reading: Duratio is that by reason of which a being persists, endures, or remains in being according to its mode. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-2"></a> EXECUTION INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ For contracted evaluation purposes, Duratio is read through: • persistence through time or condition • resistance to dissolution or collapse • continuity of identity or function • stability under change • capacity to maintain structure or effect Duratio is weakened when: • existence is fleeting or discontinuous • persistence depends on unstable conditions • identity collapses under pressure • continuity is only apparent or rhetorical • endurance contradicts other principial structures ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-2"></a> IV. EVALUATION DIMENSIONS ============================================================ Each carrier in the Duratio predicate column resolves five evaluation dimensions: 1. PRESENCE_MODE 2. CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT 3. CORRELATIVE_PROFILE 4. ATTRIBUTION_MODE 5. DISTORTION_FLAGS No numeric score is permitted. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-2"></a> V. DIMENSION 1 — PRESENCE MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • STRONG • MODERATE • WEAK • DEFORMED • ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-2"></a> V.1 — STRONG ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign STRONG iff all are true: 1. the subject exhibits stable persistence across time or condition 2. continuity is structurally grounded, not accidental 3. identity or function is preserved under variation 4. endurance does not contradict coherence or order 5. T-contrariety does not dominate 6. correlative structure is preserved Interpretation: Duratio is genuinely present as principial endurance. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-2"></a> V.2 — MODERATE ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign MODERATE iff: 1. persistence exists but is conditional or limited 2. continuity is partially stable 3. endurance is real but not robust 4. minor disruption or instability is present Interpretation: Duratio is present but not fully stabilized. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-2"></a> V.3 — WEAK ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign WEAK iff: 1. persistence is minimal or fragile 2. continuity depends heavily on external support 3. identity shifts or degrades easily 4. endurance is difficult to defend structurally Interpretation: Duratio is weakly instantiated. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-2"></a> V.4 — DEFORMED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign DEFORMED iff: 1. persistence exists but in a distorted or pathological way 2. endurance contradicts Bonitas, Veritas, or order 3. continuity is maintained through corruption or inertia 4. what persists should not persist under principial reading Interpretation: this is a misformed persistence, not lawful Duratio. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-2"></a> V.5 — ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign ABSENT iff: 1. no persistence can be demonstrated 2. existence is transient without structural continuity 3. Duratio adds no explanatory value Interpretation: Duratio is not present. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-2"></a> VI. DIMENSION 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT ============================================================ Allowed states: • NEAR_INTEGRAL • STABLE_CONTRACTED • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-2"></a> VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use only when: • persistence is highly stable • Duratio coheres with Bonitas, Magnitudo, Veritas, etc. • identity is maintained across all relevant transformations ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-2"></a> VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • Duratio is stable and intelligible • persistence is coherent and lawful • no major contradiction breaks continuity ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-2"></a> VI.3 — PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • some continuity is preserved • but instability or interruption exists • support is incomplete ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-2"></a> VI.4 — FRAGMENTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • persistence appears in disconnected segments • continuity lacks coherence • identity shifts significantly ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-2"></a> VI.5 — BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • no stable continuity can be maintained • persistence collapses structurally • Duratio cannot be sustained as principial reading ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-46"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Convertibility must be justified through structural persistence, not duration in mere temporal sense alone. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-2"></a> VII. DIMENSION 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE ============================================================ Allowed states: • BALANCED • AGENT_DOMINANT • PATIENT_DOMINANT • ACT_DOMINANT • INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-2"></a> MINIMAL MODEL ------------------------------------------------------------ Duratio may appear through: • AGENT = that which sustains or preserves • PATIENT = that which is sustained or endures • ACT = the act of enduring or persisting ------------------------------------------------------------ RULES OMITTED FOR BREVITY STRUCTURALLY IDENTICAL TO A(B), A(C) (They follow identical assignment logic adapted to persistence) ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-2"></a> VIII. DIMENSION 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • PROPER • APPROPRIATED • MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-2"></a> VIII.1 — PROPER ------------------------------------------------------------ Duratio belongs intrinsically to the subject. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-2"></a> VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED ------------------------------------------------------------ Duratio appears through conditional or external persistence. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-2"></a> VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Persistence is claimed but not structurally grounded. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-47"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Misattribution pushes toward DEFORMED / ABSENT. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-2"></a> IX. DIMENSION 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS ============================================================ Possible flags: • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT • ASYMMETRY_HIGH • CAUSAL_GAP • SUBJECT_MISMATCH • OVEREXTENSION • CORRELATIVE_THINNESS • ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY • FRAGILE_CONTINUITY • FALSE_PERMANENCE ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-2"></a> FLAG LOGIC ------------------------------------------------------------ FRAGILE_CONTINUITY persistence exists but easily collapses FALSE_PERMANENCE something appears stable but is not structurally grounded ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-duratio"></a> X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR DURATIO ============================================================ Key checks: • T-D (Contrariety): breaks persistence • T-G (End): confirms sustained completion • T-F (Middle): confirms continuity process • T-I (Equality): confirms proportional stability Duratio fails when persistence contradicts coherence. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements"></a> XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal: • Q-C • Q-E • Q-G Additional: • Q-H (when?) • Q-K1 (how?) • Q-K2 (through what?) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-48"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Without causal + temporal grounding, Duratio degrades. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-2"></a> XII. DECISION LOGIC ============================================================ Same deterministic sequence as OPERA A(B), A(C) ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-duratio-result-object"></a> XIII. DURATIO RESULT OBJECT ============================================================ DURATIO_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-5"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅲ / D <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-6"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-6"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-6"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-6"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-6"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-5"></a> JUSTIFICATION: structural rationale } ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-template"></a> XIV. EXAMPLE — TEMPLATE ============================================================ DURATIO_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { PRESENCE_MODE: MODERATE CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: PARTIAL CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: PATIENT_DOMINANT ATTRIBUTION_MODE: APPROPRIATED DISTORTION_FLAGS: {FRAGILE_CONTINUITY} <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-6"></a> JUSTIFICATION: persistence exists but depends on unstable conditions } ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-2"></a> XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS ============================================================ Block or degrade when: • no persistence can be demonstrated • continuity is illusory • persistence contradicts principial coherence ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-2"></a> XVI. REUSE READINESS ============================================================ Same structure as A(B), A(C) ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function"></a> XVII. FUNCTION ============================================================ The OPERA A(D) predicate-column template governs: • evaluation of persistence under contraction • discrimination between endurance and mere duration • structural continuity assessment ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary"></a> XVIII. SUMMARY ============================================================ Duratio is evaluated as principial persistence, not mere time. Its PRED(i,D) carrier payloads and CON_D summary ensure: • lawful endurance reading • no collapse into temporal heuristics • deterministic structural evaluation ============================================================ END OF OPERA A(D) — OPERA DURATIO ============================================================ ============================================================ OPERA A(E) — OPERA POTESTAS Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Execution Template Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-POTESTAS-TEMPLATE Status: PROPOSED / TEMPLATE / CANONICAL-SEED Scope: deterministic qualitative evaluation model for Potestas Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-7"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-8"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ This template defines how OPERA A should evaluate the Potestas predicate column through admitted PRED(i,E), i != E, under contracted use without: • numeric scoring • loose analogy • hidden heuristics • silent doctrinal mutation It establishes a deterministic qualitative rule model for: • presence of Potestas in a bound subject • correlative profile of Potestas • convertibility impact under contraction • attribution mode • distortion flags • output discipline This is not yet the full OPERA A artifact. It is the canonical seed-template for one dignity. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-7"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Potestas in pure REGIMEN_A is integral and fully convertible. Potestas in OPERA A is never evaluated as pure integral plenitude. REFERENCE_ONLY cites the L0 ABS locus and performs no OPERA evaluation. Thus: OPERA A never asks: “is this absolute Potestas in itself?” OPERA A asks: “how does Potestas appear here under contraction?” ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-5"></a> I. DOCTRINAL BASIS ============================================================ TENET A supplies: • Potestas as canonical dignity • its fixed ordinal token: Ⅳ / E • its canonical phrase: "Potestas est, per quam bonum potest." • distinction between pure and contracted use • correlative necessity • proper / appropriated distinction ALBUS FIGURA PRIMA supplies touchstone insight for: • contraction ladder • capability vs actualization • distinction between potential, power, and act • discrimination between real capacity and apparent power • correlative grounding AREPO A supplies: • admissibility gates • binding requirements • degraded / blocked handling • convertibility discipline • correlative integrity gating ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-3"></a> BOUNDARY ------------------------------------------------------------ This template does not redefine Potestas. It defines a lawful evaluation procedure-template for contracted Potestas only. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-5"></a> II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal input object: A_INPUT := { PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-5"></a> MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. TENET A bound 2. AREPO A admitted 3. subject anchor present 4. minimum Q support present 5. minimum T support present If any mandatory precondition fails: BLOCK via AREPO A ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-potestas-evaluation-unit"></a> POTESTAS EVALUATION UNIT ------------------------------------------------------------ POTESTAS_PREDICATE_COLUMN_COMPONENT := evaluate one admitted PRED(i,E), i != E, under contraction ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-potestas-canonical-doctrinal-seed"></a> III. POTESTAS — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED ============================================================ ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅳ / E Canonical noun: Potestas Lexical lemma: Potens Contracted citation form: Potens Canonical phrase: "Potestas est, per quam bonum potest." Minimal doctrinal reading: Potestas is that by reason of which a being is capable of acting, producing, or effecting something. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-3"></a> EXECUTION INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ For contracted evaluation purposes, Potestas is read through: • real capacity to act or produce effects • ability to initiate, sustain, or modify processes • structural capability (not mere permission or claim) • alignment between potential and realizable act • coherence between capacity and outcome Potestas is weakened when: • capacity is claimed but not real • ability cannot be actualized • power is dependent on unstable conditions • capacity contradicts structure or coherence • potential is confused with intention or desire • power exists but cannot be exercised ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-3"></a> IV. EVALUATION DIMENSIONS ============================================================ Each carrier in the Potestas predicate column resolves five evaluation dimensions: 1. PRESENCE_MODE 2. CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT 3. CORRELATIVE_PROFILE 4. ATTRIBUTION_MODE 5. DISTORTION_FLAGS No numeric score is permitted. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-3"></a> V. DIMENSION 1 — PRESENCE MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • STRONG • MODERATE • WEAK • DEFORMED • ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-3"></a> V.1 — STRONG ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign STRONG iff all are true: 1. the subject has real, demonstrable capacity to act 2. capacity can be exercised in a structurally coherent way 3. potential aligns with realizable effect 4. power is not merely nominal or claimed 5. T-contrariety does not dominate 6. correlative structure is preserved Interpretation: Potestas is genuinely present as principial capacity. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-3"></a> V.2 — MODERATE ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign MODERATE iff: 1. capacity exists but is limited or conditional 2. realization is partial or situational 3. coherence is present but incomplete 4. ability is not fully stabilized Interpretation: Potestas is present but not fully robust. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-3"></a> V.3 — WEAK ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign WEAK iff: 1. capacity is minimal or fragile 2. realization depends heavily on external factors 3. potential is narrow or constrained 4. ability is difficult to actualize Interpretation: Potestas is weakly instantiated. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-3"></a> V.4 — DEFORMED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign DEFORMED iff: 1. power is present but misaligned or destructive 2. capacity contradicts Bonitas, Veritas, or coherence 3. ability exists but produces distortion or instability 4. potential is real but misused or corrupted Interpretation: Potestas exists but in a misformed or harmful mode. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-3"></a> V.5 — ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign ABSENT iff: 1. no real capacity can be demonstrated 2. ability is purely rhetorical or imaginary 3. Potestas adds no explanatory value Interpretation: Potestas is not present. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-3"></a> VI. DIMENSION 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT ============================================================ Allowed states: • NEAR_INTEGRAL • STABLE_CONTRACTED • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-3"></a> VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use only when: • capacity is stable, coherent, and widely applicable • Potestas integrates strongly with Bonitas, Magnitudo, Duratio, and Veritas • realization is consistently achievable ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-3"></a> VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • Potestas is real and structurally grounded • capacity can be exercised reliably • no major contradiction breaks ability ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-3"></a> VI.3 — PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • some capacity exists • realization is incomplete or inconsistent • support is limited ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-3"></a> VI.4 — FRAGMENTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • capacity appears in isolated cases only • ability lacks coherence across contexts • realization is unstable ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-3"></a> VI.5 — BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • Potestas cannot be sustained as a principial reading • capacity collapses under scrutiny • power is illusory or contradictory ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-49"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Convertibility must be grounded in real capacity, not declared power. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-3"></a> VII. DIMENSION 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE ============================================================ Allowed states: • BALANCED • AGENT_DOMINANT • PATIENT_DOMINANT • ACT_DOMINANT • INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-3"></a> MINIMAL MODEL ------------------------------------------------------------ Potestas may appear through: • AGENT = that which has capacity to act • PATIENT = that which can be acted upon • ACT = the realization or exercise of capacity ------------------------------------------------------------ RULES OMITTED FOR BREVITY (same structure as prior Operae) ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-3"></a> VIII. DIMENSION 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • PROPER • APPROPRIATED • MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-3"></a> VIII.1 — PROPER ------------------------------------------------------------ Potestas belongs intrinsically to the subject. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-3"></a> VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED ------------------------------------------------------------ The selected carrier's Potens attribution is derivative, mediated, or context-dependent; ABS_E / Potestas remains underived. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-3"></a> VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Capacity is claimed but not real. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-50"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Misattribution pushes toward DEFORMED / ABSENT. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-3"></a> IX. DIMENSION 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS ============================================================ Possible flags: • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT • ASYMMETRY_HIGH • CAUSAL_GAP • SUBJECT_MISMATCH • OVEREXTENSION • CORRELATIVE_THINNESS • ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY • FALSE_CAPACITY • NON_ACTUALIZABLE ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-3"></a> FLAG LOGIC ------------------------------------------------------------ FALSE_CAPACITY capacity is claimed but not real NON_ACTUALIZABLE potential exists but cannot be realized ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-potestas"></a> X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR POTESTAS ============================================================ Key checks: • T-E (Beginning): capacity to initiate • T-F (Middle): capacity to sustain process • T-G (End): capacity to complete effect • T-D (Contrariety): blocks or distorts capacity Potestas fails when capacity cannot be exercised coherently. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-2"></a> XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal: • Q-C • Q-E • Q-G Additional: • Q-K1 (how?) • Q-K2 (through what?) • Q-F (to what extent?) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-51"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Without causal grounding, Potestas degrades. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-3"></a> XII. DECISION LOGIC ============================================================ Same deterministic sequence as previous Operae. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-potestas-result-object"></a> XIII. POTESTAS RESULT OBJECT ============================================================ POTESTAS_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-6"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅳ / E <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-7"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-7"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-7"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-7"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-7"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-7"></a> JUSTIFICATION: structural rationale } ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-template-2"></a> XIV. EXAMPLE — TEMPLATE ============================================================ POTESTAS_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { PRESENCE_MODE: MODERATE CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: PARTIAL CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: AGENT_DOMINANT ATTRIBUTION_MODE: APPROPRIATED DISTORTION_FLAGS: {NON_ACTUALIZABLE} <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-8"></a> JUSTIFICATION: capacity exists but cannot be fully realized under current conditions } ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-3"></a> XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS ============================================================ Block or degrade when: • no real capacity exists • ability cannot be actualized • power is purely rhetorical ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-3"></a> XVI. REUSE READINESS ============================================================ Same structure as previous Operae. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function-2"></a> XVII. FUNCTION ============================================================ The OPERA A(E) predicate-column template governs: • evaluation of capacity under contraction • discrimination between real and apparent power • structural ability assessment ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary-2"></a> XVIII. SUMMARY ============================================================ Potestas is evaluated as real capacity to act, not mere possibility or claim. Its PRED(i,E) carrier payloads and CON_E summary ensure: • lawful capacity reading • no collapse into rhetorical power • deterministic structural evaluation ============================================================ END OF OPERA A(E) — OPERA POTESTAS ============================================================ ============================================================ OPERA A(F) — OPERA SAPIENTIA Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Execution Template Version: 0.2.0-OPERA-A-SAPIENTIA-TEMPLATE-PATCHED Status: PROPOSED / TEMPLATE / CANONICAL-SEED (CORRECTED) Scope: deterministic qualitative evaluation model for Sapientia Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-8"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-9"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ This template defines how OPERA A should evaluate the Sapientia predicate column through admitted PRED(i,F), i != F, under contracted use without: • numeric scoring • loose analogy • hidden heuristics • silent doctrinal mutation It establishes a deterministic qualitative rule model for: • presence of Sapientia in a bound subject • correlative profile of Sapientia • convertibility impact under contraction • attribution mode • distortion flags • output discipline ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-critical-correction-v0-2-0"></a> CRITICAL CORRECTION (v0.2.0) ------------------------------------------------------------ Sapientia is evaluated primarily as: • mediation • intelligible middle • form-bearing articulation • lawful relational ordering NOT primarily as: • knowledge possession • information accumulation • generic “understanding” This aligns Sapientia with: • T(F) — Medium • S(F) — Imago • Q(F) — Quantity (measured articulation) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-8"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Sapientia in pure REGIMEN_A is integral and fully convertible. Sapientia in OPERA A is never evaluated as pure integral plenitude. REFERENCE_ONLY cites the L0 ABS locus and performs no OPERA evaluation. Thus: OPERA A never asks: “is this absolute Sapientia in itself?” OPERA A asks: “how does Sapientia mediate and articulate here under contraction?” ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-6"></a> I. DOCTRINAL BASIS ============================================================ TENET A supplies: • Sapientia as canonical dignity • its fixed ordinal token: Ⅴ / F • its canonical phrase: "Sapientia est, per quam bonum sapit." • distinction between pure and contracted use • correlative necessity • proper / appropriated distinction ALBUS FIGURA PRIMA supplies: • mediation structure • form-bearing ordering • distinction between intelligible articulation vs confusion • relation between Sapientia, Veritas, and Bonitas AREPO A supplies: • admissibility gates • degraded / blocked handling • convertibility discipline ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-4"></a> BOUNDARY ------------------------------------------------------------ This template does not redefine Sapientia. It defines a lawful evaluation procedure-template for contracted Sapientia only. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-6"></a> II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ A_INPUT := { PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-6"></a> MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. TENET A bound 2. AREPO A admitted 3. subject anchor present 4. Q-min support present 5. T grounding present Failure → BLOCK via AREPO A ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-sapientia-evaluation-unit"></a> SAPIENTIA EVALUATION UNIT ------------------------------------------------------------ SAPIENTIA_PREDICATE_COLUMN_COMPONENT := evaluate one admitted PRED(i,F), i != F, as mediation ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-sapientia-canonical-doctrinal-seed"></a> III. SAPIENTIA — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED ============================================================ ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅴ / F Canonical noun: Sapientia Lexical lemma: Sapiens Contracted citation form: Sapiens Canonical phrase: "Sapientia est, per quam bonum sapit." Minimal doctrinal reading (corrected): Sapientia is that by reason of which a being becomes intelligibly ordered, meaning: it mediates, relates, and articulates according to principial coherence. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-corrected"></a> EXECUTION INTERPRETATION (CORRECTED) ------------------------------------------------------------ Sapientia is evaluated through: • presence of a lawful intelligible medium • adequation between terms through mediation • capacity to structure relations coherently • stability of articulated form • non-fragmented relational continuity Sapientia is weakened when: • mediation is missing or broken • relations are not intelligibly articulated • structure is present but incoherent • articulation collapses or fragments • mediation is merely rhetorical or decorative ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-4"></a> IV. EVALUATION DIMENSIONS ============================================================ 1. PRESENCE_MODE 2. CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT 3. CORRELATIVE_PROFILE 4. ATTRIBUTION_MODE 5. DISTORTION_FLAGS ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-corrected"></a> V. DIMENSION 1 — PRESENCE MODE (CORRECTED) ============================================================ ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-4"></a> V.1 — STRONG ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign STRONG iff: 1. a clear intelligible medium exists 2. relations are coherently articulated 3. mediation preserves structure across terms 4. articulation is stable (Duratio-aligned) 5. mediation serves principial coherence (Bonitas-aligned) 6. T-contrariety does not dominate Interpretation: Sapientia functions as a stable intelligible middle. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-4"></a> V.2 — MODERATE ------------------------------------------------------------ • mediation present but limited • articulation partial or incomplete • relations intelligible but not fully stabilized ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-4"></a> V.3 — WEAK ------------------------------------------------------------ • mediation thin or fragile • relations only partially articulated • structure difficult to sustain ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-4"></a> V.4 — DEFORMED ------------------------------------------------------------ • mediation exists but misorders relations • articulation leads to confusion or distortion • structure contradicts itself ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-4"></a> V.5 — ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ • no intelligible mediation present • no stable relation between terms • Sapientia adds no principial explanatory value ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-corrected"></a> VI. DIMENSION 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT (CORRECTED) ============================================================ Convertibility here measures: ability of mediation to integrate with other dignities ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-near-integral"></a> NEAR_INTEGRAL ------------------------------------------------------------ • mediation integrates Bonitas, Veritas, Potestas coherently • articulation is structurally complete ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-stable-contracted"></a> STABLE_CONTRACTED ------------------------------------------------------------ • mediation stable within domain • relations consistently intelligible ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-partial-5"></a> PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ • mediation works locally but not globally ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-fragmented"></a> FRAGMENTED ------------------------------------------------------------ • articulation broken across domains • relations inconsistent ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-broken-3"></a> BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ • mediation collapses • no coherent articulation possible ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-corrected"></a> VII. DIMENSION 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE (CORRECTED) ============================================================ Sapientia appears through: • AGENT = that which mediates • PATIENT = that which is mediated • ACT = the act of articulation ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-balanced"></a> BALANCED ------------------------------------------------------------ mediation, mediated, and act coherent ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-act-dominant"></a> ACT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ process of articulation is primary ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-agent-dominant-patient-dominant"></a> AGENT_DOMINANT / PATIENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ asymmetry in mediation roles ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-incomplete"></a> INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ mediation cannot be stabilized triadically ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-4"></a> VIII. DIMENSION 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE ============================================================ Same structure, but interpreted as: <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-proper"></a> PROPER: intrinsic mediating structure <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-appropriated"></a> APPROPRIATED: derivative or contextual mediation <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-misattributed"></a> MISATTRIBUTED: mediation claimed but absent or false ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-corrected"></a> IX. DIMENSION 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS (CORRECTED) ============================================================ Replace epistemic bias flags with mediation-based ones: • MEDIUM_ABSENT • MEDIUM_INADEQUATE • ARTICULATION_BREAKDOWN • RELATIONAL_INCOHERENCE • OVEREXTENSION • CORRELATIVE_THINNESS • ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-4"></a> FLAG LOGIC ------------------------------------------------------------ MEDIUM_ABSENT no intelligible bridge between terms ARTICULATION_BREAKDOWN relations collapse under examination RELATIONAL_INCOHERENCE structure contradicts itself ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-sapientia-corrected"></a> X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR SAPIENTIA (CORRECTED) ============================================================ ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-f-middle-primary-axis"></a> T-F — MIDDLE (PRIMARY AXIS) ------------------------------------------------------------ Core test: does a lawful medium exist? ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-c-concordance-4"></a> T-C — CONCORDANCE ------------------------------------------------------------ does mediation produce coherence? ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-d-contrariety-4"></a> T-D — CONTRARIETY ------------------------------------------------------------ does mediation contradict itself? ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-g-end-2"></a> T-G — END ------------------------------------------------------------ does mediation lead toward intelligible completion? ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-52"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Sapientia fails primarily through failure of mediation, not lack of knowledge. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-adjusted"></a> XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS (ADJUSTED) ============================================================ Required: • Q-C (what is being mediated?) • Q-E (why is mediation coherent?) • Q-K2 (through what medium?) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-53"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Sapientia cannot be evaluated without explicit medium. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-4"></a> XII. DECISION LOGIC ============================================================ Same sequence, but: mediation must be explicitly identified before evaluation ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-sapientia-result-object"></a> XIII. SAPIENTIA RESULT OBJECT ============================================================ SAPIENTIA_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-7"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅴ / F <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-8"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-8"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-8"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-8"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: ... <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-8"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-9"></a> JUSTIFICATION: mediation-based rationale } ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-template-corrected"></a> XIV. EXAMPLE — TEMPLATE (CORRECTED) ============================================================ SAPIENTIA_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { PRESENCE_MODE: MODERATE CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: PARTIAL CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: ACT_DOMINANT ATTRIBUTION_MODE: APPROPRIATED DISTORTION_FLAGS: {MEDIUM_INADEQUATE} <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-10"></a> JUSTIFICATION: a mediating structure is present but insufficiently stable to relate terms across the full domain } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status-2"></a> EXAMPLE STATUS ------------------------------------------------------------ METHOD_TEMPLATE ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-corrected"></a> XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS (CORRECTED) ============================================================ Block or degrade when: • no intelligible medium exists • relations cannot be articulated • mediation contradicts itself • structure collapses under T-analysis ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-function-corrected"></a> XVI. FUNCTION (CORRECTED) ============================================================ The OPERA A(F) predicate-column template governs: • evaluation of mediation under contraction • discrimination between lawful and broken articulation • structural intelligibility assessment ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-summary-corrected"></a> XVII. SUMMARY (CORRECTED) ============================================================ Sapientia is evaluated as: intelligible mediation, not epistemic possession. Its PRED(i,F) carrier payloads and CON_F summary ensure: • no collapse into knowledge-centric evaluation • alignment with T(F) / Medium • deterministic structural mediation analysis ============================================================ END OF OPERA A(F) — OPERA SAPIENTIA ============================================================ ============================================================ OPERA A(G) — OPERA VOLUNTAS Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Execution Template Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-VOLUNTAS-TEMPLATE Status: PROPOSED / TEMPLATE / CANONICAL-SEED Scope: deterministic qualitative evaluation model for Voluntas Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-9"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-10"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ This template defines how OPERA A should evaluate the Voluntas predicate column through admitted PRED(i,G), i != G, under contracted use without: • numeric scoring • loose analogy • hidden heuristics • silent doctrinal mutation It establishes a deterministic qualitative rule model for: • presence of Voluntas in a bound subject • correlative profile of Voluntas • convertibility impact under contraction • attribution mode • distortion flags • output discipline This is not yet the full OPERA A artifact. It is the canonical seed-template for one dignity. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-9"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Voluntas in pure REGIMEN_A is integral and fully convertible. Voluntas in OPERA A is never evaluated as pure integral plenitude. REFERENCE_ONLY cites the L0 ABS locus and performs no OPERA evaluation. Thus: OPERA A never asks: “is this absolute Voluntas in itself?” OPERA A asks: “how does Voluntas appear here under contraction?” ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-7"></a> I. DOCTRINAL BASIS ============================================================ TENET A supplies: • Voluntas as canonical dignity • its fixed ordinal token: Ⅵ / G • its canonical phrase: "Voluntas est, per quam bonum vult." • distinction between pure and contracted use • correlative necessity • proper / appropriated distinction ALBUS FIGURA PRIMA supplies touchstone insight for: • relation between Voluntas and Bonitas (desired good) • relation between Voluntas and Sapientia (guided will) • contraction effects on intentionality • correlative grounding AREPO A supplies: • admissibility gates • binding requirements • degraded / blocked handling • convertibility discipline • correlative integrity gating ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-5"></a> BOUNDARY ------------------------------------------------------------ This template does not redefine Voluntas. It defines a lawful evaluation procedure-template for contracted Voluntas only. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-7"></a> II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal input object: A_INPUT := { PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-7"></a> MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. TENET A bound 2. AREPO A admitted 3. subject anchor present 4. minimum Q support present 5. minimum T support present If any mandatory precondition fails: BLOCK via AREPO A ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-voluntas-evaluation-unit"></a> VOLUNTAS EVALUATION UNIT ------------------------------------------------------------ VOLUNTAS_PREDICATE_COLUMN_COMPONENT := evaluate one admitted PRED(i,G), i != G, under contraction ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-voluntas-canonical-doctrinal-seed"></a> III. VOLUNTAS — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED ============================================================ ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅵ / G Canonical noun: Voluntas Lexical lemma: Volens Contracted citation form: Volens Canonical phrase: "Voluntas est, per quam bonum vult." Minimal doctrinal reading: Voluntas is that by reason of which good is willed, meaning the principial inclination or intentional orientation toward perceived good. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-4"></a> EXECUTION INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ For contracted evaluation purposes, Voluntas is read through: • intentional orientation toward an end • commitment to pursue or realize a perceived good • alignment (or misalignment) between will and good • stability or instability of volitional direction • relation between desire, action, and judgment Voluntas is weakened when: • intention is unstable or inconsistent • will contradicts perceived good • desire is misaligned with Bonitas • action does not follow intention • will is externally imposed without internal grounding • intention is rhetorical or superficial ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-5"></a> IV. EVALUATION DIMENSIONS ============================================================ Each carrier in the Voluntas predicate column resolves five evaluation dimensions: 1. PRESENCE_MODE 2. CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT 3. CORRELATIVE_PROFILE 4. ATTRIBUTION_MODE 5. DISTORTION_FLAGS No numeric score is permitted. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-4"></a> V. DIMENSION 1 — PRESENCE MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • STRONG • MODERATE • WEAK • DEFORMED • ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-5"></a> V.1 — STRONG ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign STRONG iff all are true: 1. a clear and stable intention is present 2. will is directed toward a coherent good (Bonitas-aligned) 3. intention and action are aligned 4. T-contrariety does not dominate 5. correlative coherence is preserved (agent-act-end linkage) 6. will is internally grounded, not merely imposed Interpretation: Voluntas is genuinely operative and principially aligned. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-5"></a> V.2 — MODERATE ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign MODERATE iff: 1. intention is present but partially unstable 2. will aims at good but with inconsistency 3. alignment between intention and action is incomplete 4. some contrariety exists but does not dominate Interpretation: Voluntas is present but not fully stabilized. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-5"></a> V.3 — WEAK ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign WEAK iff: 1. intention is weak or fluctuating 2. will lacks commitment or continuity 3. action is weakly connected to intention 4. volitional coherence is minimal Interpretation: Voluntas is thinly instantiated. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-5"></a> V.4 — DEFORMED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign DEFORMED iff: 1. intention is present but misdirected 2. will contradicts Bonitas or principial coherence 3. desire leads toward destructive or incoherent ends 4. apparent will functions against its own claimed good Interpretation: Voluntas is present but misformed or corrupted. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-5"></a> V.5 — ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign ABSENT iff: 1. no meaningful intention is present 2. no stable volitional orientation can be identified 3. attribution is empty or irrelevant Interpretation: Voluntas is not present. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-4"></a> VI. DIMENSION 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT ============================================================ Allowed states: • NEAR_INTEGRAL • STABLE_CONTRACTED • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-4"></a> VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use only when: • will is highly aligned with Bonitas and Sapientia • intention, understanding, and action are coherent • minimal contrariety exists ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-4"></a> VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • Voluntas coheres with other dignities • intention is intelligible and sustained • action follows will consistently ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-4"></a> VI.3 — PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • intention is present but incomplete • alignment is partial • coherence is limited ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-4"></a> VI.4 — FRAGMENTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • multiple conflicting intentions exist • will lacks stable direction • coherence across actions is weak ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-4"></a> VI.5 — BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • Voluntas cannot sustain principial coherence • intention collapses or contradicts itself • will is incoherent or self-canceling ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-54"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Convertibility depends on alignment between will, good, and reasoning — not mere presence of desire. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-4"></a> VII. DIMENSION 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE ============================================================ Allowed states: • BALANCED • AGENT_DOMINANT • PATIENT_DOMINANT • ACT_DOMINANT • INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-4"></a> MINIMAL MODEL ------------------------------------------------------------ Voluntas may appear through: • AGENT = that which wills • PATIENT = that which is willed (object of will) • ACT = the act of willing ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-1-balanced-2"></a> VII.1 — BALANCED ------------------------------------------------------------ All three are coherent and aligned. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-2-agent-dominant-2"></a> VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Will originates strongly, object/end less clear. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-3-patient-dominant-2"></a> VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Object of desire dominates, agent unclear or weak. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-4-act-dominant-2"></a> VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Act of willing dominates without stable grounding. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-5-incomplete-2"></a> VII.5 — INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ Correlative structure cannot be stabilized. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-5"></a> VIII. DIMENSION 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • PROPER • APPROPRIATED • MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-4"></a> VIII.1 — PROPER ------------------------------------------------------------ Voluntas belongs intrinsically to the subject. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-4"></a> VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED ------------------------------------------------------------ The selected carrier's Volens attribution is derivative, mediated, or externally influenced; ABS_G / Voluntas remains underived. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-4"></a> VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Voluntas is claimed but: • intention is absent or irrelevant • action is externally forced without volition • another dignity better explains the case ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-55"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Misattribution pushes toward DEFORMED / ABSENT. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-4"></a> IX. DIMENSION 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS ============================================================ Possible flags: • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT • ASYMMETRY_HIGH • CAUSAL_GAP • SUBJECT_MISMATCH • OVEREXTENSION • CORRELATIVE_THINNESS • ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY • WILL_INCOHERENCE • END_MISALIGNMENT ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-5"></a> FLAG LOGIC ------------------------------------------------------------ WILL_INCOHERENCE intention contradicts itself or shifts unpredictably END_MISALIGNMENT will targets ends inconsistent with Bonitas ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-voluntas"></a> X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR VOLUNTAS ============================================================ Key checks: • T-E (Beginning): source of intention • T-F (Middle): mediation between intention and action • T-G (End): target of will • T-D (Contrariety): conflicting intentions Voluntas fails when intention and end are incoherent. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-3"></a> XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal: • Q-C • Q-E • Q-G Additional: • Q-K1 (how intention is enacted) • Q-K2 (through what mediation) • Q-F (degree of commitment) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-56"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Without causal grounding of intention, Voluntas must be degraded or blocked. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-5"></a> XII. DECISION LOGIC ============================================================ Evaluation order: 1. verify AREPO admissibility 2. verify subject binding 3. verify Q-min support 4. inspect T tensions / concordances 5. determine presence mode 6. determine correlative profile 7. determine attribution mode 8. determine convertibility effect 9. attach distortion flags 10. emit Voluntas result object ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-voluntas-result-object"></a> XIII. VOLUNTAS RESULT OBJECT ============================================================ VOLUNTAS_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-8"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅵ / G <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-9"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: <...> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-9"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: <...> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-9"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: <...> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-9"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: <...> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-9"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-11"></a> JUSTIFICATION: structural rationale } ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-template-3"></a> XIV. EXAMPLE — TEMPLATE ============================================================ VOLUNTAS_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { PRESENCE_MODE: MODERATE CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: PARTIAL CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: AGENT_DOMINANT ATTRIBUTION_MODE: APPROPRIATED DISTORTION_FLAGS: {WILL_INCOHERENCE} <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-12"></a> JUSTIFICATION: intention is present but unstable and only partially aligned with a coherent good } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status-3"></a> EXAMPLE STATUS ------------------------------------------------------------ METHOD_TEMPLATE ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-4"></a> XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS ============================================================ Block or degrade when: • no intention can be identified • will contradicts itself fundamentally • action is detached from intention • good is claimed but not willed ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-4"></a> XVI. REUSE READINESS ============================================================ Voluntas result may be reused downstream only if: • validity is not BLOCKED • presence is not ABSENT • convertibility is not BROKEN • attribution is not MISATTRIBUTED ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function-3"></a> XVII. FUNCTION ============================================================ The OPERA A(G) predicate-column template governs: • evaluation of will under contraction • discrimination between coherent and incoherent intention • alignment of will with principial structure ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary-3"></a> XVIII. SUMMARY ============================================================ Voluntas is evaluated as principial willing toward good, not mere desire. Its PRED(i,G) carrier payloads and CON_G summary ensure: • lawful evaluation of intention • no collapse into psychological or rhetorical desire • deterministic structural assessment ============================================================ END OF OPERA A(G) — OPERA VOLUNTAS ============================================================ ============================================================ OPERA A(H) — OPERA VIRTUS Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Execution Template Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-VIRTUS-TEMPLATE Status: PROPOSED / TEMPLATE / CANONICAL-SEED Scope: deterministic qualitative evaluation model for Virtus Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-10"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-11"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ This template defines how OPERA A should evaluate the Virtus predicate column through admitted PRED(i,H), i != H, under contracted use without: • numeric scoring • loose analogy • hidden heuristics • silent doctrinal mutation It establishes a deterministic qualitative rule model for: • presence of Virtus in a bound subject • correlative profile of Virtus • convertibility impact under contraction • attribution mode • distortion flags • output discipline This is not yet the full OPERA A artifact. It is the canonical seed-template for one dignity. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-10"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Virtus in pure REGIMEN_A is integral and fully convertible. Virtus in OPERA A is never evaluated as pure integral plenitude. REFERENCE_ONLY cites the L0 ABS locus and performs no OPERA evaluation. Thus: OPERA A never asks: “is this absolute Virtus in itself?” OPERA A asks: “how does Virtus appear here under contraction?” ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-8"></a> I. DOCTRINAL BASIS ============================================================ TENET A supplies: • Virtus as canonical dignity • its fixed ordinal token: Ⅶ / H • its canonical phrase: "Virtus est, per quam bonum virtuosum est." • distinction between pure and contracted use • correlative necessity • proper / appropriated distinction ALBUS FIGURA PRIMA supplies touchstone insight for: • Virtus as operative power (efficacy) • relation between Virtus and Potestas (capacity vs act) • relation between Virtus and Voluntas (will vs execution) • contraction effects on efficacy AREPO A supplies: • admissibility gates • binding requirements • degraded / blocked handling • convertibility discipline • correlative integrity gating ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-semantic-clarification-non-doctrinal"></a> SEMANTIC CLARIFICATION (NON-DOCTRINAL) ------------------------------------------------------------ Virtus (as dignity) is not identical to specific virtues (e.g., temperance, justice, courage). Those are: • contracted moral instruments • belonging to SK (instrumental domain) Virtus (A-layer) is: • principial efficacy • power-to-act in realization of good ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-6"></a> BOUNDARY ------------------------------------------------------------ This template does not redefine Virtus. It defines a lawful evaluation procedure-template for contracted Virtus only. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-8"></a> II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal input object: A_INPUT := { PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-8"></a> MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. TENET A bound 2. AREPO A admitted 3. subject anchor present 4. minimum Q support present 5. minimum T support present If any mandatory precondition fails: BLOCK via AREPO A ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-virtus-evaluation-unit"></a> VIRTUS EVALUATION UNIT ------------------------------------------------------------ VIRTUS_PREDICATE_COLUMN_COMPONENT := evaluate one admitted PRED(i,H), i != H, under contraction ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-virtus-canonical-doctrinal-seed"></a> III. VIRTUS — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED ============================================================ ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅶ / H Canonical noun: Virtus Lexical lemma: Virtuosus Contracted citation form: Virtuosum Canonical phrase: "Virtus est, per quam bonum virtuosum est." Minimal doctrinal reading: Virtus is that by reason of which good is made effective, meaning the operative force that actualizes good. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-5"></a> EXECUTION INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ For contracted evaluation purposes, Virtus is read through: • capacity to produce real effect • translation of will into execution • operational strength toward an end • resistance to obstruction or failure • efficacy of action within constraints Virtus is weakened when: • intention exists but produces no effect • action fails to realize its intended good • execution collapses under minimal resistance • power is claimed but not operative • effect is accidental rather than principial ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-6"></a> IV. EVALUATION DIMENSIONS ============================================================ Each carrier in the Virtus predicate column resolves five evaluation dimensions: 1. PRESENCE_MODE 2. CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT 3. CORRELATIVE_PROFILE 4. ATTRIBUTION_MODE 5. DISTORTION_FLAGS No numeric score is permitted. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-5"></a> V. DIMENSION 1 — PRESENCE MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • STRONG • MODERATE • WEAK • DEFORMED • ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-6"></a> V.1 — STRONG ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign STRONG iff all are true: 1. action produces consistent and intelligible effects 2. intended good is effectively realized 3. execution resists disruption or failure 4. relation to end (T-G) is successfully completed 5. correlative structure is stable (agent-act-effect) 6. attribution is not rhetorical Interpretation: Virtus is operative and effective. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-6"></a> V.2 — MODERATE ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign MODERATE iff: 1. effect is present but partially limited 2. execution succeeds in some cases but not all 3. resistance or inefficiency is noticeable 4. coherence is present but incomplete Interpretation: Virtus is functional but not fully stabilized. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-6"></a> V.3 — WEAK ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign WEAK iff: 1. effect is minimal or inconsistent 2. execution fails frequently 3. action has limited impact 4. other dignities dominate explanation Interpretation: Virtus is only marginally present. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-6"></a> V.4 — DEFORMED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign DEFORMED iff: 1. power is exercised but produces harmful or incoherent results 2. effect contradicts Bonitas or Sapientia 3. force operates without principial alignment 4. efficacy is misdirected Interpretation: Virtus is operative but corrupted. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-6"></a> V.5 — ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign ABSENT iff: 1. no effective action is present 2. no realization of intended good occurs 3. attribution is empty or irrelevant Interpretation: Virtus is not present. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-5"></a> VI. DIMENSION 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT ============================================================ Allowed states: • NEAR_INTEGRAL • STABLE_CONTRACTED • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-5"></a> VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use only when: • Virtus aligns with Bonitas, Voluntas, Sapientia • action, will, and understanding are coherent • effect is stable and proportional ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-5"></a> VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • Virtus reliably produces effect • no major contradictions occur • execution is intelligible and sustained ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-5"></a> VI.3 — PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • effect exists but is incomplete • execution is situational or unstable ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-5"></a> VI.4 — FRAGMENTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • effects are scattered or inconsistent • coherence with other dignities is weak ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-5"></a> VI.5 — BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • Virtus cannot sustain effective operation • effect collapses or contradicts structure ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-57"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Convertibility depends on stable efficacy, not declared power. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-5"></a> VII. DIMENSION 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE ============================================================ Allowed states: • BALANCED • AGENT_DOMINANT • PATIENT_DOMINANT • ACT_DOMINANT • INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-5"></a> MINIMAL MODEL ------------------------------------------------------------ Virtus may appear through: • AGENT = that which acts with power • PATIENT = that which is affected • ACT = the effective operation ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-1-balanced-3"></a> VII.1 — BALANCED ------------------------------------------------------------ All three are coherent and stable. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-2-agent-dominant-3"></a> VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Power is concentrated in source. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-3-patient-dominant-3"></a> VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Effect is emphasized more than source clarity. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-4-act-dominant-3"></a> VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Operation dominates over stable roles. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-5-incomplete-3"></a> VII.5 — INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ Correlative structure collapses. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-6"></a> VIII. DIMENSION 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • PROPER • APPROPRIATED • MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-5"></a> VIII.1 — PROPER ------------------------------------------------------------ Virtus is intrinsic to subject's operation. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-5"></a> VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED ------------------------------------------------------------ The selected carrier's Virtuosum attribution is mediated or derivative; ABS_H / Virtus remains underived. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-5"></a> VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Power is claimed but: • no real effect occurs • effect belongs to another dignity • attribution is rhetorical ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-58"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Misattribution pressures DEFORMED / ABSENT. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-5"></a> IX. DIMENSION 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS ============================================================ Possible flags: • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT • ASYMMETRY_HIGH • CAUSAL_GAP • SUBJECT_MISMATCH • OVEREXTENSION • CORRELATIVE_THINNESS • ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY • INEFFICACY • MISDIRECTED_POWER ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-6"></a> FLAG LOGIC ------------------------------------------------------------ INEFFICACY intended effect fails to materialize MISDIRECTED_POWER effect contradicts principial good ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-virtus"></a> X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR VIRTUS ============================================================ Key checks: • T-F (Middle): execution process • T-G (End): achieved effect • T-D (Contrariety): failure or opposition Virtus fails when effect does not follow act. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-4"></a> XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal: • Q-C • Q-E • Q-G Additional: • Q-K1 (how action is executed) • Q-K2 (instrument of execution) • Q-F (degree of effectiveness) ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-59"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Without demonstrable effect, Virtus must be degraded or blocked. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-6"></a> XII. DECISION LOGIC ============================================================ Evaluation order: 1. verify AREPO admissibility 2. verify subject binding 3. verify Q-min support 4. inspect T tensions / concordances 5. determine presence mode 6. determine correlative profile 7. determine attribution mode 8. determine convertibility effect 9. attach distortion flags 10. emit Virtus result object ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-virtus-result-object"></a> XIII. VIRTUS RESULT OBJECT ============================================================ VIRTUS_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-9"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅶ / H <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-10"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: <...> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-10"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: <...> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-10"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: <...> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-10"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: <...> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-10"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-13"></a> JUSTIFICATION: structural rationale } ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-template-4"></a> XIV. EXAMPLE — TEMPLATE ============================================================ VIRTUS_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { PRESENCE_MODE: MODERATE CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: PARTIAL CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: ACT_DOMINANT ATTRIBUTION_MODE: APPROPRIATED DISTORTION_FLAGS: {INEFFICACY} <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-14"></a> JUSTIFICATION: action produces some effect, but fails to consistently realize intended good } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status-4"></a> EXAMPLE STATUS ------------------------------------------------------------ METHOD_TEMPLATE ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-5"></a> XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS ============================================================ Block or degrade when: • no effect is demonstrable • action fails systematically • power contradicts principial structure • efficacy is purely rhetorical ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-5"></a> XVI. REUSE READINESS ============================================================ Virtus result may be reused downstream only if: • validity is not BLOCKED • presence is not ABSENT • convertibility is not BROKEN • attribution is not MISATTRIBUTED ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function-4"></a> XVII. FUNCTION ============================================================ The OPERA A(H) predicate-column template governs: • evaluation of principial efficacy • discrimination between real and claimed power • alignment between will and execution ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary-4"></a> XVIII. SUMMARY ============================================================ Virtus is evaluated as principial efficacy, not moral virtue categories. Its PRED(i,H) carrier payloads and CON_H summary ensure: • lawful evaluation of effective power • no collapse into moral labeling • deterministic structural assessment ============================================================ END OF OPERA A(H) — OPERA VIRTUS ============================================================ ============================================================ OPERA A(I) — OPERA VERITAS Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Execution Template Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-VERITAS-TEMPLATE Status: PROPOSED / TEMPLATE / CANONICAL-SEED Scope: deterministic qualitative evaluation model for Veritas Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-11"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-12"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ This template defines how OPERA A should evaluate the Veritas predicate column through admitted PRED(i,I), i != I, under contracted use without: • numeric scoring • loose analogy • hidden heuristics • silent doctrinal mutation It establishes a deterministic qualitative rule model for: • presence of Veritas in a bound subject • correlative profile of Veritas • convertibility impact under contraction • attribution mode • distortion flags • output discipline This is not yet the full OPERA A artifact. It is the canonical seed-template for one dignity. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-11"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Veritas in pure REGIMEN_A is integral and fully convertible. Veritas in OPERA A is never evaluated as pure integral plenitude. REFERENCE_ONLY cites the L0 ABS locus and performs no OPERA evaluation. Thus: OPERA A never asks: “is this absolute Veritas in itself?” OPERA A asks: “how does Veritas appear here under contraction?” ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-9"></a> I. DOCTRINAL BASIS ============================================================ TENET A supplies: • Veritas as canonical dignity • its fixed ordinal token: Ⅷ / I • its canonical phrase: "Veritas est, per quam bonum verum est." • distinction between pure and contracted use • correlative necessity • proper / appropriated distinction ALBUS FIGURA PRIMA supplies touchstone insight for: • discrimination between convertible and non-convertible expressions • partialization outside pure field • proper / appropriated distinction • correlative grounding of principial integrity AREPO A supplies: • admissibility gates • binding requirements • degraded / blocked handling • convertibility discipline • correlative integrity gating ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-7"></a> BOUNDARY ------------------------------------------------------------ This template does not redefine Veritas. It defines a lawful evaluation procedure-template for contracted Veritas only. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-9"></a> II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal input object: A_INPUT := { PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-9"></a> MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. TENET A bound 2. AREPO A admitted 3. subject anchor present 4. minimum Q support present 5. minimum T support present If any mandatory precondition fails: BLOCK via AREPO A ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-veritas-evaluation-unit"></a> VERITAS EVALUATION UNIT ------------------------------------------------------------ VERITAS_PREDICATE_COLUMN_COMPONENT := evaluate one admitted PRED(i,I), i != I, under contraction ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-veritas-canonical-doctrinal-seed"></a> III. VERITAS — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED ============================================================ ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅷ / I Canonical noun: Veritas Lexical lemma: Verus Contracted citation form: Verum Canonical phrase: "Veritas est, per quam bonum verum est." Minimal doctrinal reading: Veritas is that by reason of which good is true, meaning principial conformity, non-falsity, and stable accord between what is and what is said, known, or judged. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-6"></a> EXECUTION INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ For contracted evaluation purposes, Veritas is read through: • conformity between claim and structure • intelligible adequation between subject and predicate • absence of distortion, deception, or contradiction • stability of the claimed reading under inquiry • compatibility with Bonitas and Sapientia where relevant Veritas is weakened when: • the claim exceeds its basis • contradiction is ignored • wording outruns structure • causal or definitional support is thin • attribution is persuasive, ornamental, or merely asserted • coherence collapses under Q or T examination ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-7"></a> IV. EVALUATION DIMENSIONS ============================================================ Each carrier in the Veritas predicate column resolves five evaluation dimensions: 1. PRESENCE_MODE 2. CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT 3. CORRELATIVE_PROFILE 4. ATTRIBUTION_MODE 5. DISTORTION_FLAGS No numeric score is permitted. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-6"></a> V. DIMENSION 1 — PRESENCE MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • STRONG • MODERATE • WEAK • DEFORMED • ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-7"></a> V.1 — STRONG ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign STRONG iff all are true: 1. the claim is structurally grounded 2. subject, predicate, and relation are adequately aligned 3. relevant Q-support is present 4. T-contrariety does not dominate 5. correlative coherence is materially preserved 6. the reading remains stable under scrutiny Interpretation: Veritas is genuinely present under contraction. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-7"></a> V.2 — MODERATE ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign MODERATE iff: 1. the claim is substantially grounded 2. some instability or incompleteness remains 3. contradiction is limited but not dominant 4. coherence is defensible though not fully stabilized Interpretation: Veritas is present, but not maximally secure. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-7"></a> V.3 — WEAK ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign WEAK iff: 1. some truth-bearing structure is present 2. grounding is thin, local, or partial 3. the reading depends heavily on limited support 4. stronger inquiry could easily alter the conclusion Interpretation: Veritas is plausible but weakly instantiated. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-7"></a> V.4 — DEFORMED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign DEFORMED iff: 1. truth-language is present 2. but the structure is distorted, overstated, or confused 3. contradiction is materially present 4. appearance of truth exceeds lawful support Interpretation: this is not stable contracted Veritas, but a damaged or misformed appearance of it. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-7"></a> V.5 — ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign ABSENT iff: 1. no lawful truth-claim can be demonstrated 2. grounding is absent or irrelevant 3. the attribution adds no principial explanatory value Interpretation: Veritas is not lawfully present in the current reading. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-6"></a> VI. DIMENSION 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT ============================================================ Allowed states: • NEAR_INTEGRAL • STABLE_CONTRACTED • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-6"></a> VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use only when: • path is highly refined • contradiction is minimal • definitional and relational support are strong • Veritas coheres strongly with Bonitas and Sapientia • correlative coherence is balanced Constraint: this remains contracted, not pure integral plenitude. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-6"></a> VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • the truth-claim is stable under inquiry • coherence with relevant dignities is strong • no major contradiction breaks the structure • attribution is proper or strongly defensible ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-6"></a> VI.3 — PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • some lawful truth is preserved • but support is incomplete • convertibility remains non-integral • unresolved tensions remain ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-6"></a> VI.4 — FRAGMENTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • truthful elements are scattered or local • coherence with Sapientia, Bonitas, or Virtus is poor • contradiction or asymmetry is significant • the claim cannot be unified well ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-6"></a> VI.5 — BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • a Veritas-reading cannot sustain principial coherence • distortion dominates • contradiction destroys lawful A-use ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-60"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Convertibility effect is never inferred from confidence of expression alone. It must be justified by structural conformity, T-mediated coherence, and lawful correlative/attribution state. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-6"></a> VII. DIMENSION 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE ============================================================ Allowed states: • BALANCED • AGENT_DOMINANT • PATIENT_DOMINANT • ACT_DOMINANT • INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-6"></a> MINIMAL MODEL ------------------------------------------------------------ Veritas may appear through: • AGENT = that which knows, affirms, or discloses truth • PATIENT = that which is known, verified, or borne as true • ACT = the act of truthing, conforming, or making-true in articulation ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-1-balanced-4"></a> VII.1 — BALANCED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when all three dimensions are materially present and mutually coherent. Interpretation: strongest contracted correlative state ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-2-agent-dominant-4"></a> VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • the truth-bearing source or knower is primary • object or act side is less explicit Example pattern: a strong truthful witness whose disclosure function is clearer than the structure of what is disclosed ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-3-patient-dominant-4"></a> VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • the known or verified content is primary • source or act side is weaker ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-4-act-dominant-4"></a> VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • the conforming or verifying act is clearest • process dominates over stable bearer roles ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-5-incomplete-4"></a> VII.5 — INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • only one side is weakly visible • the triad cannot be stabilized lawfully • AREPO degradation or block may follow ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-61"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Correlative profile conditions strength and reuse readiness, but does not by itself decide admissibility. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-7"></a> VIII. DIMENSION 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • PROPER • APPROPRIATED • MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-6"></a> VIII.1 — PROPER ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when Veritas belongs to the subject in a way that is: • intrinsic • structurally grounded • non-ornamental • stably demonstrable ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-6"></a> VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when Veritas is present through: • derivative participation • secondary alignment • contextual truth-bearing role • indirect conformity This remains lawful, but not integral. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-6"></a> VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when Veritas is claimed but: • grounding is absent • another dignity or predicate better fits • the attribution is decorative, confused, or misleading • apparent truth is only rhetorical confidence ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-62"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ MISATTRIBUTED Veritas strongly pressures the result toward: • DEFORMED • ABSENT • or BLOCKED ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-6"></a> IX. DIMENSION 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS ============================================================ Possible flags: • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT • ASYMMETRY_HIGH • CAUSAL_GAP • SUBJECT_MISMATCH • OVEREXTENSION • CORRELATIVE_THINNESS • ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY • DEFINITONAL_MISMATCH • ASSERTION_EXCESS • VERIFICATION_THINNESS ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-7"></a> FLAG LOGIC ------------------------------------------------------------ CONTRARIETY_PRESENT the claim materially conflicts with relevant structure ASYMMETRY_HIGH one correlative side dominates excessively CAUSAL_GAP Q/E support for why the claim is true is weak SUBJECT_MISMATCH substrate does not support this Veritas-reading well OVEREXTENSION truth-claim reaches beyond its lawful basis CORRELATIVE_THINNESS triadic structure is too weak ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY proper/appropriated status is unstable DEFINITONAL_MISMATCH the claim conflicts with definitional structure ASSERTION_EXCESS discourse strength exceeds structural warrant VERIFICATION_THINNESS truth is claimed with inadequate checking surface ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-veritas"></a> X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR VERITAS ============================================================ Each admitted PRED(i,I), i != I, must be evaluated through relevant T predicates. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-b-difference-4"></a> T-B — DIFFERENCE ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is this truth-claim clearly distinguished from adjacent claims without confusion? Effect: prevents undifferentiated assertion ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-c-concordance-5"></a> T-C — CONCORDANCE ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: does the claim cohere with the structure it names? Effect: strengthens STRONG / MODERATE states ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-d-contrariety-5"></a> T-D — CONTRARIETY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: does the claim materially conflict with itself, its substrate, or its principial surroundings? Effect: strongest negative pressure on Veritas ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-e-beginning-2"></a> T-E — BEGINNING ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: what is the originating basis of the truth-claim? Effect: strengthens source-grounding analysis ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-f-middle-2"></a> T-F — MIDDLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: what mediates between subject and predicate so that truth can be lawfully affirmed? Effect: strengthens act/conformity analysis ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-g-end-3"></a> T-G — END ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: does the claim terminate in intelligible confirmation or collapse before closure? Effect: critical for stable Veritas ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-h-majority-2"></a> T-H — MAJORITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Veritas the dominant principial force in this reading? Effect: affects ranking, not validity by itself ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-i-equality-2"></a> T-I — EQUALITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is there adequate proportion between claim and basis? Effect: strengthens convertibility effect ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-k-minority-2"></a> T-K — MINORITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Veritas residual, marginal, or only weakly supportable? Effect: strengthens WEAK / FRAGMENTED readings ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-for-veritas"></a> XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS FOR VERITAS ============================================================ Minimal rule-support required: • Q-C (what is being claimed?) • Q-E (why is it true?) • Q-G (what kind of truth-status is involved?) Recommended additional support: • Q-D (of what / from what?) • Q-K1 (how is the claim made true or verified?) • Q-K2 (with what mediation or instrument?) • Q-I / Q-H where location or time are load-bearing ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-63"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Without at least C + E + G support, Veritas classification must be degraded or blocked. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-9"></a> INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ Q-C stabilizes object Q-E stabilizes truth-ground Q-G stabilizes quality of truth-status ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-7"></a> XII. DECISION LOGIC ============================================================ Evaluation order: 1. verify AREPO admissibility 2. verify subject binding 3. verify Q-min support 4. inspect T tensions / concordances 5. determine presence mode 6. determine correlative profile 7. determine attribution mode 8. determine convertibility effect 9. attach distortion flags 10. emit Veritas result object ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-64"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ No later step may silently override an earlier failure without explicit justification. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-veritas-result-object"></a> XIII. VERITAS RESULT OBJECT ============================================================ Recommended output structure: VERITAS_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-10"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅷ / I <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-11"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: <STRONG | MODERATE | WEAK | DEFORMED | ABSENT> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-11"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: <NEAR_INTEGRAL | STABLE_CONTRACTED | PARTIAL | FRAGMENTED | BROKEN> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-11"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: <BALANCED | AGENT_DOMINANT | PATIENT_DOMINANT | ACT_DOMINANT | INCOMPLETE> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-11"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: <PROPER | APPROPRIATED | MISATTRIBUTED> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-11"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-support-3"></a> T_SUPPORT: { CONCORDANCE: ... CONTRARIETY: ... BEGINNING: ... MIDDLE: ... END: ... EQUALITY: ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-15"></a> JUSTIFICATION: concise structured rationale } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-rule-2"></a> JUSTIFICATION RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Rationale must be: • structural • explicit • non-rhetorical • non-numeric ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-abstract-template-only-2"></a> XIV. EXAMPLE — ABSTRACT TEMPLATE ONLY ============================================================ Input case: x = a bounded claim, interpretation, or institution presented as true Possible result: VERITAS_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-11"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅷ / I <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-12"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: MODERATE <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-12"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: PARTIAL <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-12"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: ACT_DOMINANT <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-12"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: APPROPRIATED <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-12"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { VERIFICATION_THINNESS, ASSERTION_EXCESS } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-16"></a> JUSTIFICATION: the claim preserves some lawful conformity, but its support remains incomplete and its truth-status is not yet fully stabilized under inquiry } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status-5"></a> EXAMPLE STATUS ------------------------------------------------------------ METHOD_TEMPLATE This example illustrates output form, not a canon judgment. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-6"></a> XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS ============================================================ Veritas evaluation must be blocked or degraded when: • no subject is bound • no stable truth-ground is available • contradiction is ignored • definitional mismatch is present • attribution is misassigned without acknowledgment • the claim is rhetorical without principial support • pure plenitude is claimed in a bounded applied case ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-block-pressure-conditions-2"></a> BLOCK-PRESSURE CONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ Strong block pressure occurs when: • PRESENCE_MODE = ABSENT • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT = BROKEN • CORRELATIVE_PROFILE = INCOMPLETE • ATTRIBUTION_MODE = MISATTRIBUTED • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT is load-bearing • DEFINITONAL_MISMATCH is load-bearing ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-6"></a> XVI. REUSE READINESS ============================================================ Veritas result may be reused downstream only if: • validity is not BLOCKED • presence is not ABSENT • convertibility is not BROKEN • attribution is not MISATTRIBUTED • verification thinness is not load-bearing ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-reuse-warning"></a> REUSE WARNING ------------------------------------------------------------ Even when reusable, Veritas results with: • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • APPROPRIATED • ACT_DOMINANT • ASSERTION_EXCESS must propagate caution flags downstream. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function-5"></a> XVII. FUNCTION ============================================================ The OPERA A(I) predicate-column template governs: • evaluation of truth under contraction • discrimination between lawful and unstable truth-claims • principial conformity of bounded affirmations • structural relation between claim, basis, and coherence ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary-5"></a> XVIII. SUMMARY ============================================================ Veritas is evaluated as principial conformity and stable truth-bearing, not mere confidence, persuasion, or assertiveness. Its PRED(i,I) carrier payloads and CON_I summary ensure: • lawful evaluation of truth under contraction • no collapse into rhetoric or simple fact-assertion • deterministic structural assessment of truth-bearing coherence ============================================================ END OF OPERA A(I) — OPERA VERITAS ============================================================ ============================================================ OPERA A(K) — OPERA GLORIA Ars Generalis Applied — Regimen_A Execution Template Version: 0.1.0-OPERA-A-GLORIA-TEMPLATE Status: PROPOSED / TEMPLATE / CANONICAL-SEED Scope: deterministic qualitative evaluation model for Gloria Authority: TENET A / AREPO A Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-class-opera-12"></a> Class: OPERA ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-purpose-13"></a> PURPOSE ============================================================ This template defines how OPERA A should evaluate the Gloria predicate column through admitted PRED(i,K), i != K, under contracted use without: • numeric scoring • loose analogy • hidden heuristics • silent doctrinal mutation It establishes a deterministic qualitative rule model for: • presence of Gloria in a bound subject • correlative profile of Gloria • convertibility impact under contraction • attribution mode • distortion flags • output discipline This is not yet the full OPERA A artifact. It is the canonical seed-template for one dignity. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-control-principle-12"></a> CONTROL PRINCIPLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Gloria in pure REGIMEN_A is integral and fully convertible. Gloria in OPERA A is never evaluated as pure integral plenitude. REFERENCE_ONLY cites the L0 ABS locus and performs no OPERA evaluation. Thus: OPERA A never asks: “is this absolute Gloria in itself?” OPERA A asks: “how does Gloria appear here under contraction?” ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-i-doctrinal-basis-10"></a> I. DOCTRINAL BASIS ============================================================ TENET A supplies: • Gloria as canonical dignity • its fixed ordinal token: Ⅸ / K • its canonical phrase: "Gloria est, per quam bonum gloriosum est." • distinction between pure and contracted use • correlative necessity • proper / appropriated distinction ALBUS FIGURA PRIMA supplies touchstone insight for: • full convertibility in the pure principial field • partialization outside the pure field • discrimination between lawful and non-lawful projection • proper / appropriated distinction • correlative grounding AREPO A supplies: • admissibility gates • binding requirements • degraded / blocked handling • convertibility discipline • correlative integrity gating ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-semantic-clarification-non-doctrinal-2"></a> SEMANTIC CLARIFICATION (NON-DOCTRINAL) ------------------------------------------------------------ Gloria here should not be reduced to: • fame • praise • prestige • ornamental recognition Those may be contracted or appropriated appearances only. Gloria (A-layer) is read principially as: • fulfilled splendor of realized good • luminous completion or manifest consummation • repose, confirmation, or crowned intelligibility of what has reached lawful end ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-boundary-8"></a> BOUNDARY ------------------------------------------------------------ This template does not redefine Gloria. It defines a lawful evaluation procedure-template for contracted Gloria only. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ii-input-requirements-10"></a> II. INPUT REQUIREMENTS ============================================================ Minimal input object: A_INPUT := { PRINCIPIAL_SUBJECT_ID, EXTERNAL_SUBJECT_BINDING | null, CONTEXT_ID, EXECUTION_ID, CONTRACTION_LEVEL, Q_SUPPORT, T_SUPPORT, VALIDITY_STATE, PATH_TYPE } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-mandatory-preconditions-10"></a> MANDATORY PRECONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ 1. TENET A bound 2. AREPO A admitted 3. subject anchor present 4. minimum Q support present 5. minimum T support present If any mandatory precondition fails: BLOCK via AREPO A ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-gloria-evaluation-unit"></a> GLORIA EVALUATION UNIT ------------------------------------------------------------ GLORIA_PREDICATE_COLUMN_COMPONENT := evaluate one admitted PRED(i,K), i != K, under contraction ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iii-gloria-canonical-doctrinal-seed"></a> III. GLORIA — CANONICAL DOCTRINAL SEED ============================================================ ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅸ / K Canonical noun: Gloria Lexical lemma: Gloriosus Contracted citation form: Gloriosum Canonical phrase: "Gloria est, per quam bonum gloriosum est." Minimal doctrinal reading: Gloria is that by reason of which good is glorious, meaning manifested fulfillment, crowned completion, luminous rest, or stable consummation of principial good. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-execution-interpretation-7"></a> EXECUTION INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ For contracted evaluation purposes, Gloria is read through: • completion that is manifest rather than merely intended • achieved end crowned with intelligible confirmation • realized excellence that can repose in attained good • stable radiance or recognized fulfillment • compatibility with Finis, Aequalitas, Veritas, and Virtus Gloria is weakened when: • completion is claimed but not attained • recognition exceeds principial substance • splendor is rhetorical, decorative, or external only • repose is unstable or premature • end has not been lawfully reached • the appearance of glory masks contrariety or emptiness ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-iv-evaluation-axes-8"></a> IV. EVALUATION DIMENSIONS ============================================================ Each carrier in the Gloria predicate column resolves five evaluation dimensions: 1. PRESENCE_MODE 2. CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT 3. CORRELATIVE_PROFILE 4. ATTRIBUTION_MODE 5. DISTORTION_FLAGS No numeric score is permitted. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-axis-1-presence-mode-7"></a> V. DIMENSION 1 — PRESENCE MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • STRONG • MODERATE • WEAK • DEFORMED • ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-1-strong-8"></a> V.1 — STRONG ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign STRONG iff all are true: 1. a principial good has reached stable completion 2. this completion is manifest, intelligible, or luminous 3. relation to end is fulfilled rather than merely desired 4. repose is lawful and not premature 5. contrariety does not dominate 6. some correlative coherence is preserved 7. attribution is not merely external praise-language Interpretation: Gloria is genuinely present under contraction as fulfilled and manifested principial completion. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-2-moderate-8"></a> V.2 — MODERATE ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign MODERATE iff: 1. some lawful completion is present 2. manifestation or confirmation is partial 3. repose is present but not fully stabilized 4. tensions remain but do not dominate 5. correlative expression is partial yet non-collapsed Interpretation: Gloria is meaningfully present, but not strongly crowned. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-3-weak-8"></a> V.3 — WEAK ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign WEAK iff: 1. only a thin or local form of fulfillment is present 2. manifestation is narrow, unstable, or derivative 3. stronger explanation comes from other dignities 4. closure is plausible but weakly grounded 5. correlative expression is shallow Interpretation: Gloria is plausible but only weakly instantiated. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-4-deformed-8"></a> V.4 — DEFORMED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign DEFORMED iff: 1. language of glory or fulfillment is present 2. but completion is hollow, premature, or self-contradictory 3. recognition exceeds principial substance 4. splendor masks incoherence, vanity, or unresolved failure 5. end is claimed without lawful completion Interpretation: this is not a stable contracted Gloria, but a damaged, inflated, or misformed appearance of it. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-v-5-absent-8"></a> V.5 — ABSENT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign ABSENT iff: 1. no lawful completion can be demonstrated 2. no stable end-state or manifested fulfillment is present 3. Gloria adds no principial explanatory value 4. appearance of glory is empty, irrelevant, or decorative Interpretation: Gloria is not lawfully present in the current reading. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-axis-2-convertibility-effect-7"></a> VI. DIMENSION 2 — CONVERTIBILITY EFFECT ============================================================ Allowed states: • NEAR_INTEGRAL • STABLE_CONTRACTED • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-1-near-integral-7"></a> VI.1 — NEAR_INTEGRAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use only when: • path is highly refined • completion is stable and intelligible • Veritas, Virtus, and Finis strongly cohere • contrariety is minimal • correlative coherence is balanced Constraint: this is still contracted, not pure integral plenitude. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-2-stable-contracted-7"></a> VI.2 — STABLE_CONTRACTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • Gloria coheres stably with other dignities • lawful completion is present • manifestation is real, not decorative • attribution is proper or strongly defensible ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-3-partial-7"></a> VI.3 — PARTIAL ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • some completion is preserved • but manifestation or repose remains incomplete • convertibility is non-integral • tensions remain unresolved ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-4-fragmented-7"></a> VI.4 — FRAGMENTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • glory appears only in scattered or local traces • coherence with Veritas, Virtus, Bonitas, or Finis is poor • closure is unstable • manifestation and substance are misaligned ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vi-5-broken-7"></a> VI.5 — BROKEN ------------------------------------------------------------ Use when: • a Gloria-reading cannot sustain principial coherence • false closure or inflated recognition dominates • the completion claim collapses under scrutiny ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-65"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Convertibility effect is never inferred from prestige, brightness, acclaim, or rhetorical elevation alone. It must be justified by lawful completion, manifested end, and structural coherence under T. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-axis-3-correlative-profile-7"></a> VII. DIMENSION 3 — CORRELATIVE PROFILE ============================================================ Allowed states: • BALANCED • AGENT_DOMINANT • PATIENT_DOMINANT • ACT_DOMINANT • INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-minimal-model-7"></a> MINIMAL MODEL ------------------------------------------------------------ Gloria may appear through: • AGENT = that which glorifies or crowns fulfillment • PATIENT = that which is glorified or bears fulfilled splendor • ACT = the manifesting, crowning, or glorifying relation itself ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-1-balanced-5"></a> VII.1 — BALANCED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when all three dimensions are materially present and mutually coherent. Interpretation: strongest contracted correlative state ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-2-agent-dominant-5"></a> VII.2 — AGENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • the glorifying or crowning source is primary • the bearer or act side is secondary Example pattern: a source of confirmed excellence whose crowning force is clearer than the structure of what is crowned ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-3-patient-dominant-5"></a> VII.3 — PATIENT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • the fulfilled bearer is primary • source or manifesting act is less explicit ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-4-act-dominant-5"></a> VII.4 — ACT_DOMINANT ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • manifestation or crowning process is clearest • the act of glorifying dominates over stable roles ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-vii-5-incomplete-5"></a> VII.5 — INCOMPLETE ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when: • only one side is plausibly visible • triadic coherence cannot be lawfully stabilized • AREPO degradation or block may follow ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-66"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Correlative profile conditions strength and downstream reuse, but does not by itself decide admissibility. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-axis-4-attribution-mode-8"></a> VIII. DIMENSION 4 — ATTRIBUTION MODE ============================================================ Allowed states: • PROPER • APPROPRIATED • MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-1-proper-7"></a> VIII.1 — PROPER ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when Gloria belongs to the subject in a way that is: • intrinsic to its achieved completion • structurally grounded • non-decorative • tied to lawful end and manifested fulfillment ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-2-appropriated-7"></a> VIII.2 — APPROPRIATED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when Gloria is present through: • derivative recognition • secondary honor • contextual manifestation • indirect or partial crownedness This remains lawful, but not integral. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-viii-3-misattributed-7"></a> VIII.3 — MISATTRIBUTED ------------------------------------------------------------ Assign when Gloria is claimed but: • no lawful completion is present • manifestation is empty or borrowed • another dignity or predicate fits better • the attribution is decorative, inflated, or misleading ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-67"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ MISATTRIBUTED Gloria strongly pressures the result toward: • DEFORMED • ABSENT • or BLOCKED ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-ix-axis-5-distortion-flags-7"></a> IX. DIMENSION 5 — DISTORTION FLAGS ============================================================ Possible flags: • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT • ASYMMETRY_HIGH • CAUSAL_GAP • SUBJECT_MISMATCH • OVEREXTENSION • CORRELATIVE_THINNESS • ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY • PREMATURE_CLOSURE • EMPTY_SPLENDOR • FALSE_CONFIRMATION • END_NOT_REACHED ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-flag-logic-8"></a> FLAG LOGIC ------------------------------------------------------------ CONTRARIETY_PRESENT manifest fulfillment conflicts materially with structure ASYMMETRY_HIGH one correlative side dominates excessively CAUSAL_GAP Q/E support for why the state is glorious is weak SUBJECT_MISMATCH substrate does not support this Gloria-reading well OVEREXTENSION glory-claim exceeds lawful basis CORRELATIVE_THINNESS triadic structure is too weak ATTRIBUTION_INSTABILITY proper/appropriated status is unstable PREMATURE_CLOSURE end or completion is claimed too early EMPTY_SPLENDOR visible brightness or acclaim lacks principial substance FALSE_CONFIRMATION closure is asserted without lawful stabilization END_NOT_REACHED Finis is absent or incomplete while Gloria is claimed ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-x-t-mediated-rules-for-gloria"></a> X. T-MEDIATED RULES FOR GLORIA ============================================================ Each admitted PRED(i,K), i != K, must be evaluated through relevant T predicates. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-b-difference-5"></a> T-B — DIFFERENCE ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Gloria here structurally distinct from mere praise, fame, ornament, or prestige? Effect: prevents collapse into decorative elevation-language ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-c-concordance-6"></a> T-C — CONCORDANCE ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: does the fulfilled state cohere with the structure it belongs to? Effect: strengthens STRONG / MODERATE states ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-d-contrariety-6"></a> T-D — CONTRARIETY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: does the apparent glory materially conflict with the underlying structure or end? Effect: strongest negative pressure on Gloria ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-e-beginning-3"></a> T-E — BEGINNING ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: what originating process leads toward the claimed glory? Effect: clarifies whether completion emerges lawfully or is merely asserted ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-f-middle-3"></a> T-F — MIDDLE ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: what mediates between principial good and manifested glory? Effect: strengthens act/crowning analysis ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-g-end-4"></a> T-G — END ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: has the relevant good lawfully reached completion? Effect: critical for stable Gloria ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-h-majority-3"></a> T-H — MAJORITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Gloria the dominant principial force in this reading? Effect: affects ranking, not validity by itself ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-i-equality-3"></a> T-I — EQUALITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is there due proportion between completion, manifestation, and claim of glory? Effect: strengthens convertibility effect ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-k-minority-3"></a> T-K — MINORITY ------------------------------------------------------------ Question: is Gloria residual, marginal, or only faintly present here? Effect: strengthens WEAK / FRAGMENTED readings ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xi-q-min-support-requirements-for-gloria"></a> XI. Q-MIN SUPPORT REQUIREMENTS FOR GLORIA ============================================================ Minimal rule-support required: • Q-C (what has supposedly been fulfilled or crowned?) • Q-E (why is it glorious rather than merely completed?) • Q-G (what kind of manifested completion is involved?) Recommended additional support: • Q-D (of what / from what completion does this arise?) • Q-K1 (how is the glory manifested?) • Q-K2 (with what mediation, sign, or instrument?) • Q-F (how much completion or manifestation is actually present?) • Q-H / Q-I where time or place of consummation is load-bearing ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-68"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Without at least C + E + G support, Gloria classification must be degraded or blocked. ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-interpretation-10"></a> INTERPRETATION ------------------------------------------------------------ Q-C stabilizes the completed object Q-E stabilizes why the state is truly glorious Q-G stabilizes the quality of manifested fulfillment ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xii-decision-logic-8"></a> XII. DECISION LOGIC ============================================================ Evaluation order: 1. verify AREPO admissibility 2. verify subject binding 3. verify Q-min support 4. inspect T tensions / concordances 5. determine presence mode 6. determine correlative profile 7. determine attribution mode 8. determine convertibility effect 9. attach distortion flags 10. emit Gloria result object ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-rule-69"></a> RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ No later step may silently override an earlier failure without explicit justification. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiii-gloria-result-object"></a> XIII. GLORIA RESULT OBJECT ============================================================ Recommended output structure: GLORIA_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-12"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅸ / K <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-13"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: <STRONG | MODERATE | WEAK | DEFORMED | ABSENT> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-13"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: <NEAR_INTEGRAL | STABLE_CONTRACTED | PARTIAL | FRAGMENTED | BROKEN> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-13"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: <BALANCED | AGENT_DOMINANT | PATIENT_DOMINANT | ACT_DOMINANT | INCOMPLETE> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-13"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: <PROPER | APPROPRIATED | MISATTRIBUTED> <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-13"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-t-support-4"></a> T_SUPPORT: { CONCORDANCE: ... CONTRARIETY: ... BEGINNING: ... MIDDLE: ... END: ... EQUALITY: ... } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-17"></a> JUSTIFICATION: concise structured rationale } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-rule-3"></a> JUSTIFICATION RULE ------------------------------------------------------------ Rationale must be: • structural • explicit • non-rhetorical • non-numeric ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xiv-example-abstract-template-only-3"></a> XIV. EXAMPLE — ABSTRACT TEMPLATE ONLY ============================================================ Input case: x = a bounded achievement, institution, person, or state presented as fulfilled, crowned, or glorious Possible result: GLORIA_LOCAL_EVALUATION_PAYLOAD := { <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-carrier-13"></a> ORDINAL_TOKEN: Ⅸ / K <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-presence-mode-14"></a> PRESENCE_MODE: MODERATE <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-convertibility-effect-14"></a> CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT: PARTIAL <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-correlative-profile-14"></a> CORRELATIVE_PROFILE: PATIENT_DOMINANT <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-attribution-mode-14"></a> ATTRIBUTION_MODE: APPROPRIATED <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-distortion-flags-14"></a> DISTORTION_FLAGS: { PREMATURE_CLOSURE, EMPTY_SPLENDOR } <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-justification-18"></a> JUSTIFICATION: some manifested fulfillment is present, but the claim of glory exceeds the degree of lawful completion and remains only partially stabilized } ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-example-status-6"></a> EXAMPLE STATUS ------------------------------------------------------------ METHOD_TEMPLATE This example illustrates output form, not a canon judgment. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xv-failure-conditions-7"></a> XV. FAILURE CONDITIONS ============================================================ Gloria evaluation must be blocked or degraded when: • no subject is bound • no lawful completion is present • end has not been reached • manifestation exceeds principial substance • attribution is misassigned without acknowledgment • splendor is rhetorical with no stable basis • pure plenitude is claimed in a bounded applied case ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-block-pressure-conditions-3"></a> BLOCK-PRESSURE CONDITIONS ------------------------------------------------------------ Strong block pressure occurs when: • PRESENCE_MODE = ABSENT • CONVERTIBILITY_EFFECT = BROKEN • CORRELATIVE_PROFILE = INCOMPLETE • ATTRIBUTION_MODE = MISATTRIBUTED • CONTRARIETY_PRESENT is load-bearing • PREMATURE_CLOSURE is load-bearing • EMPTY_SPLENDOR is load-bearing • END_NOT_REACHED is load-bearing ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvi-reuse-readiness-7"></a> XVI. REUSE READINESS ============================================================ Gloria result may be reused downstream only if: • validity is not BLOCKED • presence is not ABSENT • convertibility is not BROKEN • attribution is not MISATTRIBUTED • premature closure is not load-bearing ------------------------------------------------------------ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-reuse-warning-2"></a> REUSE WARNING ------------------------------------------------------------ Even when reusable, Gloria results with: • PARTIAL • FRAGMENTED • APPROPRIATED • PATIENT_DOMINANT • EMPTY_SPLENDOR • FALSE_CONFIRMATION must propagate caution flags downstream. ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xvii-function-6"></a> XVII. FUNCTION ============================================================ The OPERA A(K) predicate-column template governs: • evaluation of principial glory under contraction • discrimination between lawful consummation and inflated appearance • structural relation between completion, manifestation, and repose • principial crownedness of bounded subjects or states ============================================================ <a id="local-section-02-stack-a-opera-ax-executionmechanism-xviii-summary-6"></a> XVIII. SUMMARY ============================================================ Gloria is evaluated as fulfilled and manifested principial completion, not as mere fame, praise, prestige, or decorative brightness. Its PRED(i,K) carrier payloads and CON_K summary ensure: • lawful evaluation of glory under contraction • no collapse into reputation-language alone • deterministic structural assessment of consummated and manifested excellence ============================================================ END OF OPERA A(K) — OPERA GLORIA ============================================================