# ROTAS LLULLIANAE — Duplex ATSQ / ASTX Version: `2.2.0-ROTAS-LLULLIANAE-PROVISIONAL-TEST-USE` Status: `PROVISIONAL_TEST_USE_AUTHORIZED / NON-CANONICAL / NOT DEPLOYMENT-BINDING` Authority: `USER / HUMAN CONTROL PLANE` Class: `AGLA / ROTAS / LLULLIANA / CALIBRATIO / DUPLEX` Mutation policy: `VERSION-CONTROLLED ONLY` Dependencies: - root ROTAS class law; - `TENET_LLULLIANA.md`; - `LLULLIANA_SOURCE_REGISTER.md`. Related support: - `LIBER_DE_DRIFT_ANGLOPHONICO_IN_INTERPRETATIONE_LLULLI.md` supplies non-executable drift signatures; - AREPO, OPERA, and SATOR artifacts must gate every provisional test use; - the full duplex candidate remains development evidence until authorized cleanup. These ROTAS select and order phase-qualified houses and reference routes. They do not answer a historical question, establish genealogy, admit sources, or independently grant runtime authority. `ROTA ≠ SOURCE ≠ INTERPRETATION ≠ OPERA` ## I. Duplex law The two wheels are independent: ```text ATSQ — final ternary Art A_TERN → T_TERN → S_TERN → Q_TERN → A_TERN ASTX — quaternary / Ars Demonstrativa A_DEM → S_DEM → T_DEM → X_DEM → A_DEM ``` They may be compared only after each traversal closes independently. - `ATSQ ≠ ASTX` - `A_TERN ≠ A_DEM` - `S_TERN ≠ S_DEM` - `T_TERN ≠ T_DEM` - `Q_TERN ≠ X_DEM` - same carrier letter does not guarantee the same regime; - shared vocabulary does not guarantee the same operation. ## II. Phase-selection gate Required input: ```text TARGET_WORK: TARGET_PHASE: TARGET_OPERATION: ``` | Phase | Routing disposition | |---|---| | `TERNARY` | select ATSQ | | `QUATERNARY` | select ASTX | | `TRANSITIONAL` | traverse ATSQ and ASTX separately; compare only after both returns | | `PRE_ART` | `OUTSIDE_DUPLEX / DEFER` | | `POST_ART_LOGIC` | `OUTSIDE_DUPLEX / DEFER`; a later local bridge requires explicit authorization | | `UNRESOLVED` | `PHASE_UNRESOLVED`; select neither wheel and never merge them | `NO PHASE RESOLUTION → NO REGIME SUBSTITUTION` No house may be selected merely because a familiar word or letter appears. ## III. R0–R3 reference-routing law Every house exposes four reference routes: | Route | Routing role | Expected TENET evidence class | |---|---|---| | `R0` | primary Lullian work containing the figure, regime, term, or operation | `E0` | | `R1` | historically relevant control corpus used to block drift | normally `E1` | | `R2` | external comparative author, school, or later reception | normally `E3`; declared comparison only | | `R3` | critical edition, philological aid, dictionary, or method-oriented secondary reconstruction | normally `E2` | `R0–R3` identify where a house routes. `E0–E4` identify what evidentiary authority a resulting claim has. The namespaces must not collapse. Candidate routing precedence `R0 > R1 > R2 > R3` is retained only as a house-loading convention. Claim adjudication remains governed by TENET’s evidentiary order: `E0 > claim-relevant E1/E2 > E3 > E4` Therefore: - an R2 comparison never overrides R0; - an R3 critical reconstruction may correct an R2 analogy or reception claim; - source affinity is not genealogical proof; - a listed reference is a retrieval target, not evidence that it was actually consulted. ## IV. Common house contract Each house must define and later emit: ```text HOUSE_ID: PHASE_BINDING: PARS_ARTIS: CAPUT_BINDING: FUNCTION: ENTRY_QUESTIONS: R0_PRIMARY_ROUTES: R1_CONTROL_ROUTES: R2_COMPARATIVE_ROUTES: R3_RECONSTRUCTION_ROUTES: TERMS_OR_RELATIONS: TERMINI_LATINI: OPERATIONES_TRANSVERSALES: DRIFT_BLOCKS: EXIT_CONDITION: STATE_DELTA: NEXT_HOUSE: RETURN_OBLIGATION: UNRESOLVED_CLAIMS: ``` Allowed house deltas: - `NO_CHANGE` - `REINFORCED` - `DISPLACED` - `PROPERTY_REINTRODUCED` - `DRIFT_INCREASED` - `DRIFT_CORRECTED` A delta must name the changed field and supporting evidence tier. It may not silently alter phase, house identity, or source authority. House exit does not mean historical truth has been decided. It means the minimum routing contract is satisfied or an explicit unresolved state has been emitted. ## IV-A. Ordo Artis and Latin-carrier law ATSQ is a calibration topology, not a claim that the `Ars brevis` consists only of A, T, S, and Q or historically executes one fixed circuit. Every `Ars brevis` traversal must declare which of the thirteen parts are material: `Alphabetum; Figurae; Definitiones; Regulae; Tabula; Evacuatio tertiae figurae; Multiplicatio quartae figurae; Mixtio principiorum et regularum; Novem subiecta; Applicatio; Quaestiones; Habituatio; Modus docendi hanc Artem.` The following are cross-cutting operation bindings, not additional ATSQ houses: | Source operation | Required trace when material | |---|---| | `Tabula` | column, camera, T position, routed reasons | | `Evacuatio` | propositions, media, questions, definitions/rules, solution state | | `Multiplicatio` | triadic camera, changed conditions, rotation, non-arbitrary expansion | | `Mixtio` | starting principle, traversed principles/rules, subject condition, media | | `Applicatio` | implicit→explicit, abstract→concrete, question→locus | | `Quaestiones` | question species, one of twelve loci, answered or exercise state | | `Habituatio` | retained parts, textual process, multiplied reasons | | `Modus docendi` | memorization, rational exposition, demonstration, learner exercise | `S_TERN`, `Q_TERN`, and every other house ID are AGLA calibration aliases. They are not letters or house names quoted from the `Ars brevis`. Source Latin must remain visible beside the alias. ## V. ROTA ATSQ — ternary wheel Global function: ```text A_TERN: what principles are active? T_TERN: how are they related? S_TERN: where are they contracted? Q_TERN: how may the contracted relation be investigated? RETURN A_TERN: does the result preserve the principial field? ``` Default topology: `A_TERN → T_TERN → S_TERN → Q_TERN → A_TERN`. ### ATSQ-1 — CASA A_TERN / Principia absoluta Phase binding: `TERNARY`. Function: identify active dignities or absolute principles, their activity, correlatives, predication, convertibility, generality, and contraction. Terms: `Bonitas, Magnitudo, Duratio/Aeternitas, Potestas, Sapientia, Voluntas, Virtus, Veritas, Gloria` Entry questions: - Which `principia` are explicit, implicit, or absent? - Does a secondary witness call them `dignitates`, and if so is that carrier distinguished from the `Ars brevis` wording `novem principia`? - Is the term essential, correlative, participatory, moral, or appropriated? - Is predication general or contracted? - Are subject–predicate conversion and correlatives textually warranted? Reference routes: - `R0`: `Ars brevis` Figure A, definitions, mixture, subjects; `Ars generalis ultima` alphabet, first figure, definitions, mixture, subjects, application; `Liber de ascensu et descensu intellectus` where contraction or traversal is material. - `R1`: Pseudo-Dionysius, `De divinis nominibus`; Eriugenian Dionysian mediation and `Periphyseon`, only as claim-relevant control. - `R2`: Augustine for faculty/interior-participation comparison; Aquinas for localized predication or causality; Proclus for declared processional comparison. - `R3`: critical editions; Lullian definition dictionaries; Bonner and scholarship on ternary dignities, correlatives, and contraction. Drift blocks: - `THOMISTIC_GLOBALIZATION` - `AUGUSTINIAN_PSYCHOLOGIZATION` - `DIVINE_ATTRIBUTE_AS_HUMAN_PSYCHOLOGY` - `DIGNITY_AS_STATIC_CATEGORY` - `PRINCIPLE_WITHOUT_ACTIVITY` - `DIVINE_NAME_AS_EXHAUSTIVE_DEFINITION` - `R2_OR_R3_PRESENTED_AS_R0` Exit: ```text A_TERN_EXIT := principles identified + contraction degree identified + predication mode identified + correlatives checked + unresolved textual claims declared ``` Delta: record principle profile as `NO_CHANGE`, `REINFORCED`, `DISPLACED`, or `PROPERTY_REINTRODUCED`; drift deltas remain available. Edge: `A_TERN → T_TERN`. A principle cannot proceed without a declared relational question. ### ATSQ-2 — CASA T_TERN / Principia relativa Phase binding: `TERNARY`. Function: qualify Lullian principles through the ternary relations: `Differentia, Concordantia, Contrarietas, Principium, Medium, Finis, Maioritas, Aequalitas, Minoritas` Entry questions: - What difference must remain? - What concordance permits relation without identity? - What kind of contrariety is present? - What `Principium`, `Medium`, and `Finis` organize the act? - What species and subject condition govern `Maioritas`, `Aequalitas`, or `Minoritas`? - What direction of ascensus or descensus is evidenced? Reference routes: - `R0`: ternary Figure T and definitions in `Ars brevis` and `Ars generalis ultima`; mixture, subjects, questions; `Liber de ascensu et descensu intellectus`. - `R1`: Dionysian naming and hierarchy; Eriugenian procession, participation, and return where material. - `R2`: Aristotle for relation, cause, or opposition; Proclus for declared processional comparison; Aquinas for localized medium, end, and degree comparison. - `R3`: critical editions; Bonner; studies of Figure T, correlatives, relation, action, ascensus, and descensus. Drift blocks: - `T_AS_STATIC_TAXONOMY` - `MEDIUM_AS_MERE_MIDPOINT` - `RELATION_AS_ACCIDENT_ONLY` - `ONE_WAY_HIERARCHY` - `THOMISTIC_RECODING_OF_ALL_T_TERMS` - `DIFFERENCE_AS_ABSOLUTE_SEPARATION` - `CONCORDANCE_AS_IDENTITY` - `T_TERN_T_DEM_COLLAPSE` Exit: ```text T_TERN_EXIT := active relation identified + relation species identified + medium identified + ascent/descent direction identified + ternary carrier verified ``` Delta: record relation, medium, and direction changes explicitly. Edge: `T_TERN → S_TERN`. A relation remains too general until contracted into a phase-valid subject. ### ATSQ-3 — CASA S_TERN / Novem subiecta Phase binding: `TERNARY`. Carrier clarification: `S_TERN` is an AGLA routing alias for the chapter `Novem subiecta`. It is not a source-letter claim. The source subjects remain mapped by B–K in the alphabet. Function: identify the subject and lawful contraction field: - `SB` Deus - `SC` Angelus - `SD` Caelum - `SE` Homo - `SF` Imaginativa - `SG` Sensitiva - `SH` Vegetativa - `SI` Elementativa - `SK` Instrumentativa Entry questions: - Which subject is active and where is its local definition? - Is the principle proper, appropriated, participatory, or instrumental? - What contraction degree is present? - Which properties must not transfer from another subject? - Is the use ontological, functional, representational, or analogical? Reference routes: - `R0`: nine subjects, application, and questions in `Ars brevis` and `Ars generalis ultima`; `Arbor scientiae` or ascensus–descensus only when the claim requires them. - `R1`: subject-specific historical controls; Dionysian–Eriugenian for SB/SC when admitted; Augustinian faculty control for SE’s learner context. - `R2`: only the comparison specifically declared for the active subject. - `R3`: critical definitions, Bonner, and scholarship on ternary subjects, application, and contraction. Subhouse SB requirements: - route divine naming and theoanalogical controls through the TENET/LIBER constraints; - block `EVANGELICAL_GOD_PROFILE`, `NEOPENTECOSTAL_AGENCY`, `SCRIPTURE_AS_PERFECT_CODE`, `ANTHROPOMORPHIC_PSYCHOLOGY`, and `DIVINE_NAME_AS_UNIVOCAL_DEFINITION`. Subhouse SC requirements: - parse messenger, mediator, receiver, transmitter, illuminator, interpreter, delegate, and ordered minister before ontology; - block `ANGELUS_AS_SUPERNATURAL_SPECIES_ONLY`, `NEOPENTECOSTAL_SPIRITUAL_WARFARE`, `FUNCTION_SUBSTANCE_COLLAPSE`, and `HIERARCHY_AS_STATIC_CASTE`. Subhouse SE requirements: - Augustinian memory, intellect, and will may control faculty, habituation, and learning claims; - the control applies to the learner, not the whole metaphysical system. Drift blocks: - `S_TERN_EQUALS_S_DEM` - `SUBJECT_WITHOUT_LOCAL_DEFINITION` - `PROPERTY_TRANSFER_WITHOUT_CONTRACTION` - `ANALOGY_ONTOLOGY_COLLAPSE` - `SUBJECT_SOURCE_TIER_UNDECLARED` Exit: ```text S_TERN_EXIT := subject identified + local definition retrieved or marked unresolved + contraction level identified + proper/appropriated distinction checked + analogy/ontology distinction checked ``` Delta: record subject, contraction, property, and drift changes. Edge: `S_TERN → Q_TERN`. Only a question compatible with the subject definition may proceed. ### ATSQ-4 — CASA Q_TERN / Regulae et quaestiones Phase binding: `TERNARY`. Function: determine the lawful interrogative mode: `B Utrum; C Quid; D De quo; E Quare; F Quantum; G Quale; H Quando; I Ubi; K-1 Quomodo; K-2 Cum quo` Entry questions: - Does the question seek existence, definition, material composition, cause, end, quantity, quality, time, place, mode, instrument, or company? - Are K-1 `Quomodo?` and K-2 `Cum quo?` kept distinct? - Which subject, principles, relations, and loci are required? - Is the answer affirmative, negative, doubtful, or unresolved? Reference routes: - `R0`: rules, mixture, application, questions, learning, and teaching in `Ars brevis` and `Ars generalis ultima`; `Logica nova` only for later, explicitly bounded development. - `R1`: medieval quaestio, disputatio, topical logic, and demonstration. - `R2`: Aristotle, Aquinas, or Avicenna as declared comparative forms, never as the ontology of A/T. - `R3`: critical editions; Bonner; scholarship on Lullian questions, dialectic, demonstration, and necessary reasons. Drift blocks: - `Q_AS_ONTOLOGICAL_FOUNDATION` - `Q_GOVERNS_A_AND_T` - `THOMISM_AS_TOTAL_LLULLIAN_METAPHYSICS` - `QUESTION_AS_PROMPT_ONLY` - `ANSWER_WITHOUT_LOCUS` - `ANSWER_WITHOUT_DEFINITION` - `RULE_WITHOUT_SUBJECT` - `Q_EQUALS_X` Exit: ```text Q_TERN_EXIT := question species identified + required loci identified + subject definition respected + principles and relations checked + answer state declared ``` Delta: record question mode, answer state, confidence, and corrected drift. Edge and compulsory return: `Q_TERN → A_TERN`. The return must test whether the proposed solution preserves active principles, definitions, relations, and contraction degrees. A proposition from Q is never a complete traversal by itself. ## VI. ATSQ entry and compulsory-return law Default entry is `A_TERN`. Alternative entry is allowed only when the input already establishes a phase-valid dominant house. Examples: - angelus question: `S_TERN → T_TERN → Q_TERN → A_TERN`, with missing A prerequisites recovered and traced; - medium question: `T_TERN → S_TERN → Q_TERN → A_TERN`; - utrum question: `Q_TERN`, followed by recovery of S, T, and A before final return. `START_ANYWHERE → RECOVER REQUIRED HOUSES → RETURN_TO_A_TERN` Final ATSQ state: - `CALIBRATED_ROUTE` - `PROVISIONAL_ROUTE` - `SOURCE_INSUFFICIENT` - `PHASE_UNRESOLVED` - `HOUSE_EXIT_FAILED` ## VII. ROTA ASTX — quaternary wheel Global function: ```text A_DEM: what expanded principial field is active? S_DEM: how is it received or enacted by the rational faculties? T_DEM: how is it relationally articulated? X_DEM: how does it withstand opposition or objection? RETURN A_DEM: does the result preserve the quaternary principial field? ``` Default topology: `A_DEM → S_DEM → T_DEM → X_DEM → A_DEM`. ASTX is a provisional calibration route for the quaternary architecture, not a claim that every historical execution of the `Ars demonstrativa` followed one circuit. ### ASTX-1 — CASA A_DEM / Dignitates expansae Phase binding: `QUATERNARY`. Function: identify the expanded dignity field without premature compression into the later B–K ternary carrier set. Entry questions: - Which dignity is active? - Is it retained in the later ternary field or specific to the expanded architecture? - Is it functioning as divine name, cause, act, or participated property? - How does it relate to God, creature, operation, and rational soul in this passage? Reference routes: - `R0`: `Ars demonstrativa` alphabet, Figure A, second Figure A, definitions, combinations, applications, and questions; earlier Lullian substrates only when explicitly compared. - `R1`: Pseudo-Dionysius and Eriugena where divine naming, participation, or procession is materially active. - `R2`: Augustine, Proclus, or Aquinas only as localized comparison. - `R3`: critical editions; Bonner on quaternary and transitional phases; Rubio and scholarship on figure evolution. Drift blocks: - `TERNARY_COMPRESSION_APPLIED_TOO_EARLY` - `A_DEM_EQUALS_A_TERN` - `DIGNITIES_AS_STATIC_LIST` - `THOMISTIC_NORMALIZATION` - `TEXTUAL_LANGUAGE_AS_PERFECT_DIVINE_CODE` - `EXPANDED_ALPHABET_UNSUPPORTED` Exit: ```text A_DEM_EXIT := dignity identified + quaternary carrier verified + expanded-alphabet relation preserved + divine-name or principial mode checked ``` Delta: record expanded-field changes without importing a ternary identity. Edge: `A_DEM → S_DEM`. ### ASTX-2 — CASA S_DEM / Anima rationalis Phase binding: `QUATERNARY`. Function: identify the dynamic state and combinations of `Memoria`, `Intellectus`, and `Voluntas`. Entry questions: - Which faculty and act are active? - Is the state act, potency, privation, negation, or combination? - Are the acts proper, ordered, disordered, or indeterminate? - Do memory, intellect, and will agree, differ, or oppose? - Is a modern psychological/computational analogy being imported? Reference routes: - `R0`: `Ars demonstrativa` Figure S, second Figure S, faculty combinations, applications, and questions. - `R1`: Augustine’s faculty triad where textually and historically material. - `R2`: medieval faculty psychology; Dionysian reception/illumination or Thomistic faculty analysis only as declared comparison. - `R3`: critical editions; Bonner; studies of Figure S and quaternary cognitive architecture. Drift blocks: - `S_DEM_EQUALS_NINE_TERNARY_SUBJECTS` - `MEMORY_EQUALS_COMPUTER_STORAGE` - `INTELLECT_EQUALS_MODERN_CONSCIOUSNESS` - `WILL_EQUALS_PREFERENCE_SCORE` - `AUGUSTINE_AS_TOTAL_SYSTEM` - `NEGATION_EQUALS_SIMPLE_ABSENCE` Exit: ```text S_DEM_EXIT := faculty identified + act/potency/privation distinguished + combination state identified + psychological analogy marked ``` Delta: record faculty, act, combination, privation, and drift changes. Edge: `S_DEM → T_DEM`. ### ASTX-3 — CASA T_DEM / Principia et operationes Phase binding: `QUATERNARY`. Function: identify the relational and operational structure of the `Ars demonstrativa` without filling it with ternary Figure T by default. `T_DEM ≠ T_TERN` Entry questions: - Which quaternary triangle, chain, or relation is active? - Are God, creature, and operation functioning as source, agent, act, patient, or medium? - Is the operation natural, moral, intellectual, divine, or participated? - Is a ternary relation being imported without R0 evidence? Reference routes: - `R0`: `Ars demonstrativa` Figure T, second Figure T, definitions, combinations, applications, and questions. - `R1`: Dionysian and Eriugenian controls where naming, hierarchy, procession, or participation is material. - `R2`: Proclus, Aristotle, or Aquinas as localized comparison. - `R3`: critical editions; Bonner; Rubio and scholarship on the evolution of A, S, and T. Drift blocks: - `T_DEM_COLLAPSED_INTO_T_TERN` - `DEUS_CREATURA_OPERATIO_RECODED_AS_TERNARY_TRIAD` - `ACT_AGENT_PATIENT_ASSERTED_WITHOUT_R0_CONTROL` - `AQUINAS_AS_PRIMARY_NORMALIZER` - `QUATERNARY_RELATION_WITHOUT_CARRIER` Exit: ```text T_DEM_EXIT := quaternary relation identified + source carrier verified + operation identified + ternary substitution blocked ``` Delta: record relation and operation changes with carrier provenance. Edge: `T_DEM → X_DEM`. ### ASTX-4 — CASA X_DEM / Oppositiones Phase binding: `QUATERNARY`. Function: route oppositions, objections, and veridictional tensions without reducing X to Q, generic negation, Boolean truth, or the classical square of opposition. Entry questions: - Which poles are opposed? - Is opposition contradictory, contrary, privative, relative, apparent, temporal, or modal? - Is there a medium? - Does the objection concern a principle, relation, faculty, application, or formulation? - Is the terminal state truth, falsity, doubt, or suspension? Reference routes: - `R0`: `Ars demonstrativa` Figure X, second Figure X, questions, applications, and Y/Z terminals where actually present; other quaternary X variants only with work identification. - `R1`: Augustinian predestination, will, grace, or foreknowledge only when the chamber requires it. - `R2`: Aristotelian opposition, the medieval square, or scholastic disputatio as comparison, never identity. - `R3`: critical editions; Bonner; Rubio; studies of X variants, objections, predestination, and Lullian veridiction. Drift blocks: - `X_EQUALS_CLASSICAL_SQUARE_OF_OPPOSITION` - `X_EQUALS_Q` - `X_EQUALS_GENERIC_NEGATION` - `PREDESTINATION_READ_THROUGH_MODERN_CALVINISM` - `EVANGELICAL_GRACE_DEFAULT` - `NEOPENTECOSTAL_SPIRITUAL_CAUSATION` - `OPPOSITION_WITHOUT_PHASE_CONTROL` - `Y_Z_COLLAPSED_INTO_BOOLEAN_TRUE_FALSE` - `X_VARIANT_WITHOUT_WORK_ID` Exit: ```text X_DEM_EXIT := poles identified + opposition type identified + objection locus identified + possible medium tested + veridiction status marked ``` Delta: record poles, opposition type, medium, terminal state, and corrected drift. Edge and compulsory return: `X_DEM → A_DEM`. The return must test whether the resolution preserves the expanded principial field rather than merely silencing the objection. ## VIII. ASTX entry and compulsory-return law Default entry is `A_DEM`. Alternative entry requires established quaternary phase and recovery of every prerequisite house needed for the claim. `START_ANYWHERE → RECOVER REQUIRED HOUSES → RETURN_TO_A_DEM` X never replaces Q: - Q is the interrogative mode of the ternary Art; - X is the phase-qualified oppositional field of the quaternary architecture. ## IX. Cross-wheel bridge For a transitional or cross-phase question: 1. open an ATSQ trace and an ASTX trace separately; 2. complete or explicitly fail each wheel’s compulsory return; 3. compare only the closed traces; 4. do not translate houses without an explicit transition mapping. Required comparison fields: ```text QUATERNARY_FORM: TERNARY_FORM: PRESERVED: COMPRESSED: DISPLACED: NEWLY_EXPLICIT: NOT_EQUIVALENT: EVIDENCE_FOR_TRANSITION: UNRESOLVED_TRANSITION: ``` Cross-wheel deltas: - `PRESERVED` - `COMPRESSED` - `DISPLACED` - `NEWLY_EXPLICIT` - `NOT_EQUIVALENT` - `UNRESOLVED` Bridge prohibitions: - no `X_DEM → Q_TERN` equivalence by letter/function proximity; - no `S_DEM → S_TERN` equivalence; - no `T_DEM → T_TERN` equivalence; - no `A_DEM → A_TERN` identity; - no combined “average” wheel; - no transfer without work, phase, carrier, operation, and evidence. ## X. Minimum duplex trace Every traversal must expose: ```text ROTA_SELECTED: ATSQ | ASTX TARGET_WORK: TARGET_PHASE: TARGET_OPERATION: ENTRY_HOUSE: HOUSES_VISITED: HOUSES_RECOVERED: R0_ROUTES: R1_ROUTES: R2_ROUTES: R3_ROUTES: EVIDENCE_TIERS_ACTUALLY_ADMITTED: PARTES_ARTIS_MATERIALES: CAPITA_VINCULATA: TERMINI_LATINI: OPERATIONES_TRANSVERSALES: LATIN_PIVOT_ID: LATIN_PIVOT_STATUS: DRIFTS_BLOCKED: UNRESOLVED_TERMS: HOUSE_DELTAS: RETURN_HOUSE: RETURN_COMPLETED: TRUE | FALSE FINAL_STATUS: ``` Allowed final status: - `CALIBRATED_ROUTE` - `PROVISIONAL_ROUTE` - `SOURCE_INSUFFICIENT` - `PHASE_UNRESOLVED` - `WRONG_WHEEL_REJECTED` - `HOUSE_EXIT_FAILED` - `RETURN_INCOMPLETE` ## XI. Failure conditions - `phase_unresolved` - `wrong_wheel_selected` - `atsq_astx_collapse` - `a_dem_a_tern_collapse` - `s_dem_s_tern_collapse` - `t_dem_t_tern_collapse` - `x_q_collapse` - `reference_tier_inversion` - `routing_tier_evidence_tier_collapse` - `secondary_overrides_primary` - `comparative_source_normalization` - `thomistic_globalization` - `augustinian_globalization` - `dionysian_totalization` - `evangelical_confessional_drift` - `neopentecostal_drift` - `calvinist_predestination_drift` - `angelus_species_collapse` - `theoanalogy_ontology_collapse` - `angeoanalogy_ontology_collapse` - `question_without_subject` - `subject_without_definition` - `relation_without_principle` - `opposition_without_poles` - `delta_without_evidence` - `answer_without_return` - `ordo_artis_truncated` - `latin_source_paraphrase_collapse` - `translation_bypassed_latin_pivot` - `k1_k2_collapse` - `s_tern_source_carrier_collapse` - `principia_dignitates_unmarked_substitution` Any failure remains non-executable and must be passed to later AREPO rules as an explicit denial, remediation, or deferral candidate. ## XII. Unresolved historical claims The following source-candidate assertions remain provisional: 1. exact part/chapter mappings for `Ars brevis`, `Ars generalis ultima`, and `Ars demonstrativa`; 2. the work-specific historical form and variants of Figures A, S, T, X, and Y/Z terminals; 3. the stability of `Deus–Creatura–Operatio` as a T_DEM mapping across relevant witnesses; 4. the precise place of `praedestinatio` and `obiectio` within X variants; 5. paraphrases and chapter references attributed to Bonner; 6. the exact Rubio works and passages supporting figure-transition claims; 7. the direction and strength of Dionysian, Eriugenian, Augustinian, Aristotelian, or Thomistic control in each house. Disposition: `PROVISIONAL / REQUIRES EDITION-LEVEL OR CLAIM-SPECIFIC EVIDENCE`. ## XIII. Root boundary No root ROTAS law was changed. Phase-qualified house identities, dual routing/evidence namespaces, cross-wheel comparison, and compulsory returns are implemented locally. Any proposal to generalize those patterns across stacks remains `DEFERRED / AWAITING HUMAN AUTHORIZATION` in the source register. ## XIV. Final law ATSQ calibrates the final ternary Art through principles, relations, subjects, and questions. ASTX calibrates the quaternary demonstrative architecture through expanded dignities, rational faculties, relational operations, and oppositions. The wheels may communicate after closure, but they must never collapse. `PHASE → WHEEL → HOUSE → ROUTED REFERENCES → EXIT → DELTA → COMPULSORY RETURN`
Actual artifact: 15_STACK_LLULLIANA/ROTAS_LLULLIANAE.md