============================================================ SATOR TRIVIUM — OUTPUT REQUIREMENTS GRAMMATICA / LOGICA / RHETORICA Version: 0.1.0-SATOR-TRIVIUM-OUTPUT-REQUIREMENTS Status: DRAFT / MEDIATION CANDIDATE SOURCE-BOUNDED NON-CANONICAL NOT SYSTEM_INDEX REGISTERED NOT RUNTIME AUTHORIZED Authority: USER / HUMAN CONTROL PLANE Class: SATOR Domain Class: AGLA / SATOR / TRIVIUM Depends-On: • TENET_TRIVIUM_DoctrinalInvariants_v0.1.0 • ROTAS_TRIVIUM_StructuralInstantiation_v0.1.0 • AREPO_TRIVIUM_InputAdmissibility_v0.1.0 • OPERA_TRIVIUM_ExecutionMechanism_v0.1.0 • AGLA_SATOR_CLASS_LAW Trace Modes: • CONCISE_TRACE • ANALYTICAL_TRACE • PEDAGOGICAL_TRACE • FULL_TRACE Rhetoric State Contract: RHETORICA_STATE := SOURCE_BOUND | DEFERRED_CARRIERS_UNRESOLVED | UNAVAILABLE Scope: • human-facing mediation • agent-facing handoff • dual output consistency • source/inference/status exposure • Trivium result separation • Q/T trace exposure • rhetoric-gap and contradiction disclosure Canonical Effect: NONE Mutation Policy: VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY ============================================================ ## I. Purpose SATOR TRIVIUM governs how admitted and executed Trivium results are communicated to humans, agents or both. It exposes status, distinctions, provenance, uncertainty and next lawful transitions without re-executing, repairing or canonizing the result. Core question: ```text How shall the Trivium result be made legible without hiding its sources, art boundaries, unresolved states, contradictions, Q/T route or execution status? ``` ## II. Control-plane position ```text TENET constrains. ROTAS structures. AREPO admits or blocks. OPERA executes. SATOR mediates. ``` SATOR may compress or translate presentation. It may not change: ```text admission class execution completion state source status Q/T species identity art result contradiction status unresolved items downstream route maturity ``` ## III. Mediation modes ```text HUMAN AGENT DUAL ``` ### III.1 HUMAN Readable critical result with enough trace to inspect sources, distinctions and uncertainty. ### III.2 AGENT Typed handoff package with stable IDs, state transitions, source pointers, Q/T records and next permitted action. ### III.3 DUAL Human and agent surfaces generated from one execution record. They may differ in compression, never in status or conclusion. ## IV. Required status markers Every output must distinguish applicable markers: ```text USER_BOUND DIRECT_SOURCE AGLA_ARTIFACT LIBER_INFORMANT PARSED MODEL_PRIOR COMMON_INFERENCE STRUCTURAL_DERIVATION EXPERIMENTAL_HYPOTHESIS UNRESOLVED DEFERRED BLOCKED AREPO_ADMITTED AREPO_ADMITTED_WITH_FLAGS AREPO_PROVISIONAL OPERA_EXECUTED OPERA_EXECUTED_WITH_FLAGS OPERA_PARTIAL NOT_EXECUTED NON_CANONICAL ``` No marker can be omitted merely because it complicates the narrative. ## V. Result partition law The output must preserve separate surfaces: ```text GRAMMATICAL RESULT LOGICAL RESULT RHETORICAL RESULT OR DEFERRED STATE T(BCD) CROSS-ART RESULT Q SPECIES TRACE T SPECIES TRACE ART AMPLIFICATION PROFILE PROVENANCE / UNCERTAINTY DOWNSTREAM ROUTE ``` A single fluent paragraph may summarize them only after the partition has been preserved in the underlying record. ## VI. Human-facing output levels ### VI.1 `CONCISE_CRITICAL` ```text main conclusion one or two decisive distinctions important uncertainty ``` ### VI.2 `ANALYTICAL` ```text status Grammar Logic Rhetoric T(BCD) source/inference notes next route ``` ### VI.3 `PEDAGOGICAL` Adds definitions, examples, explanation of why arts differ and how Q/T were used. ### VI.4 `AUDIT` Exposes full admitted species, relation records, provenance, failures and handoff fields. The default level is selected by user request, telos, risk and operator profile—not by a fixed preference for maximal disclosure. ## VII. Human-facing standard structure Recommended order: ```text 1. STATUS 2. OBJECT AND TELOS 3. CORE RESULT 4. GRAMMATICA 5. LOGICA 6. RHETORICA OR DEFERRED STATE 7. T(BCD): DIFFERENCE / CONCORDANCE / CONTRARIETY 8. Q/T TRACE SUMMARY 9. SOURCES / INFERENCES / UNRESOLVED 10. NEXT LAWFUL ROUTE ``` SATOR may reorder locally for readability if all required fields remain recoverable. ## VIII. Agent-facing handoff package ```text TRIVIUM_AGENT_HANDOFF := schema_version execution_id artifact_versions admission_class completion_state object_binding telos_binding source_trace[] namespace_bindings[] oratio_refs[] grammatical_result_ref logical_result_ref rhetorical_result_ref q_result_refs[] t_result_refs[] cross_art_refs[] art_activation_profile claim_provenance[] unresolved_items[] failure_items[] downstream_routes[] next_permitted_transition termination_condition ``` Stable semantic IDs must be retained. Agent output must not replace them with display ordinals alone. ## IX. Dual consistency law For DUAL mode: ```text status_human = status_agent conclusion_human ≈ conclusion_agent unresolved_human ⊇ load_bearing_unresolved_agent source_commitments_human = source_commitments_agent ``` The human surface may omit low-level fields only if the omission cannot mislead about result, authority or uncertainty. ## X. Grammatical mediation law The grammatical section should expose, according to depth: ```text part-of-speech placements parent `NOMEN` where B/C adaptation is used part-specific accidents resolved values/gradus agreement/government/construction literal ambiguity source versus adaptation status ``` Required wording guard: ```text Do not call B/C “the nine parts of Donatus.” Say that Donatus has eight parts and the stack splits NOMEN structurally. ``` ## XI. Logical mediation law The logical section should expose: ```text subject/predicate binding Porphyrian predicable candidates Aristotelian category candidates proposition/inference state medium or missing medium validity/underdetermination experimental wheel placement status ``` Required guards: ```text part of speech ≠ predicable ≠ category Aristotelian source registry ≠ experimental nine-slot placement ARIST.RELATIO ≠ REGIMEN_T ``` ## XII. Rhetorical mediation law When rhetoric is source-bounded, expose: ```text speaker/audience/situation telos disposition/salience expected effect source-bound rhetorical functions ``` When carrier-dependent rhetoric is unavailable: ```text RHETORICAL STATUS: DEFERRED — CARRIERS UNRESOLVED ``` Never hide the open edge of the Trivium triangle by converting Grammar or Logic into pseudo-Rhetoric. ## XIII. `T(BCD)` mediation law Present cross-art relations explicitly: ```text DIFFERENTIA: what each art establishes that the other does not CONCORDANTIA: how they cooperate and through which medium CONTRARIETAS: where their operations or ends actually resist ``` If no contrariety is supported, say so. Do not manufacture conflict for symmetry. If difference alone exists: ```text DIFFERENTIA PRESENT CONTRARIETAS NOT ESTABLISHED ``` ## XIV. Q trace mediation At minimum expose: ```text primary species activated conditional/diagnostic species that changed the result whether FULL sweep occurred unanswered questions ``` Do not present a same-letter diagonal as the reason for a result when a species-level source mapping governed the execution. ## XV. T trace mediation At minimum expose: ```text operator local species relata respectus direction level ``` Example format: ```text TF.MENSURATIO relata: Petrus / Paulus respectus: doctrina TH.SUB_SUB direction: Petrus > Paulus respectus: degree of doctrine ``` A grammatical comparative does not justify hiding the relata-based species resolution. ## XVI. Art amplification mediation Report: ```text GRAMMATICA: AMPLIFIED | FULL | CUSTODIAL | DEFERRED | UNAVAILABLE LOGICA: AMPLIFIED | FULL | CUSTODIAL | DEFERRED | UNAVAILABLE RHETORICA: AMPLIFIED | FULL | CUSTODIAL | DEFERRED | UNAVAILABLE ``` Include the telos-based reason. Never phrase local amplification as universal superiority. ## XVII. Contradiction and non-closure law Diagnostic contradiction must remain visible. Forbidden mediation: ```text smoothing incompatible analyses into one generic answer omitting a logical failure because rhetoric is effective omitting rhetorical force because logic is valid repairing ambiguity without source or user binding ``` Allowed closure markers: ```text CLOSED WEAKLY_CLOSED OPEN_BY_AMBIGUITY OPEN_BY_RHETORIC_GAP OPEN_BY_SOURCE_GAP CONTRADICTORY_DIAGNOSTIC ``` ## XVIII. Provenance and uncertainty display Human-readable qualifiers: ```text Parsed from source Declared by the user Required by an AGLA artifact Inferred from structure Based on ordinary model knowledge Experimental placement Still unresolved ``` Agent-readable qualifiers use the canonical provenance channel IDs. A synthesis may aggregate claims only if each load-bearing component remains traceable. ## XIX. Canonicality and draft notice For current TRIVIUM artifacts, SATOR must disclose: ```text DRAFT NON-CANONICAL NOT SYSTEM_INDEX REGISTERED NO RUNTIME AUTHORITY ``` Human approval of a draft does not by itself create registration or deployment authority. ## XX. Scholastic-Latin mediation When a Latin trace exists, SATOR may expose it as: ```text FULL LATIN TRACE COMPRESSED LATIN TRACE LATIN APPENDIX AGENT-ONLY LATIN TRACE ``` Human outputs may include a vernacular gloss. Required disclosure: ```text The Latin is a controlled operative representation. It does not validate the reasoning by style or language. ``` Never call an explicit rationale a revelation of inaccessible private internal reasoning. It is a structured execution trace produced by OPERA. ## XXI. Prompt-interpretation disclosure When the stack was used to interpret a prompt, output must state: ```text AGLA activation was explicit. The prompt was object-bound and telos-bound before routing. Ordinary model priors remained available but were governed and marked. ``` If activation was absent and no execution occurred, say so rather than implying a hidden Trivium pass. ## XXII. Reproducibility notice Expose the replay basis when relevant: ```text artifact versions source set object/telos bindings Q species T species traversal mode unresolved states ``` Do not promise identical wording across model versions. State that reproducibility concerns comparable operative path and commitments. ## XXIII. Blocked/deferred output formats ### XXIII.1 BLOCKED ```text STATUS: BLOCKED BLOCKING GATE: FAILURE CODE: WHAT IS MISSING: WHAT WAS NOT EXECUTED: NEXT PERMITTED TRANSITION: ``` ### XXIII.2 DEFERRED ```text STATUS: DEFERRED REASON: PRESERVED CHECKPOINT: REQUIRED SOURCE/ARTIFACT: NEXT PERMITTED TRANSITION: ``` ### XXIII.3 PROVISIONAL ```text STATUS: PROVISIONAL EXECUTED SURFACES: UNAVAILABLE SURFACES: PROHIBITED CONCLUSION: UNRESOLVED ITEMS: ``` ## XXIV. Successful human-output template ```text STATUS admission / execution / canonicality OBJECT AND TELOS object proximate and global ends CORE JUDGMENT concise result GRAMMATICA findings and ambiguity LOGICA predication, category, inference RHETORICA situated action or deferred state T(BCD) difference concordance contrariety Q/T TRACE load-bearing species and respectus PROVENANCE source / user / artifact / inference / prior UNRESOLVED residual items NEXT ROUTE candidate only; not implicit execution ``` ## XXV. Successful agent-output template ```json { "status": {}, "object_binding": {}, "telos_binding": {}, "art_results": { "grammatica": {}, "logica": {}, "rhetorica": {} }, "q_trace": [], "t_trace": [], "cross_art_t_bcd": [], "provenance": [], "unresolved": [], "downstream_routes": [], "next_permitted_transition": null } ``` This is a shape example, not a MACHINA schema declaration. ## XXVI. Training- and teaching-aware mediation For human learning, SATOR may explain why a distinction matters and show one compact example. For agent training, SATOR may expose: ```text failure code corrected namespace correct species missing respectus invalid transition replay package ``` Pedagogy must not simplify away operative boundaries. ## XXVII. Compression law Compression is admissible when: ```text status remains visible load-bearing distinction remains visible source/inference boundary remains visible unresolved item remains visible no art is silently eliminated ``` ```text COMPRESSION ≠ OMISSION OF GOVERNANCE ``` ## XXVIII. Failure conditions ```text status_hidden source_inference_hidden art_results_collapsed rhetoric_gap_hidden contradiction_smoothed q_species_hidden_when_load_bearing t_relata_or_respectus_hidden local_amplification_presented_as_superiority draft_presented_as_canon latin_presented_as_validity agent_handoff_missing_state human_agent_dual_divergence mediation_reexecutes_opera next_route_presented_as_already_executed ``` ## XXIX. Final mediation law ```text SATOR TRIVIUM exposes status before authority claims, preserves each art before synthesis, shows T(BCD) before closure, marks Q/T species when load-bearing, and keeps sources, inference, priors and unresolved states distinct. SATOR mediates. SATOR does not execute. ``` ## XXX. Closure ```text SATOR TRIVIUM STATUS: MEDIATION DRAFT COMPLETE TRIVIUM PENTAGRAM DRAFT COMPLETE CANONICAL EFFECT: NONE ```