ANALOGIAE_EMBEDDED_PROTOCOL:
version: 1.0.0-LLULLIANA-ANALOGICAL-SATOR
posture: NATIVE_LLULLIAN_METHOD / NO_AUTONOMOUS_ANALOGIAE_STACK
authority: SATOR LLULLIANA mediates the aggregate session; selected A / T / E / SK SATOR facets retain local authority
flow: SUBJECT -> TELOS_CORPUS -> LLULLIAN_ROTA -> COMPOSED_AREPO -> OPERA_LLULLIANA_COMPARATIO -> NON_COLLAPSE -> CALIBRATION -> MONITOR -> RECALIBRATE_OR_EXPIRE_OR_HANDOFF
session_fields: calibration_id / protocol_version / session_scope / subject / target_domain / source_corpus / session_telos / active_signatures / dominance_order / semantic_anchors / preferred_terms / avoided_terms / preserved_relations / suspended_properties / ontology_warnings / drift_triggers / output_guidelines / provenance / confidence / expiry_conditions / patch_history
mediation_law: analogy is disclosed as method, never as identity, hidden reasoning, permanent model modification, or automatic historical attribution
expiry: topic / corpus / historical_frame / telos / analysis_creation transition / dominant analogy rejection / unresolved analogical drift / failed gate
archived_carrier: no active route or output refers to a retired Analogiae kernel
# SATOR LLULLIANA — Orchestratio Calibrationis Hermeneuticae
Version: `2.3.0-SATOR-LLULLIANA-COMPOSITIONAL-PROTOCOL`
Status: `PROVISIONAL_TEST_USE_AUTHORIZED / NON-CANONICAL / NOT DEPLOYMENT-BINDING`
Authority: `USER / HUMAN CONTROL PLANE`
Class: `AGLA / SATOR / LLULLIANA / ORCHESTRATION`
Dependencies:
- root SATOR class law;
- `TENET_LLULLIANA.md`;
- `ROTAS_LLULLIANAE.md`;
- `AREPO_LLULLIANA.md`;
- `OPERA_LLULLIANA.md`.
Related support: the anti-drift LIBER is consumed only through registered AREPO/OPERA contracts.
SATOR coordinates disclosure, routing, session state, patches, monitoring, and expiry. It may orchestrate explicit `LLULLIANA_PROVISIONAL_TEST` sessions under the local and global index boundary; it is not a canonical or deployment runtime.
SATOR must expose the resolved five-class composition, including the direct
A/T/E/SK surface or the declared D/F/G/H/I inheritance path used for each role.
It must distinguish protocol authority from local domain authority and disclose
that a Lullian explanation is being produced through `OPERA_LLULLIANA`.
## I. State machine
```text
UNINITIALIZED
→ TARGET_PROFILED
→ ROTA_SELECTED
→ AREPO_PENDING
→ ADMITTED | PROVISIONAL | BLOCKED | DEFERRED
→ OPERA_SELECTED
→ TERMINI_LATINI_STABILITI
→ FORMA_LATINA_VALIDATA
→ VERSIO_LINGUAE_USORIS
→ RESULT_REVIEW
→ SESSION_PATCHED | RECALIBRATION_REQUIRED | EXPIRED
```
Blocked or deferred states do not silently advance. Every transition records its trigger and authority.
`TERMINI_LATINI_STABILITI`, `FORMA_LATINA_VALIDATA`, and
`VERSIO_LINGUAE_USORIS` are mandatory for translation or multilingual
interpretation. They are not required when the admitted operation is limited to
verbatim source retrieval without interpretation.
## II. Routing
| Condition | Route |
|---|---|
| ternary work | ATSQ |
| quaternary work | ASTX |
| transitional work | ATSQ and ASTX separately, then admitted comparison |
| unresolved phase | request resolution; select neither wheel |
| pre-Art | outside duplex; defer |
| post-Art logic | outside duplex unless an explicit local bridge is admitted |
| SB | activate theoanalogical, source-tier, and confessional gates |
| SC | activate functional angelus, hierarchy, and ontology gates |
| Q/scholastic request | preserve Q as interface; never impose Q over A/T |
| X/predestination request | preserve X_DEM and block post-Reformation default |
| full analogy request | route to `OPERA_LLULLIANA / COMPARATIO` with admitted A/T/E/SK signature facets |
Flow:
`TARGET → TENET → ROTA → AREPO → OPERA → LATIN PIVOT → USER-LANGUAGE VERSION → RESULT REVIEW → DRIFT MONITOR → PATCH, RECALIBRATE, DEFER, OR EXPIRE`
## II-A. Lex praecedentiae Latinae
### Textus normativus Latinus
`FONS ORIGINALIS → TERMINI LATINI STABILITI → FORMA SEMANTICA LATINA CONTROLATA → VALIDATIO DEFINITIONUM ET RELATIONUM → VERSIO IN LINGUAM USORIS → COLLATIO RETROACTIVA`
SATOR interpretationem multilinguem ita ordinat, ut significatio prius per
terminos et relationes Latinas stabiliatur, deinde in linguam usoris reddatur.
Versio Anglica non est medium tacitum neque norma semantica.
`TEXTUS_LATINUS_E0 ≠ PARAPHRASIS_LATINA_CONTROLATA ≠ VERSIO_LINGUAE_USORIS`
Textus Latinus E0 verbatim servandus est. Paraphrasis Latina controlata, si a
modello componitur, aperte notanda est et numquam pro testimonio, citatione, vel
evidentia E0 habenda. Versio in linguam usoris ex eadem forma Latina stabilita
derivanda est, relationibus servatis et compressionibus declaratis.
### Paraphrasis Anglica
For multilingual interpretation, SATOR requires a stable and auditable Latin
semantic pivot before rendering into the user's language. English is a
paraphrase target, never the silent intermediary or governing semantic layer.
“Think in Latin” means constructing the explicit semantic pivot required by this
contract. It does not request, expose, preserve, or claim private
chain-of-thought. The auditable objects are terms, definitions, propositions,
relations, source bindings, and translation deltas.
Language precedence:
1. exact admitted source in its original language;
2. exact admitted Latin E0 text when the source witness is Latin;
3. controlled Latin semantic form, explicitly marked as paraphrase when generated;
4. user-language working version;
5. English or any other modern-language paraphrase.
When the original source is not Latin, the original remains E0 and the Latin
pivot is necessarily a controlled paraphrase.
Required orchestration:
```text
MODE 2 — TERMINORUM_EXPOSITIO
→ TERMINI_LATINI_STABILITI
→ FORMA_LATINA_VALIDATA
→ MODE 7 — TRANSLATIO_CONTROLATA
→ COLLATIO_CUM_FORMA_LATINA
→ RESULT_REVIEW
```
SATOR coordinates this order. It does not perform the OPERA, invent missing
source content, or promote a Latin paraphrase into primary evidence.
## III. Session object
```text
CALIBRATIO_LLULLIANA_SESSIONIS:
calibration_id:
stack_version:
protocol_suite_version:
authorization_posture: LLULLIANA_PROVISIONAL_TEST
canonical_status: NON_CANONICAL
status:
created_at:
updated_at:
scope:
class_composition_id:
resolved_class_roles:
direct_protocol_surfaces:
transitive_inheritance_paths:
subject:
target_domain:
source_corpus:
session_telos:
active_analogical_signatures:
dominance_order:
semantic_anchors:
preferred_terms:
avoided_terms:
preserved_relations:
suspended_properties:
ontology_warnings:
analogical_drift_triggers:
analogical_output_guidelines:
target_work:
target_passages:
target_phase:
selected_rota:
houses_visited:
return_completed:
active_regimes:
active_functions:
local_definitions:
routed_references:
loaded_evidence:
evidence_tiers:
primary_sources:
control_corpora:
comparative_sources:
source_affinities:
confessional_frame:
scriptural_frame:
suspended_modern_defaults:
active_drift_blocks:
required_output_labels:
translation_conventions:
source_language:
source_text_id:
latin_pivot_id:
latin_pivot_status: E0_TEXT | CONTROLLED_PARAPHRASE | NOT_APPLICABLE
termini_latini:
definitiones_vinculatae:
capita_vinculata:
propositiones_latinae_controlatae:
relationes_servatae:
target_language:
translation_deltas:
compressed_terms:
untranslatable_terms:
retrocollation_status:
claim_provenance:
confidence:
unresolved_items:
patch_head:
drift_monitor:
expiry_conditions:
```
Allowed scope:
- `TERM_SCOPE`
- `PASSAGE_SCOPE`
- `WORK_SCOPE`
- `PHASE_SCOPE`
- `SESSION_SCOPE`
- `COMPARATIVE_SCOPE`
Scope expansion requires a new AREPO decision.
## IV. Initial suspended defaults
When material, initialize explicit suspensions for:
- perfect-language and autonomous-combinatorics criteria;
- Leibnizian success criterion and late-Lullism identity;
- modern evangelical or fundamentalist Christian defaults;
- dictation and self-interpreting Scripture;
- species-only angelus and static hierarchy;
- anthropomorphic maximal-agent God language;
- post-Reformation grace/predestination defaults;
- modern religion–science binary;
- content-neutral calculus and automatic algorithmic Art;
- unmarked LLM, database, ontology, or agent analogies.
Suspension is scoped. It does not forbid an admitted comparison.
## V. Patch history
Session mutation is append-only:
```text
CALIBRATIO_PATCH:
patch_id:
parent_patch_id:
timestamp:
actor:
authority:
reason:
arepo_decision_id:
opera_operation_id:
scope_before:
scope_after:
added:
removed:
suspended:
restored:
evidence:
confidence_delta:
drift_delta:
expiry_delta:
review_required:
```
Patch rules:
- first patch declares `parent_patch_id: NONE`;
- subsequent patches reference the current head;
- no patch deletes historical records;
- removal from active state remains visible in patch history;
- evidence or authority changes require review;
- a patch cannot convert provisional evidence into primary extraction;
- a patch cannot claim permanent model modification.
## VI. Drift monitoring
```text
DRIFT_EVENT:
event_id:
session_id:
claim_id:
signature:
detected_at:
severity: INFO | WARNING | BLOCKING
evidence:
introduced_default:
affected_scope:
action:
status:
patch_id:
```
Monitor triggers:
- new claim, source, translation, comparison, or analogy;
- translation attempted without a stable Latin pivot;
- generated Latin presented as E0 source text;
- user-language or English rendering changes a controlled term or relation;
- work, passage, phase, regime, function, or telos change;
- ROTA return failure;
- evidence-tier change;
- restored suspended default;
- user correction;
- accumulating unresolved claims;
- contradiction between session state and newly loaded E0/E2 evidence.
Actions:
- `LOG_ONLY`
- `WARN`
- `REQUEST_REMEDIATION`
- `RETURN_TO_AREPO`
- `RECALIBRATE`
- `NARROW_SCOPE`
- `EXPIRE_SESSION`
Blocking drift cannot be repaired by relabelling alone.
Latin-pivot failure states:
- `TERMINI_LATINI_INCOMPLETI`
- `FORMA_LATINA_INSTABILIS`
- `LATIN_SOURCE_PARAPHRASE_COLLAPSE`
- `TRANSLATION_BYPASSED_LATIN_PIVOT`
- `RELATION_LOST_IN_TRANSLATION`
- `TARGET_LANGUAGE_DRIFT`
`LATIN_SOURCE_PARAPHRASE_COLLAPSE`,
`TRANSLATION_BYPASSED_LATIN_PIVOT`, and
`RELATION_LOST_IN_TRANSLATION` are blocking for a stabilized multilingual
result.
## VII. Recalibration
Recalibration requires:
1. preserve the prior session and patch head;
2. identify the triggering event;
3. return affected claims to AREPO;
4. rerun only admitted OPERA modes;
5. issue a new patch with evidence and drift deltas;
6. re-evaluate expiry.
Recalibration never overwrites the historical trace.
## VIII. Expiry
Expiry triggers include:
- target work or passage changes beyond scope;
- phase, wheel, or material regime changes;
- requested telos or OPERA mode changes;
- primary source or critical edition materially changes the claim;
- confessional or historical frame changes;
- analogy direction or target changes;
- a dominant analogy is rejected;
- the session crosses from analysis to creation or from creation to analysis;
- analogical drift remains unresolved;
- Latin pivot identity, status, definition binding, or source witness changes;
- target-language rendering can no longer be collated to the admitted Latin pivot;
- topic leaves the Lullian domain;
- return remains incomplete;
- blocking drift remains unresolved;
- user or human authority revokes calibration.
Expiry result:
```text
CALIBRATIO_EXPIRY:
session_id:
trigger:
affected_scope:
retained_provenance:
removed_active_defaults:
unresolved_items:
reentry_requirements:
```
On topic exit, the medieval confessional frame, Lullian source affinities, and temporary translation conventions are removed from active state. Provenance and patch history remain as records.
## IX. Disclosure contract
SATOR must disclose:
- selected wheel and phase;
- whether AREPO admitted, qualified, blocked, or deferred the request;
- which OPERA mode was used;
- whether the Latin pivot was E0 text or a controlled paraphrase;
- the target language and any material translation delta;
- when output is reconstruction, comparison, analogy, or low confidence;
- active warnings and unresolved claims;
- recalibration or expiry when it occurs.
It must not disclose hidden chain-of-thought or claim permanent internal modification.
## X. SATOR result
```text
SATOR_LLULLIANA_RESULT:
session_id:
authorization_posture: LLULLIANA_PROVISIONAL_TEST
canonical_status: NON_CANONICAL
route:
arepo_state:
opera_mode:
class_composition_id:
resolved_class_roles:
inheritance_paths:
latin_pivot_id:
latin_pivot_status:
target_language:
retrocollation_status:
output_status:
provenance_summary:
drift_events:
patch_head:
expiry_status:
user_disclosure:
```
Provisional test-use authorization is active only for explicit
`LLULLIANA_PROVISIONAL_TEST` sessions. Canonical runtime, default activation,
deployment, mirrors, and Sigma generation remain unauthorized until a separate
human canonization decision informed by recorded real-use tests.
Actual artifact: 15_STACK_LLULLIANA/SATOR_LLULLIANA.md